6 ms·
Because book quality has nothing to do with release date. Books aren't fruit. And because "classics" means a huge, multi-century or millenia long filtering pr
by coldtea 6y ago
Because book quality has nothing to do with release date.
Books aren't fruit.
And because "classics" means a huge, multi-century or millenia long filtering process, where it has been found good, useful, and insightful for generations upon generations of people.
Also, because all the best of your modern books will soon enough be "classics" too, and you'll be as dead as the people who wrote the older classics. So what makes you think you or your compotemporary authors have some unique insight just because you happen to be living at the moment?
Only a belief in an arrow of progress where non-technical things (morals, books, ideas) get monotonically better (or at least, where the dominant vector over time points to better) would justify not reading the classics. But then again only someone ignorant enough to not have read the classics would believe such an idea. So reading the classics will cure you of that too.
(Even for technical things it's not always the case - there were civilizations more advanced than those that followed them, or periods where we went backwards in quality of life, knowledge of science, etc., for centuries - but at least with technical knowledge it's possible to amass and improve. You don't amass morals however, and even the higher moral ideas and ideals can be used for the worst attrocities).
- zozbot234 6y ago...Also, because the "classics" are so readily available online, free of copyright and in easy-to-use, open formats. You can't really say that about much modern literature; of course there's plenty of good content on the web, but if you're actually looking for actual 'literature' meaning stuff that's been commercially published, that can be quite hard to access in anything other than dead-tree format.
- Jabbles 6y agohttps://standardebooks.org/ https://standardebooks.org/ was recently discussed here, and looks great for out-of-copyright books. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26207484 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26207484
- 1996 6y ago> ...Also, because the "classics" are so readily available online, free of copyright and in easy-to-use, open formats Or you can use Z-Library and get the same advantage for modern stuff > actual 'literature' meaning stuff that's been commercially published, that can be quite hard to access in anything other than dead-tree format. Not with the right software :)
- anjbe 6y agoThe fact that classics are in the public domain provides other benefits besides simply being able to download them. They can also be freely redistributed without bringing The Man down on one’s own head. A large chunk of my reading these days comes from Standard Ebooks, and I regularly fix typos and make other formatting or markup improvements, since all the books are published on GitHub and the maintainers are very responsive.
- jimbob45 6y agoThis. I was able to read all of the Sherlock Holmes books for free in high school. When you’re broke, classics are a great option to turn to.
- dhosek 6y agoI read a lot of Graham Greene and Isaac Asimov for free in high school. Loads of other books too. There are big buildings in my community full of books and they let me pick them off the shelves and take them home and read them as long as I promised to bring them back in a few weeks. They even had a big room with the same policies at my high school and even my elementary school.
- Barrin92 6y ago>Because book quality has nothing to do with release date. Quality has a lot to do with release date, although in the opposite direction you seem to imply here. Books that have been part of the discourse for hundreds or thousands of years are likely of significant value because they have been hammered at, turned upside-down and kept people engaged for a very long time. That's a pretty good indicator for their value, and it also increases the chance that the books are still going to be relevant in another 50 years. So cultural artifacts are actually like reverse-fruit. The older they are, the likely they have struck a nerve and found something that's meaningful regardless of what age we happen to find ourselves in. If you have to choose between a classic and a random politician's campaign memoir published half a year ago, picking the former based on age is actually a really good idea.
- doggodaddo78 6y agoCabernet Sauvignon ;-)
- andreilys 6y agoThis is captured in the concept of the “Lindy Effect”, which says the future life expectancy of something like a book is proportional to its current age, so that every additional period of survival implies a longer remaining life expectancy. In other words NYT’s 2021 best seller list is less likely to be read in 2030 than a classic.
- davidivadavid 6y agoYou're just repeating his point, but introduced unnecessary confusion. The book quality has nothing to do with the release date itself. There's probably plenty of bad old books. The value is in the filtering that occurred and made those books disappear.
- OJFord 6y agoYou can leave it at filtering, really. Is there anyone alive and writing today that anyone, seriously, ranks among the pan-century greats? I think it takes time to realise anyway, they're old or dead by the time it's clear how great they are (or were). There's no point naming them, but of the three ~contemporary authors I thought of, two are dead and one I came to realise only really had the one hit I was aware of.
