4 ms·
I couldn't get the article, and finally I went to http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:blogs.gnome.org/mccann/2011/06/08/new-pony/&hl=en&client=
by btilly 15y ago
I couldn't get the article, and finally I went to http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:blogs.gnome.org/mccann/2011/06/08/new-pony/&hl=en&client=firefox-a&hs=Md4&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&biw=989&bih=703&strip=1 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:blogs.g... for Google's text-only cached version.
There is a very simple reason why this is true. Usability researchers have known and repeatedly verified for at least 20 years that regular users simply don't "get" directory trees. They don't understand the idea of directories within directories within directories with files scattered at all levels, and the same file possibly being in multiple places and each copy being potentially different.
We're not talking illiterates. We're talking about college graduates who have used computers for years but simply don't understand this basic concept. And if you try to explain it to them you'll hit a blank wall.
You can know one of these for a long time without noticing this lack of knowledge. They will successfully use files that are in a directory system. But when you dig deeper you realize that they have memorized actions. "I click on this icon, and search for my file." "Wouldn't it be nicer if you organized your files into folders?" "You can put folders into that icon???"
It is a surprise the first time you realize that someone you know, who is not an obvious moron, really doesn't understand the idea of a directory structure. And it is a surreal experience to try to explain it and fail. It is doubly surreal because everyone who actually works with software has to understand this point so you lose track of the fact that some don't. It can be hard to believe that these people exist. But they do and they are in the majority.
This is a huge problem for anyone writing consumer software. It may make your software more flexible, but as soon as you expose the filesystem to regular users, your software is not going to be user friendly. Therefore popular applications like iTunes go out of their way to hide the existence of the filesystem from users.
(And since everyone does that, people have no reason to learn to understand the filesystem, and the cycle repeats...)
- chadgeidel 15y agoI agree. It's time we (as "computer people") stopped putting the onus on the users to figure out "our way", and start taking some responsibility to build solutions that work without a scientific or engineering degree to understand.
- dman 15y agoI think that movement is well underway with the iphone, ipad, unity (ubuntu) and gnome3.
- sudont 15y agoAs someone who's taught educational technology as a sort-of TA in college, I've seen this, and something a bit similar: folders, but not well organized. If it's more than one deep, it's lost. Same thing with my parents. But really, are they wrong? With spotlight on my Mac, and Google Desktop on my PC, I can move files to a "files" folder and search away, without all the "uber micro" that some nerds seem to require.