4 ms·
> Evaluating the capabilities of NFTs against the value offerings of something like rare art is an apples to oranges comparison. Someone should tell that to al
by smt88 6y ago
> Evaluating the capabilities of NFTs against the value offerings of something like rare art is an apples to oranges comparison.
Someone should tell that to all the artists who are selling NFTs with the implication that they're analogous to owning original works.
I agree that it's apples-to-oranges, which is why so many people are appalled at the charlatans who are successfully selling these oranges as apples.
> It turns the conventional model of third-party hosted digital assets on its head
How so? The assets that are "sold" as NFT are still hosted somewhere.
Owning the NFT for something does nothing more than copyright already does. You can store the digital asset on your computer with or without the NFT. You can "consume" it either way as well.
So what if the digital asset is an item in a video game? The game can check to make sure you own it before you use it!
Yes, it can. But the creator of that game can also choose not to do that, just as anyone can choose not to respect copyright.
> I mean to acknowledge its limitations and its potential at the same time
What is its potential? What can someone do with NFTs that they couldn't do before?
- TheColorYellow 6y ago> What is its potential? What can someone do with NFTs that they couldn't do before? The novelty comes from the underlying protocols that back the NFT. These protocols create marketplaces that are widely available and accessible and are reliably secure and robust. Take copyright for example. Copyright laws vary across regions and marketplace. The encoding and repudiation of these copyright laws is based on analog processes. The data related to the assets in question are stored in databases with a widely varying degree of access. Verifiability across assets or even within a single asset class varies and to varying degrees of reliability. And I'm not saying this to point out that copyright laws and the assets relying on them have failed or are not value add in many ways. The fundamental point is that the technological infrastructure underlying the use of copyright laws today has a lot to be desired when it applies to ease of use for digital media. Networks using blockchain protocols can offer a natively digital infrastructure solution that helps extend or replicate the value offered by something like copyright law. The natively digital aspect enables broader interaction which engenders more general purpose usage which ultimately leads to new consumer models (i.e. direct artist to consumer, peer to peer, etc.). > Owning the NFT for something does nothing more than copyright already does. You can store the digital asset on your computer with or without the NFT. You can "consume" it either way as well. The point is not to displace copyright law)(although others may argue this I do not). The value add here is in creating a widely accessible and reliable digital mechanism for creating, expressing, and modifying ownership rights. Different, or maybe even traditional, consumption models are then built on top of this to capture this value. To your point about gaming creators choosing to do so or not; this question is really a question about what is the value of blockchain protocol networks in the first place and how would someone like a game creator benefit or capture this value? To this point, I can only point out the potential benefits as I'll be the first to agree the nature of blockchain and its value is still being explored. My arguments above are trying to express the value as I see it. Would be curious to hear more thoughts and criticism.
- wokwokwok 6y agoThe point you’re making is valid, but you’re side stepping the key concern being raised. The tokens you acquire are worth nothing. Nothing about owning a token grants you any rights to anything other than what some other person is willing to pay/exchange it for. So if a game developer chooses to accept tokens, you can use them; but that developer can at any time choose to stop accepting tokens or a subset of tokens making what you own worth actually nothing. Now... for a regulated system of tokens (eg currency) a developer can’t do that: they are legally bound to accept fiat currency even though it is not redeemable for any “real” equivalent (eg gold). Since a token is not bound to the DRM access to an item (say, image for example), it’s totally pointless to asset ownership with it, because it does not prevent the copy of the original digital asset. The best you could ever hope for would be a regulated system, in which access to an asset via DRM was granted by a token. ...at which point, any “decentralised” benefit is lost. So ultimately, the risk is 100% on the buyer here. What you buy may be redeemable for something for some period of time... but that is true of any kind of token. The “uniqueness” of the NFT is an illusion; it does not offer any strong guarantee of uniquely representing an actual asset.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Now... for a regulated system of tokens (eg currency) a developer can’t do that: they are legally bound to accept fiat currency even though it is not redeemable for any “real” equivalent (eg gold). This isn't true in general. Legal tender status is very loosely an obligation to accept for existing debts, but it is not an obligation to accept it as, say, a means of accepting a offer. So unless they are giving you goods first, and the looking for payment (which certainly is not the norm for digital goods), they are under no obligation to accept currency.
- freshhawk 6y agoBut that's really why everyone will always accept them, because they can pay their debts/taxes with them. It's probably a common misconception because it's so close to correct.
- 6y ago
- DebtDeflation 6y ago> How so? The assets that are "sold" as NFT are still hosted somewhere. This is what I don't understand. It's like a baseball used in a World Series game and then signed by members of the team and the Certificate of Authenticity that accompanies it. The value of the CoA is when it ACCOMPANIES the baseball and authenticates it. I don't see how the CoA in and of itself has any value when the baseball is in someone else's possession.