9 ms·
A colleague went on once about Star Trek transporters: what if they worked by "scanning" a person, sent that data over the airwaves, then, made a perfect copy o
by JKCalhoun 6y ago
A colleague went on once about Star Trek transporters: what if they worked by "scanning" a person, sent that data over the airwaves, then, made a perfect copy of somewhere else (sourcing new molecules from wherever) — would this copy believe they were the original?
He went on: suppose you kill the original — did you "transport" the person?
Star Trek creeps me out a little now.
- JProthero 6y agoThere is a long tradition in academic philosophy of using this model of teleportation as a device for investigating questions of personal identity. Derek Parfit's 'Reasons and Persons' is probably the best-known treatment [1]. I think there are good reasons to believe this is not generally how the writers of Star Trek thought the transporters in their stories were supposed to work, but they weren't always perfectly consistent on the subject. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasons_and_persons#Personal_identity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasons_and_persons#Personal_i...
- skissane 6y ago> I think there are good reasons to believe this is not generally how the writers of Star Trek thought the transporters in their stories were supposed to work, but they weren't always perfectly consistent on the subject. I remember one episode of one of the TV shows (I forget which one), they used a transporter to transport a bomb off the ship, so it detonated in space instead. If transportation is converting matter to information, transmitting the information, then reassembling it at the other end, why would one bother doing that to a bomb? Just do the first step of converting matter to information, and then instead of transmitting it and reassembling it somewhere else, just send the information to /dev/null (I think if someone was designing a bomb, in a situation in which such technology was known, they'd try to design it so that any attempt to dematerialise/transport it would detonate it instantly.)
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoFurthermore, why not use the transporter as a weapon, creating bombs next to / inside enemy ships
- JProthero 6y agoYou might be on to something there: https://youtu.be/AtKnsxlUWr8?t=44 https://youtu.be/AtKnsxlUWr8?t=44
- marshmallow_12 6y agoi fail to see how this is an important philosophic subject, being based on absolutely no scientific data.
- JProthero 6y agoIn the philosophy of personal identity, teleportation is an intellectual contrivance only intended to help clarify thinking about personal identity. Another version of the same concept is the 'Swampman' thought experiment [1], which is also obviously not intended to be taken seriously as a scientific possibility. Most thought experiments in the philosophy of mind and personal identity have this character, e.g. Mary's Room [2], the China Brain [3], Philosophical Zombies [4], the Chinese Room [5] etc. Thought experiments are often not intended to be carried out empirically (Schrodinger did not poison cats, Maxwell could not summon demons, Einstein did not throw people off buildings or construct clocks made of light, and so on), but they are nevertheless useful tools that can lead to insights about the real world, or serve as inspiration for actual experiments (Bell tests [6] are perhaps a good example of this, as they derive directly from Ian Bell's careful consideration of a famous thought experiment of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen [7]). Quantum teleportation is also of course a real phenomenon [8], and it does have some of the same properties as the imaginary teleportation device that Parfit and other philosophers consider in their work, albeit that it has only been demonstrated at the atomic scale for now. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swampman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swampman [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_argument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_argument [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_brain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_brain [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_test [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_Podolsky_Rosen_Paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_Podolsky_Rosen_Parado... [8] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_teleportation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_teleportation
- marshmallow_12 6y agobut all the scientists you mentioned engaged in thought experiments that actually had real life parallels. Philosophising about personal identity, is completely irrelevant to us since it isn't, and never will be, possible to switch bodies.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LeoPanthera 6y agoThis actually happens in the TNG episode "Second Chances", in which Riker is unknowingly duplicated.
