7 ms·
I forget... is HAMR the slow one that kills your NAS?
by nottorp 6y ago
I forget... is HAMR the slow one that kills your NAS?
- liminalsunset 6y agoI think you're thinking about SMR - Shingled Magnetic Recording. The tracks overlap because the heads are larger for writing than for reading, so writing can be a destructive process and data must be rewritten when adjacent data is written. These types of drives are fast for sequential writes, but any operations that edit data may be slow. Additionally, the drive spends time when idle clicking around to "defragment" the shingles IIRC.
- bcrl 6y agoSMR drives are not "fast" for writes. They run at slightly less than the same speed as non-SMR drives do for sequential writes (opening zones has a cost). They are unpredictable and often slow for everything else. SMR drives are somewhat like the first generation of SSD controllers: they lots of glass jaws that nobody ever expects when garbage collection begins to kick in.
- tinus_hn 6y ago> they lots of glass jaws that nobody ever expects Looks like autocorrect got involved here
- bcrl 6y agoI've been having pretty bad luck with autocarrot lately (yes, my phone has learned that word). The word "the" has come out as all kinds of weird things that barely resemble what I meant to type on my phone. It seems partially age related, as it seems to happen more often the older I get.
- magicalhippo 6y agoAs noted that's SMR[1], which is more or less orthogonal to HAMR[2]. That is, AFAIK, a drive can have HAMR without using SMR, or it can use both. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shingled_magnetic_recording https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shingled_magnetic_recording [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat-assisted_magnetic_recording https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat-assisted_magnetic_recordi...
- nottorp 6y agoAh thanks. The pessimist in me is expecting all new models to have both though :)