I think people are missing the bigger picture... This doesn't have to be 100% correct or it's worthless. Sometimes there's gold in a failed effort. Maybe some p

I think people are missing the bigger picture... This doesn't have to be 100% correct or it's worthless. Sometimes there's gold in a failed effort. Maybe some part of Weinstein's approach moves the field forward even if the proposal is not complete. The physics community has been obsessed with string theory for a generation. Maybe this is a way to restart other areas that might lead to something.