4 ms·
> What Julia could really, really benefit from though is some vocal commercial backing-had google chosen to rewrite Tensorflow in Julia I think 2 things would h
by dgellow 6y ago
> What Julia could really, really benefit from though is some vocal commercial backing-had google chosen to rewrite Tensorflow in Julia I think 2 things would have happened
We have the example of "Swift for Tensorflow", which was pitched by Google as the "next-generation platform for machine learning" (that's from their own website) and didn't result in anything meaningful and is now dead as far as I understand. I'm not that convinced that would work better with Julia.
- dunefox 6y agoThe project was pushed by Swifts creator and it failed supposedly because he left Google AFAIK, so for Julia it would most likely have worked out much better.
- FridgeSeal 6y agoAt the time they were “picking” candidates for the Tensorflow rewrite, Julia already had Flux with an early version of Zygote and was doing auto differentiation at the language level. This was literally the killer feature they wanted, and were prepared to re-wore how significant portions of the swift language and compiler functioned to get it. Had they chosen the language based on actual suitability and not because one of them was Chris Lattners pet-project, they could have automatically been significantly further ahead in far less time and energy.
- yahyaheee 6y agoYeah Google really messed this up, they had a golden opportunity and they went the wrong direction. Julia would have been better but IMO they should have just created a new language from scratch
- fishmaster 6y ago> they should have just created a new language from scratch God, please not another one with new tools, new libraries, etc.
- yahyaheee 6y agoRight because there are so many great existing options for ML
- fishmaster 6y ago... yes?
- yahyaheee 6y agoPython — no threads, or built in types Julia — odd language R — not a general purpose programming language Most of the data scientist and ml engineers I work with want a new language. So yeah it’s not a bad idea
- fishmaster 6y ago> Julia — odd language What a profound criticism. If data scientists can't use Julia then they're not great data scientists - you have RCall and PyCall, Flux, Knet, MLJ, plotting libraries, etc. It has built-in and user-defined types, threads, multiple dispatch, ... "Please don't think that Julia is only useful for 1. custom units 2. custom GPU kernels 3. Custom array types 4. custom bayesian priors. 5. AD through custom types 6. Task based parallelism 7. symbolic gradients with modeling toolkit 8. Agent based modeling 9. physics informed neural networks 10. abstract tables types ..."
- snicker7 6y ago"Pitched by Google" == pitched by one dude (Lattner), basically.
- dgellow 6y agoIf you want to be precise it would be: "Swift for Tensorflow", a project lead by Lattner, while working at Google, as part of the Tensorflow project (published on tensorflow.org and part of the tensorflow github organization, which are two official channels). Presented at Google IO 2019 [0] as "Swift for TensorFlow is a platform for the next generation of machine learning that leverages blablabla...". I stand with my "pitched by Google" :) [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fJsqGHhlVA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fJsqGHhlVA
- pjmlp 6y agoWith zero presence on the Tensorflow 2020 conference, not even an honourable mention on the overview blog post about the state of nation regarding TensorFlow.
- hnews_account_1 6y agoPython's strength is its simplified coding style. People who use these frameworks are not software engineers who want to deal with object passing mechanics in excruciating detail. There are software engineers to do just that. So until something beats Python in simplified writing style or Python becomes incredibly slow, it won't be easy to supplant.
- yahyaheee 6y agoThere are a lot of people who are somewhere in between these groups and providing a language that goes up and down the stack well would be super useful. I agree it needs to be as simple as python on the high level though, or the data science end of the spectrum will just never adopt it.
- Cullinet 6y agoforeign function interop ideally at the system (or intermediate) level does so much. before getting distracted by dot net and mono, I feel I have to lay the blame (and my nineties) at the feet of CORBA and the Object Management Group. Seriously though, what was the OMG but a UNIX consortium trying to break the hold of DEC and VMS over the most complex critical systems..
- hnews_account_1 6y agoThat is currently a non issue since software is lagging hardware. So you can join 2 systems together fairly inefficiently and still make a go of it. Sure, a good language for people down the stack can topple python from the top, but it won't be easy. It'd be far easier if we were approaching software limits on current hardware and needed to pull everything into one language and system to make it work together.
- yahyaheee 6y agoIts useful for ML in that it requires so much optimization, that being about to drop down in the same language is incredibly handy. For ML software isn't lagging hardware its the other way around.