- Larrikin 6y agoI always imagine this will be the divide between rich and poor in the future. The more expensive technology will break the person down and send their atoms to the destination to be reconstructed, it will be slower but it will be the same person. The less expensive technology will scan the person send that data and they will be printed out from a a futuristic atomic printer in a process that kills the original. I imagine a mining colony around the asteroid belt where the CEO uses the more expensive tech that is slower to visit every so often but the workers are forced to use the tech that kills them everyday but they are just a light beam of zero and ones on their "commute"
- cgriswald 6y agoFor that to matter, atoms would have to be unique. But an identical atom is literally identical. A transported you wouldn’t be any different than a printed you. I rather suspect that “you” are simply information. If that information is copied, there’s another you—at least for the instant before that “you” starts having its own thoughts and receives information through its own senses. For you to die on transport and “someone else” to come out the other side, you’d have to exist in some way separate from your physical self; which might suggest you can survive death anyway.
- pontifier 6y agoIf you're gonna go that route, why even bother with an organic body... much easier to just throw the poor into a generic robot or something.
- tsimionescu 6y agoYou are presupposing that there is a material difference between these two. Whenever you have a discontinuation of your conscious experience (for example, when you go to sleep and wake up), you can view that as one person disappearing, and a copy waking up in the morning. In fact, unless you believe in a transcendent soul as the seat of consciousness, it must be equivalent. So, when you step into the teleporter, you can perfectly equivalently think of the person that will come up at the other side as a "copy" of you, or "future you". Let's say that the teleporter doesn't affect the local copy, it just creates a remote copy. What reason do you have to care more about the local copy than the remote copy? Why are you imagining that hacking the body up into tiny pieces, sending the pieces, and reassembling them would be any different from just killing the local copy and sending the information away? You'd still die and another person would be assembled on the other side. Now, if you do believe in a transcendent soul (I don't), things get much more interesting. In fact, teleportation in this way would amount to experimentation of this hypothesis. If humans have unique souls given to them by some god at the moment of birth, then copy teleportation should not be able to produce two copies - either one of the body copies would not be conscious at all, since one of the bodies would not have a soul, OR the two bodies would be completely different in personality, as one would have the original soul, and the other would have the new soul, which would be a completely different person. For the "move" style teleportation, the risk would be that the disassembly process kills the body and causes the soul to be separated, so that the reassembled body ends up being soul-less and doesn't function, or is inhabited by a different soul, so it must act differently.
- dehrmann 6y agoDid they just watch "The Prestige?"
- JKCalhoun 6y agoThanks for pointing out a film, but this was 30 years ago!
- dehrmann 6y agoThere's already a gap in you consciousness when you sleep. Is that any different than arriving as the copy?
- samus 6y agoI feel it's more like a gap in memory. We are usually not trained to remember our dreams. Even if I'm waken up in a non-REM phase, there is usually a kind of remembrance of how I felt during sleep. Edit: Made my statement more vague. There is definitely more to sleep though than turning consciousness off and on again.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThat is a technical point about sleep. Replace it with coma, general anaesthesia, or short death followed by reanimation, and the argument stays.
- phibz 6y agoThe video game SOMA asks this question yet in the game both the original and the copy live. It seemed like the copy still thought they were the original and the original wrestled with the idea that their conscience wasn't transfered.
- klipt 6y agoThis already happens with identical twins, who split from a single embryo at some point in their development. The only difference with splitting later in life is that you'd share more life memories from before the split.
- raducu 6y agoTransplantin a twins brain would still render the person a complete legume, not even the cranial nerve connections would be the same(sight, smell, hearing, touch of the face), let alone the spine nerves. All the nerve wiring would be wrong. DNA does not contain all the intricate nerve connections, just a meta-summary on how to build them.
- klipt 6y agoI was talking about the cloning philosophical question (e.g. being copied by a Star Trek transporter), not the surgery which I agree sounds very risky.
- j9461701 6y agoThe person who wrote the Star Trek TNG Technical Manual mentioned this, and how - as described in the show - it's probably killing you and building a clone with your memories instead of transporting you. He thought about tweaking the lore so it didn't do that, using wormholes or the like, but decided to stay true to the show's established canon.
- josefx 6y agoStar Wars: cloning takes ages, clones have to be raised and trained. Lets make a clone army to fight the mass produced robot army. Star Trek: cloning takes seconds. You can have as many copies of a veteran warrior as you want. Dangerous mission? just send in the red shirts and a few highly trained veterans in the hope that nobody important dies (again).
