9 ms·
Ethical and moral considerations aside, this also has some interesting philsophical implications: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus https://en.wikip
by userbinator 6y ago
Ethical and moral considerations aside, this also has some interesting philsophical implications: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoI find there to be nothing interesting about it. This, like so many other “philosophical quæstions” is a futile quibble of semantics that answers nothing. The simple answer to this problem, and many other problems, is that the exercise of giving clouds of atoms in vicinity to one another “identities” is not one based in salient thought. — there is no such thing. All Theseus' Ship shows is that, indeed, this theory is flawed, and easily reduced to the absurd, but that is a trivial conclusion an unindoctrinated child should be able to easily make in a multitude of ways. It's as though one come with a thought experiment that demonstrates that the borders of countries are an artificial man-made construct, rather than an actual physical property of the universe. — it is rather obvious.
- otabdeveloper4 6y ago> The simple answer to this problem, and many other problems, is that the exercise of giving clouds of atoms in vicinity to one another “identities” is not one based in salient thought. — there is no such thing. Are you implying identies don't exist? Because that either has to be sophistry (i.e. trolling) or insanity.
- bobthebuilders 6y agoWay to engage in good faith discussion.
- Blikkentrekker 6y ago“exist"? I would hardly use such words in this frame of reference. I'm saying that “identities” are a fuzzy human “You know it when you see it, and different men see it differently.” category that is bereft of any definition that can be objectively measured and reasoned about, and that what I just said is a trivial and obvious conclusion. They “exist” in the same way that borders between different oceans exist, arbitrarily drawn, and different people will think differently as to where they lie. If you wish to call that an “existence”, then be my guest, though many others would præfer to not call it such. — ironically the border between “existence” and “nonexistence” is of a similar quality.
- keiferski 6y agoThe fact that borders exist doesn’t imply that there are different centers of power. In fact, for most of history borders were notoriously ill-defined.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoBut power in practice does not adhere to how different parties arbitrarily define where borders lie. Most of nations of the world officially define Crimea to be within the Ukrainian border, but it is the Russian government who wields the actual, practical power there. It took a rather long time for many countries to stop defining mainland China as falling within the power of the R.O.C. government, despite the R.O.C. wielding no practical power there any more, and the R.O.C. still defines mainland China as falling within it's power. If “borders” of nations were defined descriptively based on sovereign entities having control over them, then they would certainly be more useful, but, this would also assume a simplified world where it is easy to decide what powerbase is sovereign, and what powerbase binarily has control over what surface of the planet; it is often not so simple and often multiple parties vie for control over a single area, and whether a powerbase be sovereign is not so easy to simply answer.
- keiferski 6y agoPower in practice does adhere to borders, just not 100% of the time. Reality isn’t a computer program. The fact that some rules are broken occasionally doesn’t mean that they aren’t rules.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoThat's very much what a law of physics is. If the law is observed broken once, that is a falsification of the entire theory. And I assume you live in a rather peaceful area if you think powers adheres to borders. In many parts of the world governments have a harm time enforcing their law upon fringe areas where effective anarchy is quite common. — the picture is certainly not as simple as you paint it.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe notion of an object, in the human sense, doesn't have any solid relationship with the physical world. I hope we are agreed on this much. For some objects, there is a stronger correlation between the human concept and the physical world (i.e. you could find a formal definition that matches to some extent what I mean by a particular spoon), but for other objects in our minds there is nothing in the physical world that truly matches our understanding (the Atlantic Ocean, as an object separate from the Pacific Ocean, is not a physical object, it is just a human abstraction). In particular, our notion of the identity of an object has no relationship with the physical world, as the Ship of Theseus shows. Our idea that objects "shatter" and "transform", so that if I break a glass the pieces are a different object than the glass; or if I mix of bowl of flower with water and roll it into a dough, the dough is a different object than the bowl of flour and the water - these are not physically definable notions. When it comes to human identity, the identity perceived by myself, the same logic MUST apply, unless you believe in a soul. The fact that I can think of myself as the same identity as myself 2 seconds ago, or myself when I was a handful of cells in my mother's womb, is obviously an artifice of the human mind. There is no such continuity in the physical world. And this has all been said from the perspective of classical physics. If you go into QM, where any notion of identity of particles would contradict the theory and observations of it, things really break down.