- doggodaddo78 6y agoBeauty is in the eye... There can be no honest absolute ranking of subjective artistic works. It's NY Review of Each Other's Books to lull oneself into ranking apples with oranges.
- coldtea 6y ago>Beauty is in the eye... Beauty yes. Culture however takes a civilization plus time, not the sole taste of some beholder. Art is not just about satisfying our individual tastes. >There can be no honest absolute ranking of subjective artistic works. No, but there doesn't have to be. It's enough to classify them in different quality bins.
- doggodaddo78 6y agoMost people have no clue where their preferences originate, whether nature or nurture (incl. social pressures and marketing). Are you really going to explain to me what art is and isn't about? :/
- bannedmanytimes 6y agoIshiguro's the unconsoled will survive.
- ofBishopWimund 6y agoThis is all well and good, really -- I love 'the classics' to whatever extent that's an agreed upon list (Harold Bloom's the Western Canon (1994), probably its most explicit recent defense, had a list of essential books that was highly controversial and admittedly personal). But I'm concerned that not enough people here have heard the counter-arguments. The problem is that time is not an unbiased filter, and all the processes of history that anoint and preserve Great Books are not purely a result of their innate or universal value. It's the same argument that's been made for the last 30-40 years about historical archives: what gets saved and how inherently excludes other stories, perspectives, and lives that we're now trying to recover. Often those exclusions are made along lines of power--race, class, gender, etc. "The Classics" is an idea with its own history that scholars can trace, where the key players are rarely literary critics or sales numbers but institutions (churches, schools, etc.) aligned with powerful interests. Of course it's more complicated, and you'd ideally want to trace each work or groups of texts individually to see how they were 'canonized' and what that meant--but what's important to question is why many of us take this notion of 'the classics' for granted, and whether we might just be stooges of old historical prejudices (that are not, of course, gone). Understandably any effort at 'canonization' makes people nervous, because we'd immediately want to know who's making the decisions. None of which is reason not to read things considered classic--Tolstoy and Thucydides and Shakespeare are some of my favorite shit-- but to treat the concept with skepticism, appreciate new work that challenges it, and consider each work on its own, rather than as part of some grand corpus handed down from above. It's an attitude that arouses a lot of contempt (Bloom called critics the 'School of Resentment' intent on subjugating all aesthetics to Marxist politcs), but it's really I think just a standard liberal challenge to established authority. In some sense it's a broader playing out of the Reformation rejection of Catholicism's stranglehold on biblical reading and interpretation, except what we're dealing with is the secular equivalent (Great Books). Inevitably there's a radical segment which will call for abandoning these books altogether as vehicles for oppression and nothing more. And every time there's a threat to established church order, including the Reformation, authorities have cried 'antinomianism' (no laws, faith justifies all)--true in a few cases, but misrepresenting the movement as a whole and disqualifying its legitimate criticisms. Anyway, contemporary writers and publishers are becoming aware of these issues and some have tried to resurrect the lost narratives excluded or unrecognized by 'the Classics,' documenting facets of the human experience that rarely earned entry. Since more people can read and think freely now than ever could during the formation of the Canon, and a lot of these people would not have had a seat at the table if they were alive then, the skepticism of 'Classics' and embrace of modern writers speaking directly to them, makes total sense. The "rich white men" point is a bit overplayed, and often misapplied, but in general it pretty succinctly nails the problem. tl;dr: there are absolutely great books considered classics but 'the classics' itself is a historical construct that's often been wielded by the powerful for their own ends; lots of folks feel no obligation to it and prefer instead to find modern writers creating new ways forward.
- johnchristopher 6y ago> Also, because all the best of your modern books will soon enough be "classics" too, and you'll be as dead as the people who wrote the older classics. > So what makes you think you or your compotemporary authors have some unique insight just because you happen to be living at the moment? Because you just stated in the previous sentence that they are soon to be considered classic? > So reading the classics will cure you of that too. ...
- jacobolus 6y agoThe best current books will (if people still keep reading them in the future) become “classics”. Most current books will be forgotten, just as most books from the past have been forgotten.
