3 ms·
> Margolis said that gasoline’s physical composition—it sinks to the bottom of bodies of water, unlike oil, which stays slick on top This doesn’t match my expe
by sokoloff 6y ago
> Margolis said that gasoline’s physical composition—it sinks to the bottom of bodies of water, unlike oil, which stays slick on top
This doesn’t match my experience where water contamination in pure gasoline very quickly settles to the bottom of a test jar and where gasoline spilled while boat fueling clearly floats on water.
Gasoline is around 6 lbs/gallon and water a bit over 8 lbs/gallon. I don’t see how gasoline could sink given those wide disparities in density.
- Pfhreak 6y agoMaybe the gasoline contains ethanol and it formed some compounds when exposed to the environmental moisture?
- sokoloff 6y agoEthanol doctoring of the fuel (whether E10 or E85) typically happens at the wholesale terminal, after the pipeline transportation.
- jackfoxy 6y agoWithout more clarification this appears to be nonsense. Do any search for gasoline floats on water and every explanation says gasoline floats on water, not the other way around. If there is any hope in this disaster it is that interstate pipelines transport raw gasoline (more or less a natural fraction of petroleum) without the additives. It is the additives like MTBE (now I believe outlawed) that create the most lasting ground pollution. Light petroleum fractions naturally migrate towards the surface, where they are either consumed by microbes that eat the light fractions (and leave the heaviest fractions) or they evaporate.
- markbnj 6y agoAgreed. The statement also caught my eye and the only thing I could find that seems even remotely relevant is http://www.earthdrx.org/specificgravitylesser.html http://www.earthdrx.org/specificgravitylesser.html. This is very specific to lighter fluids injected into a subsurface ground layer below a water layer, and theorizes as to why the lighter fluid may not percolate through the heavier fluid above.
- fuzzfactor 6y agoActually the MTBE was simply more easily detected by smell if the groundwater had come from a source where underground retail storage tanks had leaked MTBE-oxygenated gasoline. The portion of the fuel which does not evaporate can sink with gravity until it rests upon a water table within range. The vast majority of the wells contaminated by leaking gasoline went largely undetected until MTBE was widely introduced to gasoline according to the Clean Air Act of 1990. When compromised retail tanks in use started to recieve gas containing MTBE, it still took a while to seep down into some people's water just like the plain gasoline had been doing, before they started to notice since the MTBE has a characteristic non-hydrocarbon smell of an ether. MTBE itself is far less toxic than the hydrocarbons it had replaced in the fuel. Technically, by experts not considered dangerous to health in the trace amounts found in the contaminated water, just bad taste. Physicians have treated patients using pure MTBE with therapeutic effect, with side-effects that would be expected also from the more traditional USP Ethyl Ether. https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/MTBE https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/MTBE The natural components of gasoline like the benzene are recognized as far worse but they are not so easy to taste.
- Robotbeat 6y agoYup. It’s actually opposite of what he (the attorney) said. Gasoline (with a density of 0.72kg per liter) floats, and in fact it also evaporates. Which makes it partially self-cleaning (although there always seems to be some residue...). Not that gasoline vapors are great, but the local environmental problem could in principle be less than for an oil spill as oil is almost identical in density with water (light crude oil floats on water and heavy crude oil, like tar sands oil, sinks in water... although both tend to have both lighter and heavier components so both things happen).
- fuzzfactor 6y agoThat's right, gasoline has always floated on water. Mostly it evaporates but it still toxifies the water for a period of time. Gasoline is not the only thing going through Colonial: https://colpipe.s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/media/6.4.4-cpc-product-specifications-december-2018.pdf https://colpipe.s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/media/6.4.4-cpc-p... All are consumer products also preferred by military operators. It can be noted that the two cleanest fuels on the list, butane and R100 renewable diesel, are not like the others. Butane is never transported along any of the main lines, and at this time R100 still exists only on paperwork.
- Judgmentality 6y agoBut if the gasoline evaporates, doesn't it just rain down again later? It still has to go somewhere. Or do we just have ever-increasing gasoline clouds? EDIT: Thank you to everyone for the informative responses.
- fuzzfactor 6y ago>do we just have ever-increasing gasoline clouds? Well, not quite. It does remain in the atmosphere as it dissipates and is diluted, but the whole time even at the source its concentration is usually too low to condense. It just becomes air pollution, categorized as Air Toxics although some of the same natural hydrocarbons are referred to as "Unburned Hydrocarbons" when they are emitted after incomplete automotive combustion.
- 6y ago
- snicker7 6y agoIt's easier to float in salt water.
- sokoloff 6y agoIndeed and noticeably so. Salt water is 2-3% more dense than fresh water. That’s all the more reason to think that ~28% less dense gasoline would float.