3 ms·
Apple may have lost the strategic battle over antitrust definition in Europe
- Terretta 6y agoRegulators removing the only choice a consumer has today for an end-to-end curated experience, a choice made by a minority of buyers, seems anti-consumer and anti-competitive given the options. Users are free to make a philosophy and convenience choice between PC and brand-designed consoles that come only with brand-curated catalogs and brand-operated stores. Consumers deal with the consequences, such as being able to have Cyberpunk 2077 from more than once source on PC, and from zero sources on Playstation. It’s unclear why users should not be free to similarly choose between Open Handset Alliance mobiles and mobiles with brand-curated catalogs and brand-operated stores. Nobody is forcing developers to support that philosophy, just as nobody forces an indie developer on Steam to land on Playstation or Xbox or vice versa. Disappointing to see this heated hue and cry where the majority want to squash the rights of the minority to have a device where everything it can do is available in a single well-curated trusted purchase and subscription place. Unsatisfied with majority share, various factions aligned around “open” are essentially trying to outlaw the commercial and market dynamics enabling the single-stop-shop console experience that a sizable but minority segment of consumers prefer even if it means they can’t have Cyberpunk.
- PoignardAzur 6y ago> But it shows that the app store liberation movement is able to build political majorities and overcome Apple and Google's counterlobbying. Leaving aside anything factual, I really hate these rhetoric tricks. We're talking about interest groups funded by corporations with incentives for some rules fighting against other interest groups funded by corporations with incentives for the opposite rules. Calling one group a "liberation movement" and the other a "lobby" feels super dishonest. This is something you often see in mainstream media too. Usually the easiest way to know which ideology a journalist is biased towards is to ask "Which side do they describe with the same lexicon they would use if they were talking about the Rebels in Star Wars vs the Empire?"
- ksec 6y agoThat is a good take. Right now I dont even want journalist to tell me what they think. I just want them to present the fact from both side and let me do the thinking. Instead they are actively shaping their readers thinking directions.
- rsj_hn 6y agoIMO we do need to change our anti-trust definition to get rid of the requirement to show consumer harm and decide that concentration, in and of itself, is against the public interest. It's hard to demonstrate consumer harm when you don't know which technologies didn't get started because of high entry costs, or because high app store gate-keeping fees. We should also discourage obtaining a monopoly as the end goal of a business. This is not to say that we should make the notion of an appstore illegal, as there is consumer benefit in a curated app store, but something like limiting fees that can be charged to a reasonable association to fees recoverable from the expense of maintain the app store infrastructure and app-review infrastructure seems like a reasonable requirement. E.g. regulate natural monopolies that cannot be broken up like utilities.