- jkdfgljk 6y ago>...soon to be considered classic? It was "classic", not classic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scare_quotes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scare_quotes
- doggodaddo78 6y agoAbsolutely right. There are many attitudes in modern life that apply the new=better consumerism fallacy where it doesn't belong: code, people, experience, restaurants, ideas, values, music, art, film, food, literature, and durable goods. Throwing away ideas, objects, and preferences of the past wholesale loses the lessons of history, reinvents the wheel, and repeats said history.
- zebraflask 6y agoThese are all good points. I would also add that understanding the stylistic history of writing in terms of language, technique, structure, etc., improves your own writing, if you have an interest in learning to write well.
- Osmium 6y ago> Books aren't fruit. Books may not be, but: “I have a theory that plays go off, like fruit,” Tom Stoppard https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2021/03/tom-stoppard-hermione-lee/617799/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2021/03/tom-sto... There's something to be said about fiction tapping into a zeitgeist, and how fleeting that is. Even if the fiction remains relevant and interesting, it can still lose the emotional resonance it had when it was first released. I share your skepticism about the "arrow of progress" however, so don't interpret this as an argument against what you're saying, just offering a counterpoint. Many classics have left me cold on reading them, even ones that I recognize are structurally excellent.
- coldtea 6y ago>“I have a theory that plays go off, like fruit,” Tom Stoppard They do, but the classic plays are the ones that people considered as not having gone off.
- thret 6y agoThe filter, exactly. You will probably only read ~5000 books in your lifetime so targeting the best of the best will maximise your enjoyment. Of course you should pursue an author/series/subject that you particularly enjoy. It's also nice to read books that friends recommend so that you can share the experience with them.
- ipaddr 6y agoI would say 500 if you are lucky. I tried to read as many books as possible for a period of time between getting an ereader and huge book dumps. I found I could read a book every 3 days on average. Keeping that pace you could read 100 books a year. People can't keep up that pace. Of the people who read if they finish more than 5 books it would be amazing. You have periods where you read more like in school. Most people will not have read 50 books by the time they have finished school. Books on tape could increase the numbers. Most people will have read 5 or less books. Those who do read will probably average 54. To get to 500 would be amazing. To get to 5,000 would take you 50 years of reading every second you could outside of work.
- dhosek 6y agoThe correct number is somewhere between yours. I remember encountering the number 3,000 for serious readers at some point when I was in my twenties and being rather depressed at how low it is. Goodreads is my sole social network these days and it's interesting to see the range of numbers that my friends pick for their challenge goal each year from as low as single digits to one friend who routinely reads 200+ books a year. Since I've started tracking my reading about 26 years ago (probably around the time that I encountered that 3,000 books number), I've read 1,840 books (with my annual totals varying from a low of 27 to a high of 129). Probably the most important thing towards this was something my Latin professor told us, saying that if you read just ten pages just for yourself each night before you go to bed, that becomes 3,650 pages over the course of the year which is nearly the entirety of À la recherche du temps perdu. It also helps that I've done things like commute by public transportation (extra reading time) and I value reading as a means of entertainment.
- coyotespike 6y agoI'll give a caveat - many of the classics suffered by being translated. They're translated in a Victorian or pseudo-Victorian style that takes all the pizzazz out of them. For instance, the Odyssey never gripped me until Emily Wilson's translation. Beautifully lucid, so clear my eight-year-old niece easily followed it, the story pops again. By this measure, book quality and release date may have a lot to do with each other.
- HDMI_Cable 6y agoI’ve been trying to translate some of Caesar’s works into readable English, and to this day I can’t find one reason why all of these translations read like a textbook. The Latin for most of these writers was really direct and to the point, so translations specifically made it harder to read.
- Veen 6y agoPerhaps because the Venn diagram of expert-level Latinists and great writers doesn't overlap much. It also depends on their goal; literal translations for an academic audience don't prioritize readability.
- sateesh 6y agoTotally agree with it. It is not only the ancient classics, there are quite awful translations of greats like Dostovesky, Tolstoy etc. After reading Dostovesy in some bad translations, before venturing on reading any of his works I spend some time checking who are the transaltors.
- billfruit 6y agoRichard Lattimore in my opinion is a more poetic translation than Wilson and it has been out of 50 or 60 years.
- watwut 6y agoI agree about that translation. It was first time I actually enjoyed and finished that old book. The historical introduction and translators twitter explanations about translation also added a lot.