3 ms·
> Is that enough for you? If not, how many are enough? I do not know, I am interested in the real size of the potential problem. Every change of leadership in
by inglor_cz 6y ago
> Is that enough for you? If not, how many are enough?
I do not know, I am interested in the real size of the potential problem.
Every change of leadership in a big corporation carries a risk of someone leaving, if not immediately, then within a few months. People who are universally liked rarely get into CEO positions. (High agreeableness makes it really hard to execute painful decisions.)
Of course, if 1 person leaves, it is not dramatic. If half of the staff leaves, it is dramatic. But how many are enough? You probably cannot answer the question any more than I do, it is the same question like "how many sand particles you need to call it a heap".
Mozilla made their choice. They have a CEO that offends no one and a market share under 1 per cent. Perhaps they would have the same market share under Eich. Perhaps not. I think that Eich was more passionate about the product than current leadership and that it would have made some difference. Individual programmers are, to some degree, fungible; Mozilla ecosystem is one of a kind.
- eesmith 6y agoThe way you added "Or was someone offended on their behalf, preemptively?" suggested a different intent. I read it as a distrust that anyone at Mozilla would actually care, and explicit doubt on my earlier description of 'LGBT people and their fellow travelers working for and supporting Mozilla'. The overarching question I have: what does "cancel" mean? According to my definition ("negative consequences to rich, powerful, or famous people because of actions or statements that the left disagrees with"), Eich was indeed canceled. But of course, my definition is little different than "those lefties need to shut up and stop complaining!" - just couched in fancier terms. [1] Then, if he was meaningfully "canceled", does that mean that what happened was necessarily a bad thing? Obviously, as a lefty, I don't, since that would mean my complaints would never be heard. I'll construct a dramatic hypothetical. Suppose 90% of the staff threatened to leave if Eich stayed on, because of his support for homophobic legislation. This would have shown that Eich's leadership role would have been rather ineffectual, so decided to leave, in order that Mozilla survive as an organization. Would that still have been "cancelling" Eich in that case? And therefore would it be an intrinsically immoral or unethical act? [1] And I still don't know how "cancel" can be applied to this Suess case, where the copyright holder [2] has decided to stop the publication on what appears to be a voluntary decision with only scattered activism for the change. [2] Really, isn't the problem that copyright is entirely too long? Why should we wait another 40 years before a book published in 1937 enters the public domain? When he wrote it, the maximum copyright period was 56 years - until 1993. As a public domain book, we wouldn't be having this tempest in a teapot!
- inglor_cz 6y agoCopyright is absolutely too long, and I am saying that as someone who has significant income from royalties. I would be for 10 years of automatic copyright, with the possibility to purchase up to X years more for a registration fee that would start very low but would grow to significant levels, so that only the most lucrative works stay protected after, say, 30 years.