3 ms·
A number of these things are just good general advice. Others a bit less so. The explainer on "focus on getting the 'right' answer" (page 65) is actually prett
by arp242 6y ago
A number of these things are just good general advice. Others a bit less so.
The explainer on "focus on getting the 'right' answer" (page 65) is actually pretty okay. For example it encourages to "Engage with true problem solving" such as "What are some strategies we can use to engage with this problem?". That seems pretty good to me. It goes on to say that "teaching math isn't just about solving specific problems. It's about helping students understand the deeper mathematical concepts so that they can apply them throughout their lives". Again, this seems fairly on-point to me for middle/high-school math.
People seem to have taken this part in particular a bit out of context and ran with it. They mostly mean "having students than semi-mindlessly solve equations to get the right answer isn't really teaching them all that much about math". I think most here would agree with that.
I find the explainer for "Independent practice is valued over teamwork or collaboration" (page 61) really weird though: "it reinforces individualism and the notion that I’m the only one. This does not give value to collectivism and community understanding, and fosters conditions for competition and individual success". At some earlier point there was also a swipe against "capitalism".
Overall, I found it mostly good with some bad mixed in.
But ... I'm from a region in the Netherlands with a fairly homogeneous white population, and attended a school where almost everyone was white; my class certainly was. I can confidently say my math classes sucked, for quite a number of the reasons listed in that article.
But was this because of "white supremacy culture"? I don't think so. That seems like a really narrow view on things. Sometimes bad teaching is exactly that: bad teaching. Nothing more, nothing less.
- lowercased 6y agoI'd initially missed 'explainer' pages - I was clicking what looked like links, but they weren't initially working. Even after reading some of these pages, things still don't make much sense. If there's a link to 'racism', I'm still not seeing it. Another weird one was "teachers enculturated in the USA teach math the way they were taught math". But... I was under the impression that we'd been using 'common core' stuff for the past 10+ years, and a big complaint is that teachers can't teach it because it's not how they learned. Very little of these explainers seem to make any attempt to connect the racism angle, which is disappointing. As you pointed out, bad teaching can just be bad teaching, and doesn't have to have any other explanation. A few others I saw: "Have students create mathematical definitions in their own words in groups, and bring the groups together to co-construct mathematical definitions as a class." Unless there are agreed-on definitions up front, how would you determine if anyone is correct or not? "Let’s get into partners and do a thinkpair-share. We will incorporate everyone’s ideas and try to synthesize them." I had 'group work' 30+ years ago. It sucked. It assumes that everyone even cares, or cares enough at the same level. "How do I dismantle power structures in the classroom?" Classroom Activity: Flipped learning, where students teach concepts to other students. That's just creating other power structures.
- temp8964 6y agoThe good things you found in there have nothing to do with race. Also they are well known in math education. It's not like the authors discovered / created those pedagogical insights. They are using those pedagogical insights to push their political agenda.