3 ms·
Well, for starters people will at least have the option to earn an income without ads. Right now this can be pretty tricky, depending on the type of site you ru
by arp242 6y ago
Well, for starters people will at least have the option to earn an income without ads. Right now this can be pretty tricky, depending on the type of site you run.
I've been working on a recipe website for a while; it's a slow burner project. I have a bunch of feature/UX ideas that I think will improve things a lot, and I also want a site that's not full of nonsense like ads and "oh, you scrolled to see the actual recipe description HAHA FUCK YOU, here's a newsletter popup first instead" and "allow us to send you our fucking notifications" popups and whatnot. It's always hard to be sure, but overall I think it would be pretty viable business.
But ... how do you monetize this without ads? Ask for donations? Things like Patreon have made this more common in the last few years and it could work, but it sure is starting a business on hard mode. The easier all of this becomes, the better there's a chance that a viable sustainable alternative will even exist in the first place.
A big reason why this is a slow burner project is because I just don't rate the chances of actually earning significant amount of money with this in 2-3 years as very high unless I resort to adding ads (and my bar for "signifiant" is really low by the way, maybe €1000/month of turnover). Even though this is very much a project that I built purely because it's the kind if site I want to use myself, it's just really hard to justify spending a lot of time on this right now in the current "internet economy".
So in short: no, it won't guarantee anything, but it does open up new possibilities.
- lupire 6y agoHow much time are you investing for €1000/mo goal? That seems high for a slow burn recipe site which is a commodity.
- arp242 6y agoI worked on it for about 2 months full-time two years ago, but this was after a burn-out where I really needed to rediscover my joy in programming, which I did through this project so I got a lot of value out of it already in a way :-) Since then I've worked on it on the odd Sunday every once in a while, not all that much really. While it's an interesting prototype right now, actually finishing it will be quite a lot more work as there are some technical challenges remaining in the way I want to do things. Half a year at least, but let's round that up to 10 months because I'm probably underestimating things. If we consider a monthly salary of €3,000 (pretty low for a senior dev) then I'll spend €36k on building the thing, a further €36k building up revenue, so it'll me 6 years to recoup this investment with €1,000/month. In short, I don't think €1,000/month is very high at all. And this doesn't account for any marketing or other costs. Actually building a platform is one thing, but getting useful content (in this case, recipes) is another. Simply copying existing content would be pointless, so this requires further investment. Of course, the "start-up way" to do this is to find some investor who will give you money, but that investor will expect a return on their investment (which is reasonable enough) and it means I will need to maximize profit and it'll be like all the other sites that I mentioned before. What I really want is a site built by someone who likes cooking for other people who like cooking. I think the world would be better if it's easier to build something like this while still earning a reasonable amount of money (and €1,000 is very much on the low end of that IMO). As for "being a commodity", sure. But in my opinion a lot of them aren't very good for various reasons, and I think it can be a lot better.
- bombcar 6y agoIt sounds like you want a forum/community with a recipe database attached. Which is probably what you’d need to do to get traction- those who are googling “how to cook bacon” will always hit the ad-spam sites first. A forum for cooking that’s well done (harhar) enough to get 100 people to pay $10 a month to support seems possible - but you might need to enlist a YouTube celebrity cook to get it started. Try a partnership?
- arp242 6y agoNo, not at all. There are actually no "community" features at all. It's just a better recipe website. No bullshit. >99% of people never engage in those kind of things at all. I feel most community features on sites are either pointless or actively harmful. People just want something nice to cook tonight, and there are plenty of community spaces for amateur cooks already that do a fine job. I don't think you need to be a UX genius to realize that you can do better than [1] (load without adblocker for the full experience). The ridiculous space devoted to ads and popups is the most striking, but hardly the only thing: there are so many things that can be improved on that page if you just spent some effort and brainpower on it. Sometimes I wonder if the designers of those sites ever used it themselves. AllRecipes is hardly the exception; most sites are like this. This is just the biggest one. [1]: https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/214931/oven-roasted-asparagus/ https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/214931/oven-roasted-aspara...
- scrollaway 6y agoMake a patreon. If you're involved with a community (doesn't have to be on the site, can be a parallel cooking discord), you will have plenty of opportunities to monetize via that route and make a good living with it. Patron-only exclusives such as blog posts once in a while can help immensely to make users feel good about donating money to you -- makes them feel like they got good value out of it. Exclusives could be something cooking themed, and maybe featuring patron submissions (recipe submissions) on your site sometimes. Email me if you want to chat about this. Good luck otherwise.
- jimmaswell 6y agoI think it could work if web browsers standardized on some crypto to mine, maybe one like Ethereum where you can pay for distributed code to be run, and you could easily give some to websites you visit.
- mvanbaak 6y ago> But ... how do you monetize this without ads? Make something that people want instead of doi g the same as 163648462 others? There was a time where you earned money if you added something to the mix
- arp242 6y agoThat sounds great, and that's my plan exactly, but "free" is a great feature that's hard to compete against. People don't make rational decisions about these sort of things. I don't make rational decisions about these sort of things either. Although I try to be a bit thoughtful and rational about this, I've noticed I've spent ridiculous amounts of time to avoid fairly small charges, especially before I realized this and started paying attention to this. Point in case: half the articles posted to HN from medium.com have complaints about their (ad-free) monetization strategy. From what I can tell, Medium is not even profitable either; they're doing their best to find something that works without plastering every article full of ads, but thus far haven't found it yet. Even Twitter has the same problem: they've got some ads but unlike e.g. Facebook it's not full of them, and they're not profitable either.
- jart 6y agoMedium could squeeze all the blog posts in the world and it still wouldn't be enough to pay rent for its eighty-five San Francisco employees. Hosting documents is so costly that we've come to sympathize with platforms like paupers and where that leaves humble content creators such as myself I don't know.
- arp242 6y agoApparently Medium seems to provide value to people writing articles. I don't really understand the appeal myself either, but who am I to argue with other people's software choices? shrug