3 ms·
> What guarantee is there that this will reduce ads in any way? None, of course. It's possible to disable ads for users with Web Monetization, but it's also po
by sofixa 6y ago
> What guarantee is there that this will reduce ads in any way?
None, of course. It's possible to disable ads for users with Web Monetization, but it's also possible to be greedy and use both at the same time. But remember, we're not talking about big companies or anything of the sort, it's more for small scale personal blogs, or, as i pointed out, institutions like the Internet Archive or Wikipedia, so greed is IMHO unlikely and will probably be rare.
In any case, if you use an ad blocker, which you absolutely should, the ads don't impact you.
- paulryanrogers 6y ago> In any case, if you use an ad blocker, which you absolutely should... Why should everyone block the lowest friction way to pay creators? Besides the security argument which speaks more to JS, IMO.
- sofixa 6y agoBecause ads are obnoxious and privacy nightmares, and also security risks. You can just disable JS and third-party cookies, but that might break some websites ( and that number will only increase due to the proliferation of SPAs and fancy frontend frameworks). IMHO setting up ads on your website is higher friction that web monetization is.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- c22 6y agoI've actually noticed a bit of a reversal in JS requiring trends over the last year or two. Of course there are still plenty of lazy product landing pages and wordpress blogs that don't work without JS and any time I see a hamburger menu I know I'll be navigating the site 'manually'. But many of the bigger news and information sites that used to deliver a blank page at least now deliver some bastardized version of their text content (though usually not their images).
- lupire 6y agoThe friction of ads is huge, and you pay it when you see them (interupton, distraction, stress, page experience, malware risk), and when you buy things there's a cut that goes to the value-destroying ad/adtech industry. Web monetization is lower friction.
- wongarsu 6y agoSmall scale personal blogs cost next to nothing (as in: reasonable web hosting packets for $2/year exist), why would they need ads? Wikipedia on the other hand makes lots of money with one of the most obtrusive ads on the internet (giant banner that slowly rolls down stating some variant of "if everyone donates just $5 we can stop annoying you right now"). But despite getting more and more donations every year they don't make the ad less annoying or run it shorter. So I have zero confidence that giving them another revenue stream will help
- wpietri 6y agoHosting doesn't cost much. Content production isn't free.
- tubularhells 6y agoIt is free for wikipedia.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoTwitter is worth and spends billions but wikipedia should run on fumes? Are people here collectively insane?
- remram 6y agoPeople here hold multiple opinions because there are multiple people here, not because the single mind they share is insane.
- wpietri 6y agoThe content production still isn't free; other people just bear the costs.
- 6y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> Wikipedia If I remember, Wikipedia is rather controversial, for having a ginormous war chest, but still having PBS-style begfests all the time. I don't think they do any ads, now, except for their begging headers.
- lupire 6y agoWikipedia asks for money once a year. They have a ginormous war chest because they do unmatched incredibly good work for the whole world and don't waste too much of the money, despite all the nitpickers.
- Macha 6y agoNo, they have a ginormous war chest because their increasingly intrusive advertising campaigns convince people that the operational costs of wikipedia.org are unsustainable otherwise, and this has so far kept ahead of their also massively inflating expenditure: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_Cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_C...
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago90 million a year is an inflated expenditure for the most productice website to ever exist? Its an absolute pittance, that the turnover of a midsized bakery chain! Would you care to backup this outrageous claim by demonstrating similarly popular website, awash with content, that spends less?
- Macha 6y agoThe running costs of the site are 2.5 million/year per their own financial reports: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/3/31/Wikimedia_Foundation_Audit_Report_-_FY18-19.pdf https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/3/31/Wikim... Staff expenses are harder to break down, as they don't break out who's working on e.g. wikipedia development and funding and who's working on, e.g. the social movement strategy, which is allocated approximately the same budget as running wikipedia.org: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Strategy/Wikimedia_movement/2017/Frequently_asked_questions#Why_will_it_require_up_to_US$2.5_million_to_develop_a_movement_strategy https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Strategy/Wikimedia_movement/...? But from just the information they provided us, can you give a reason why Wikipedia in 2019 would need 33% more staff expenditure than 2018 for running the site? And similar increases in the years leading up to that?
- BelenusMordred 6y ago> In any case, if you use an ad blocker, which you absolutely should, the ads don't impact you. If everyone used an adblocker it would definitely impact you. So while I agree with the vibe and block for convenience along with security, it's an uneasy feeling knowing that such benefits for me only exist because many others aren't taking advantage of content creators like this.
- II2II 6y ago> If everyone used an adblocker it would definitely impact you. Sure, but would the impact be positive or negative? While some people rightfully ask to be compensated for high quality content, money also encourages many more people to contribute to the glut of low value, derivative, and outright plagiarized content.
- sn_master 6y agoyup, anytime you lookup for something on youtube, the top results are full of lame, short and sponsorship-packed animated Wikipedia summaries often with mismatching theme music because they don't want to read a book, license footage or even proper music. web is the same. tons of lazy blogs copy pasting without any effort in understanding or explaining from a different angle.
- BelenusMordred 6y ago> would the impact be positive or negative? That's a fair question and not sure I have the answer to it other than stating a personal preference. Much smarter people than me have been trying to solve this content conundrum for decades now and it doesn't seem like anyone has found something workable for all parties involved. It's a bitter pill to swallow that maybe what exists now is the best system we have and it will be around for a long time going forward.
- ineedasername 6y agoIn any case, if you use an ad blocker, which you absolutely should, the ads don't impact you That is already the status quo. The entire premise of this article is that web monetization will reduce the actual ads. It changes nothing if I still have to use my ad blocker. I don't think and but avery small minority of content creators will actually reduce their ads, and these might in any case be the people who are already very conscious of and respectfully of their consumers' privacy.