3 ms·
Just because other humans created the knowledge in question, doesn't make the search for that knowledge not research, if the knowledge isn't held by the general
by monocasa 6y ago
Just because other humans created the knowledge in question, doesn't make the search for that knowledge not research, if the knowledge isn't held by the general public in the first place, and if that knowledge requires independent gathering of data and interpretation to acquire.
I agree that Apple and the quirks in our society that encourage that secretive behavior has the effect of researchers independently replicating a small subset of Apple's work in a way that they'd be redirected to something more useful in a more open society. That doesn't make the independent researcher's work not research though.
Otherwise nearly the whole field of anthropology wouldn't exist or wouldn't be considered research.
> Lumping them together just cements the idea that the systems we built and navigate, for better or worse, are to be treated like natural laws that can't be argued with.
The systems we have built are pretty fixed in time. We can argue about how to change them going in the future, but we should also record, externally if need be like here, what has happened so that we can make better decisions going forward. Apple's choices for the M1 are arguably more set in stone than our conception of physics. We're able to retcon all of physics when we make changes to the standard model, but "what tradeoffs did Apple make in the M1" are pretty much done and set in stone (or silicon I guess).