- pontifier 6y agoI tend to agree. It's difficult to draw a good shell around what I call myself. Yes, there is the body, the brain, some part there somewhere that is "Me", but I also have children, and ideas that are part of my identity. I tend to draw the border of self a little looser than most. I'm a human, a living being, and a piece of me extends both forward and backward in time far beyond the start and end of this meat bag at a keyboard.
- Razengan 6y agoSomeone pooh-poohing something while claiming to provide a "simple answer to many problems" is ironic at best, and insufferably arrogant at worse.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoIt's a “simple answer to many problems” in the same way “Hoṃœopathy is nonsense.” is a “simple answer” to explain the complexity of “how can water have a memory?”. There is no problem, and there is no answer. There is only a complex problem from assuming a falsehood and trying to explain it. — there is nothing arrogant about calling out obvious nonsense.
- XorNot 6y agoIt doesn't really raise any interesting philosophical questions though: so long as we're moving at least an intact brain from body to body, nothing dramatic has really happened (and all the small stuff applies up and down the stack - you go under aneasthesia, we put a new part in, you wake up and get all sorts of different signalling from this part which is not genetically yours.
- jhanschoo 6y agoI don't think this is as interesting philosophically as people who have half brains removed, but note that a head transplant is more invasive than what you and the article acknowledge: the CNS is partly in the body, and the body regulates one's hormonal makeup which is in itself pretty complex and tied to one's sapience.
- f6v 6y agoSomeone here asked about gut-brain axis. The truth is that we don’t have even surface-level understanding of what truly shapes consciousness. Maybe it’s the whole package that makes you - you.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoA colleague went on once about Star Trek transporters: what if they worked by "scanning" a person, sent that data over the airwaves, then, made a perfect copy of somewhere else (sourcing new molecules from wherever) — would this copy believe they were the original? He went on: suppose you kill the original — did you "transport" the person? Star Trek creeps me out a little now.
- JProthero 6y agoThere is a long tradition in academic philosophy of using this model of teleportation as a device for investigating questions of personal identity. Derek Parfit's 'Reasons and Persons' is probably the best-known treatment [1]. I think there are good reasons to believe this is not generally how the writers of Star Trek thought the transporters in their stories were supposed to work, but they weren't always perfectly consistent on the subject. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasons_and_persons#Personal_identity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasons_and_persons#Personal_i...
- skissane 6y ago> I think there are good reasons to believe this is not generally how the writers of Star Trek thought the transporters in their stories were supposed to work, but they weren't always perfectly consistent on the subject. I remember one episode of one of the TV shows (I forget which one), they used a transporter to transport a bomb off the ship, so it detonated in space instead. If transportation is converting matter to information, transmitting the information, then reassembling it at the other end, why would one bother doing that to a bomb? Just do the first step of converting matter to information, and then instead of transmitting it and reassembling it somewhere else, just send the information to /dev/null (I think if someone was designing a bomb, in a situation in which such technology was known, they'd try to design it so that any attempt to dematerialise/transport it would detonate it instantly.)
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoFurthermore, why not use the transporter as a weapon, creating bombs next to / inside enemy ships
- cute_boi 6y agoReminds me of Anime One Piece where they want to fix the ship named Merry. But at the end luffy crew realized even if they fix the ship they have to replace the core component and after they replace the ship would no longer be merry. At the end they had to free merry by burning it :)
- puddingnomeat 6y agocoincidentally aired at the same time https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tGdqurw18gc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tGdqurw18gc