4 ms·
It's also an average, someone like Bezos technically raises the average by a lot. It just doesn't make the people working in a warehouse any richer. For the va
by mrweasel 6y ago
It's also an average, someone like Bezos technically raises the average by a lot. It just doesn't make the people working in a warehouse any richer.
For the vast majority of people, living in a wealthy country, where that wealth is more equally distributed, will be much more attractive than living in country with just a high GDP.
- jaspax 6y agoI don't think that Bezos, as an individual, has any measurable impact on the US's GDP. The headline number for Bezos is his fortune of $190B, but that's the total value of his assets, not his yearly income. Furthermore, GDP primarily measures spending, not wealth, and I would be surprised if Bezos actually spent even $1B per annum (though this might be different depending on what exactly we count as "spending", as he might make stock trades in that range). In either case, he's having a very small impact on the measured GDP of $21T, something in the range of 0.01%. Meanwhile, the difference between the US and Europe in the article is around $10K per person--hundreds of times larger than the distortion created by the billionaires.
- antwerpz 6y agoGDP measures income, not spending. If someone outside the US spends money on Amazon, and a portion of that money becomes part of Bezos' income, that portion is counted in the US GDP, not the foreign country's GDP. His income last year was around $60 billion, or $200 per person (of any age) in the United States. While last year was exceptional, all of his wealth ($600 per capita) was income in the last 20 or so years, most of it in the last 10. And his ex-wife Mackenzie Scott kept 25% of their combined wealth when they separated. So it's simply not true that his contribution to GDP looks completely trivial even when compared to total US GDP.
- jaspax 6y agoEvery source that I can find says that US calculates its GDP based on the "expenditure" approach, meaning that it measures spending, not income. Eg: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/gdp.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/gdp.asp Secondarily, capital gains is not really the same thing as income (at least, not in the tax code, and also not in GDP calculations), and most of his $60B "income" is increases in Amazon stock price. And even if it were actual cash income, the GDP difference between the US and Europe is still fifty times larger than that. Look: I was an American by birth, but I moved to Europe as an adult. I get the attraction, and I'm not trying to bag on Europe. But it's simply false to suggest that America is not overall richer than Europe, or to say that America's extra riches are all concentrated at the top.
- antwerpz 6y agoYou're confused about how GDP is calculated. The GDP difference between the US and Europe is fifty times larger than one rich person's own income? This isn't actually a great argument dismissing the suggestion that US wealth is extremely concentrated.
- dsnr 6y ago> His income last year was around $60 billion Are you really counting the increase of Amazon stock price as his personal income? This is totally inaccurate. Most of that worth is extremely volatile and can quickly dissipate if the stock price falls for whatever reason. Would you count a falling stock price as spending?
- antwerpz 6y agoI don't think you read the whole of my comment. Amazon aggressively reinvests its extremely large and stable earnings into the business which Bezos owns a large part of and controls actively. Both he and his ex-wife have realized extremely important liquid wealth by selling a significant part of their stakes. How would you measure his wealth?
- pwinnski 6y agoOne way might be measure his total net worth last year vs this year. You'd be subject to the vagaries of the stock market that way, but given that most of his wealth is paper wealth, that seems fair. Certainly Amazon revenue is not the best way.
- dsnr 6y agoI read your whole comment and am very interested in seeing a source for how Bezos earned $60 billion last year as private taxable income. The fact that amazon (not even Bezos) re-invests a large part of the corporate income has nothing to do with distorting the US GDP per capita, as you claim. I would like to see a more solid argument.
- emilsedgh 6y agoExactly for that reason, I wish it was a median not average.
- kzrdude 6y agoGDP is not computed from anything that's split on individuals, GDP median over people does unfortunately not make sense. (Not in the way that median disposable income would, for example).
- throwaway210222 6y agoGDP isn't even measured in the same way in different countries. 1. The USA gifts itself > $6 trillion in imputed values. Or about the GDP of Japan; 2. If China measured their GDP using the formula used by India, its economy would be significantly larger; 3. Nigeria overtook South Africa literally overnight by changing (amongst other things) the value of unpaid child care. Its largely are ruse to make public debt look sustainable.
- wwtrv 6y agoTo be fair, if we’re talking about wealth distribution (as opposed to income distribution) many European countries have similar inequality to the US. Some, like Sweden for instance, are even worse than the US. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_equality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_...
- tokai 6y agoSo Russia is the second most equal country after the Netherlands, and Brazil more equal than Denmark? I'm not buying that data.
- Paradigma11 6y agoThere are not enough oligarchs to make an impact.
- zzzpaz 6y agoYou're reading that the opposite way. > A Gini coefficient of zero expresses perfect equality, where all values are the same (for example, where everyone has the same income). A Gini coefficient of one (or 100%) expresses maximal inequality among values Was easy to spot, US and Russia are definitely not at the top when it comes to income equality as both are controlled by oligarchy
- mrweasel 6y agoEveryone could be equally poor.
- mrweasel 6y agoI honestly had no idea. That's pretty interesting, I wonder if it's because of a few REALLY wealthy individuals? Generally you have a lower limit to how poor a person can be, in Scandinavia that limit is reasonably high (I sure it doesn't feel that way if you're actually poor), so I would have assumed that would level out the inequality somewhat. Denmark in particular have also always excluded students from statistics on who's poor, because it's seen a temporary thing. So we don't see them as truly poor, even if they often are, but I suspect that they have to be included in the Gini coefficients calculation.