4 ms·
Closeness to the water is a requirement so that if a rocket fails it doesn't land on people. And you don't want to launch to the West so that you can take ad
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
Closeness to the water is a requirement so that if a rocket fails it doesn't land on people. And you don't want to launch to the West so that you can take advantage of the Earth's rotation rather than fighting it. (Launch sites on the West coast are for polar orbits which launch either North or South).
Given those requirements, there's no location that isn't vulnerable to hurricanes. Boca Chica actually doesn't get many hurricanes compared to Florida or further North on the Texas coast.
- ericmay 6y agoThanks a lot, Bryan. I know/knew some of those things (like being close to water in general) - I guess I was concerned about how close it appeared to be :)
- ceejayoz 6y ago> Closeness to the water is a requirement so that if a rocket fails it doesn't land on people. Not if you're Russia/China. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/26/chinese-rocket-crushes-houses-after-government-warning-to-residents.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/26/chinese-rocket-crushes-house...
- nickik 6y agoChina is moving away from that as well. China did this because of the threat of capitalist invasion but the realize its dumb. Russia is a bit different and they couldn't really move it further east because it would be to far from their industrial centers. They had a hell of a time transporting the Buran system to launch already.
- asdff 6y agoCan you launch over the great lakes? Or a desert? Also, what about the east coast? Sure, there was Sandy, but it was nothing compared to what happens in the gulf with regularity. Part of my hunch is that the regulatory environment is favorable in nowhere, TX to bring in potentially polluting industry. No chance Elon could have had a launch site built on the tip of Montauk, for example, although he probably would have loved the press of him self driving from the city to there.
- ceejayoz 6y agoLaunching closer to the equator is easier. https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/36283/negative-impact-of-having-the-launch-pad-away-from-the-equator https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/36283/negative-imp...
- baking 6y agoI think they would have to fly out between Florida and Cuba on orbital flights so a little more restricted than Cape Canaveral.
- ericmay 6y agoI have to imagine one of the reasons you wouldn't launch of the Great Lakes is the absolute insane weather we get up here.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoI imagine the weather at Baikonur Kazakhstan and Vostochny Siberia is no better, and the Russians launch from there.
- ericmay 6y agoYea I'm not entirely sure. I see that Baikonur doesn't get a lot of precipitation, but that doesn't explain Amur Oblast which looks comparable to a place like Cleveland in terms of temperature and precipitation. I have to imagine that even if weather wasn't a concern (again no idea here just enjoying the discussion) - it would cost pretty much the same to build and launch from the Gulf Coast, so long as you don't get hurricane-d, and you can launch year-round (can you launch in snow?).
- Tuna-Fish 6y agoYou want to launch east to get a boost from earth's rotation, and as close to the equator as possible. Even ignoring that, the great lakes are not big enough for sufficient safety area (if that sounds preposterous, consider that Cuba, that is a thousand miles away from their launch site, actually limits available inclinations from Boca Chica), and there are no deserts in the Americas that don't have cities between them and the east coast. I get that people want to work the political angle here, but Boca Chica was definitely the best remaining place to launch rockets from continental US, no arguments from regulatory environment needed.