3 ms·

Thanks. I think this is the key idea I was looking to understand: >"What differs between the two is that the "scheduling" that occurred by the left side "contr

Thanks. I think this is the key idea I was looking to understand: >"What differs between the two is that the "scheduling" that occurred by the left side "control unit" was instead dispersed into the reservation stations and reorder buffer of the right side diagram." Is it a correct mental model then to think about control unit being a logical or "distributed" unit(right side of diagram) instead of a monolithic unit(the left side of diagram)? I'm guessing this "reservation station/reorder buffer variant" of control unit is the predominant one in use in CISC chips these days?

pwg 6y ago
> Is it a correct mental model then to think about control unit being a logical or "distributed" unit(right side of diagram) instead of a monolithic unit(the left side of diagram)? That is a somewhat reasonable interpretation. Just keep in mind that both diagrams are massive simplifications of the actual reality (i.e., the left side diagram likely had a more dispersed control system than the block diagram would lead one to believe). > I'm guessing this "reservation station/reorder buffer variant" of control unit is the predominant one in use in CISC chips these days? It is/has been a popular model (first introduced by IBM in the 360/91 mainframe circa 1967 -- R.M. Tomasulo, "An Efficient Algorithm for Exploiting Multiple Arithmetic Units, https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~evans/greatworks/tomasulo.pdf https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~evans/greatworks/tomasulo.pdf) for many designs over the years. As for predominant in CISC chips, that really depends upon what current Intel/AMD CPU's are doing internally, and I've not kept up with their most recent offering's internal designs.
- bogomipz 6y ago
  Thanks and thanks for the link. I was aware of the Tomasulo algorithm but I don't think I've ever seen the original paper nor did I know it was inherently connected to the IBM OS/360. Cheers.

pwg 6y ago

> Is it a correct mental model then to think about control unit being a logical or "distributed" unit(right side of diagram) instead of a monolithic unit(the left side of diagram)? That is a somewhat reasonable interpretation. Just keep in mind that both diagrams are massive simplifications of the actual reality (i.e., the left side diagram likely had a more dispersed control system than the block diagram would lead one to believe). > I'm guessing this "reservation station/reorder buffer variant" of control unit is the predominant one in use in CISC chips these days? It is/has been a popular model (first introduced by IBM in the 360/91 mainframe circa 1967 -- R.M. Tomasulo, "An Efficient Algorithm for Exploiting Multiple Arithmetic Units, https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~evans/greatworks/tomasulo.pdf https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~evans/greatworks/tomasulo.pdf) for many designs over the years. As for predominant in CISC chips, that really depends upon what current Intel/AMD CPU's are doing internally, and I've not kept up with their most recent offering's internal designs.

bogomipz 6y ago
Thanks and thanks for the link. I was aware of the Tomasulo algorithm but I don't think I've ever seen the original paper nor did I know it was inherently connected to the IBM OS/360. Cheers.