5 ms·
Can someone remind me why, today, any company would ever choose to IPO instead of direct list? IPO means paying a ton of money to bankers, as well as leaving t
by crazygringo 6y ago
Can someone remind me why, today, any company would ever choose to IPO instead of direct list?
IPO means paying a ton of money to bankers, as well as leaving tons of money on the table if/when the stock "pops".
Especially now that, since December if I understand correctly, companies can now sell additional shares at the moment of the direct listing, which apparently used to not be allowed.
And then the idea that an IPO comes with guaranteed buyers hardly seems necessary in today's high-frequency high-liquidity age of trading. Plus, surely a ton of employees and investors will want to at least partially cash out from the first millisecond if the price is right, so supply will be there.
Am I missing something?
- jariel 6y agoBecause nobody knows anything about most companies and when they 'go public' nobody will buy their shares. The classical IPO process involves a road-show where the banks take the CFO/CEO to institutional buyers they line up ahead of time, they work out a price agree to buy shares ahead of time for a set price. The process is underwitten by a bank(s) who buy the shares ahead of time for a set price thereby providing certain guarantees. This notion of 'leaving money on the table when the stock pops' is just frothy hubris: the stock could equally flop, moreover, if somehow every share were sold first thing in the morning - a 'stock pop' would not benefit the company directly anyhow - the stocks will have been sold. An IPO is a big fat financial service offered by the banks, for most companies that's the path to market. Avoiding it would probably require a big brand name company with a lot of recognition, probably a very big price. Even then it's risky.
- darkwizard42 6y agoTLDR: banks take on some financial risk and offer advisement on price and inside access to capital rich accounts that would buy the shares; potentially less risky than going out on the open market alone where if no one knows who you are or aren't advised by a bank to buy your stock, they simply won't Banks do take on the risk to buy* the shares if for some reason the public market doesn't like the listing price or the interest isn't there. Sometimes they just put forth "best effort" and their role is to give inside preference/hype up shares to their large institutional customers to buy the IPO shares. They do the "pricing" of the IPO which sets the shares at a level where there is sufficient interest to sell the public offering of shares but also don't want it to pop too much because the company loses out on raising capital. However, given the inflation in the market and general hype around a lot of these companies with good growth (and some kind of path to profitability) I don't see how the bank really does anything other than what you say...take money away from the company and the whole pay for access to investors thing doesn't matter anymore. *I don't think this is always the case, but used to be in some IPOs
- neximo64 6y agoAn IPO is 2 things: 1) Transferring ownership from existing investors to new investors 2) Raising capital. You can't really do 2 with a direct listing. Companies IPO mostly because they need money not because investors want liquidity
- nemothekid 6y agoI'm not sure how you cannot do (2) with a direct listing. The company can just issue new shares to sell on the direct listing, no differently than issues new shares in a new fundraising round
- bradleyjg 6y agoHave there been any of these direct listings with share sales yet?
- neximo64 6y agoI'm not entirely sure how that's possible. If you knew stock was being sold in significant quantities (~10-20% of the company) in extremely short periods of time its almost a guarantee the price will drop on listing day. Previous direct listings have all been about transfer of ownership.
- Retric 6y ago