- kelnos 6y agoI found it interesting how Star Trek (at least TNG) avoids the ethical dilemmas via vague technological handwaving. Because, right, if you beam down a bunch of redshirts and they die, can't you just have the transporter remember their patterns and resurrect them? Of course they'd have no memories of the away mission that killed them, but that seems like a small price to pay to avoid death. But instead we have "pattern buffers" that "degrade" quickly, and presumably keeping around copies of the full quantum states of many humans would require too much storage.
- NateEag 6y agoSchlock Mercenary does a great job handling the nature of consciousness boundaries and death in a post-Singularity world (technologically speaking - digital minds retain their own personalities in this story), as well as some of the ethical concerns. It really takes off in the book "A Little Immortality": https://www.schlockmercenary.com/2016-12-05 https://www.schlockmercenary.com/2016-12-05 but the core ideas leading to that book go back much further in the comic's archives.
- DrScump 6y agoThis concept is addressed in the short story "Think Like a Dinosaur"[0], which also became an episode of "The Outer Limits". [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_Like_a_Dinosaur https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_Like_a_Dinosaur
- anoncow 6y agoA rule could be made that memories can only be moved and not copied. Copying memories could be made illegal punishable by mandatory formatting.
- developer92 6y agorules are made to be broken as they say
- anoncow 6y agoPerhaps moving can be enforced using Blockchain principles?
- est31 6y agoThere is a CGP grey video about this subject: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQHBAdShgYI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQHBAdShgYI
- developer92 6y agoI'm off the opinion that transporting is pointless from a selfish point of view: your duplicate will get to Jupiter or wherever, and think they're you, but your consciousness will stop so you will never get to experience it. I don't know what experiment you could do to prove this either way.
- Engineering-MD 6y agoYou can also apply the same argument Pre and post deep sleep or anaesthetic
- mozey 6y agoOh wow, never thought of that before. Now I'm feeling a little creeped out. Kind of makes me think of the difference between disk and RAM when rebooting a computer
- fishtacos 6y agoThere is a sci-fi/horror game called SOMA that explores a related theme. It has an "easy" mode that makes it almost a walking simulator, so even if one is not a gamer, they'd probably enjoy it. Highly recommended. https://somagame.com/ https://somagame.com/
- layer8 6y ago...or even from one moment to the next.
- TaupeRanger 6y agoAssuming there is nothing like a "soul" which persists only in relation to the current cells in your brain, you aren't even the same person you were 2 seconds ago. It's literally no different for the transporter. The "you" of 2 seconds ago is no longer conscious either. Since consciousness is so mysterious, I think admitting our ignorance on the issue is probably the most reasonable approach atm.
- tsimionescu 6y ago
- redis_mlc 6y agoBones, the MD actor on Star Trek, avoided the transporter whenever possible. So he wasn't convinced it was a good idea.
- michaelmrose 6y agoA science fiction book explored the idea that this destruction was imperfect leaving behind an echo that could only interact with other echos. I was called "Echo Round his Bones" https://www.fantasticfiction.com/d/thomas-m-disch/echo-round-his-bones.htm https://www.fantasticfiction.com/d/thomas-m-disch/echo-round...
- femto 6y agoSomething similar happens in telephony today. When you talk to your Mum over a phone that uses a predictive vocoder, you're not really talking to your Mum. You're talking to a voice synthesiser that is being instructed to talk like your Mum. Does it really matter though? It's just a different way of encoding the information. These things force one to think about the nature of what is real and what matters. Is the important thing actually hearing your Mum (whatever that means), or making the connection with her at an emotional level?
- tibbydudeza 6y agoThere was an episode of some scifi anthology show where interstellar FTL travel is achieved by a similar matter copying. Occasionally something goes wrong and the source is not "deconstructed" properly by the equipment so the procedure is for the transporter crew to terminate the original person. PS It was "Think Like A Dinosaur"