5 ms·
The Six-Lesson Schoolteacher, by John Taylor Gatto (1991)
- a9h74j 6y ago'Classroom' does have 'class' at its root.
- schoen 6y agoRight, because students were historically separated into groups by ... age?
- fludlight 6y ago...and zip code, which is very correlated with parental income, occupation, and education level
- ncmncm 6y agoMy father went to one of the last of the one-room schools, in eastern Washington state. He said about a quarter of the class would be listening to lessons at any time, the rest doing assignments or, if they had finished, a project chosen from the Book of Knowledge, an encyclopedia geared for that, that all such schools had; or, helping younger kids with their work. The faster younger kids sat in lessons with the slower older ones. They all overheard lessons taught to older kids before they got there themselves. Separating kids by age is historically new, harmful, and weird. Traditionally, younger learned from older, who learned better by needing to teach. The experience of teaching might be our greatest loss.
- 8bitsrule 6y ago>I never lie outright, but I've come to see that truth and [school]teaching are incompatible.
- kiba 6y agoOn the contrary, I would contend that there is real knowledge being taught in schools. But I do concede that it is being taught in suboptimal ways. School is draining and somehow unfun and that makes it difficult to learn.
- ggm 6y agoTerry Pratchett had "lies to children" -useful short circuits against the truth to get a pedagogical goal, like "triangles add up to 180" (not true on a curved or complex surface) Robert M. Pirsig would have been in the same head-space as this author.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIt's called "plane geometry" for a reason. You don't have to preface every proof for the entire semester with "now this only is true on a flat surface..."
- darepublic 6y agodon't have to preface every proof with it, but stating it at least once would be helpful
- Spooky23 6y agoHaven’t we learned by now that the “I have the secret of X that only I can tell you” is almost always bullshit. Yes, ideally a kid will learn basic stuff in 50 hours. What happens when he doesn’t? My son is a super smart kid, way smarter than I am. But he struggled to read at first... his teacher helped him immensely with different strategies to get him on the reading train. Now, we can’t get him to put books down. The Gatto stuff is appealing but relies on a false assumptions. There was never a time when we were all yeoman farmers reading great literature on our own or in self organized study groups. There was never a time where every kid had the family life they deserved, with enough food, present parents, nobody struggling with drugs or alcohol, etc. Gatto has good points, but frames them in fantastical bullshit.
- whatshisface 6y agoDo we have to put the kids that learn all of elementary school in 50 hours through the exact same process we put the ones that can't through?
- nullserver 6y agoHomeschool.
- Meekro 6y agoGatto's book Dumbing Us Down expands on the ideas of this essay and argues his side quite effectively. His ideas are based on his multiple decades as a successful schoolteacher and are well-supported by history. You don't have to agree with them, but you seem to be dismissing them too quickly and casually. For example, here's a quote from Dumbing Us Down that I found persuasive: "We had school, but not too much of it, and only as much as an individual wanted. People learned to read, write, and do arithmetic just fine anyway; there are some studies that suggest literacy at the time of the American Revolution, at least for non-slaves on the Eastern seaboard, was close to total. Thomas Paine's Common Sense sold 600,000 copies to a population of 3,000,000, twenty percent of whom were slaves, and fifty percent indentured servants."
- 6y ago
- frEdmbx 6y agoJohn Taylor Gatto: The Underground History of American Education https://schoolsucksproject.com/john-taylor-gatto/ https://schoolsucksproject.com/john-taylor-gatto/
- xbar 6y agoThanks for sharing. Here's a horror: No Child Left Behind and it's progeny, Common Core, have maximized standardization of the curriculum component, starving teachers and institutions of funding and flexibility of time to offer any form of education for students who would benefit from it. Gatto is right--our system is a machine. And it produces quite a bit of literacy at low cost to the people who need it. It also fails to solve problems that it could.