10 ms·
Somewhat recently a head of Microsoft was asked about forgoing access to the Chinese market if it meant protecting American interests in the face of new threats
by mc32 6y ago
Somewhat recently a head of Microsoft was asked about forgoing access to the Chinese market if it meant protecting American interests in the face of new threats. He unequivocally said, yes. He was willing to forgo their market.
I'm not sure Apple and others who either sell product there or have large manufacturing there are as willing to forgo the 'promise market', but it looks more and more we will have to. More or less the next Russia in terms of sanctions.
We'll see how Biden handles this. I'm sure it's a tough call.
- bushbaba 6y agoThe us let’s Chinese firms generally speaking full access to the us market. The CCP doesn’t allow the us companies the same. Why our government let that happen. Letting so much business leave to the CCP will be one of the greatest failings of the us government.
- refenestrator 6y agoBecause we're arrogant. We thought that if we go down the road we went down, they'd naturally settle into their proper place as manufactory for the West without wanting a seat at the table. Now they're a global power and, gasp, they act like one. Nobody could have seen this coming.
- kingkawn 6y agoI don’t think anyone was thinking it through at all. We just needed cheap goods to placate our population and they needed the jobs to placate theirs.
- cyberpunk 6y agoI’d recommend reading the 100 year marathon and watching the latest Curtis if you’re curious to learn more on that. :)
- kelnos 6y agoThe US also believed that giving China an example of "the good way" via access to the US markets would cause them to open up and allow access in kind. Turned out that was a pretty naive belief.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 6y agoIt wasn't even a belief in the first place. I read a dozen books on post-Nixon US politics. The amount of allegations from both sides of US politics that the other benefitted in the personal capacity from trade with China is staggering. At least some of them must be genuine. It comes to a very simple explanation that communists have indeed been influencing US politics for decades with very crude means, and that they were successful in that. This is an embarrassing admission US has to do first before any recovery can be started.
- refenestrator 6y agoThe very simple explanation is that the USA is infiltrated by communists?
- baybal2 6y agoIn other words, yes. I avoided stating it this bluntly for it being almost a cartoon trope. But... but one can't believe into any other explanation as any much credible. Do hundreds of US political insiders lobby for China in one voice just for nothing? You don't have closet communists, just a lot of very greedy, amoral, and easy to exploit power holders. American legal system prohibits jailing people for anything but being caught red handed in cases of political corruption. I have no idea what you can do about that without doing political persecution, but on other hand if you leave it be it will keep being exploited like hell.
- chrischen 6y ago
- tim333 6y agoThey were also trending towards being a relatively benevolent modern country under Deng Xiaoping when many restrictions were dropped. It's a bit unfortunate that under the present guy they seem to be returning to a Maoist dictatorship and I guess will stay that way for quite a while.
- wayneftw 6y agoBecause the people who own and control everything would rather build up a government like the CCP so they can better control the "useless eaters" (as Henry Kissinger put it). "Made in China" is exactly the type of curse that the global elite like to put on people. It's plain as day what's coming next and yet, everybody has just accepted it since the 70s. China will be the world superpower to replace the US and apparently we're all fine with that.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoChina acts in China's interests. They as an institution are acting no different than they have throughout the dozens of empires before it. It's basically Ming 2.0.
- Aunche 6y agoThe US has a significantly larger consumer market. A lot of people would complain if they were unable to import cheap goods from China.
- mc32 6y agoYeah but it means they don’t get paid as much either as there is no wage pressure at the bottom. You can’t have $5 T-shirts and also a $15 minimum wage.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYou can’t have $5 T-shirts and also a $15 minimum wage and low unemployment. You can have $5 T-shirts and a $15 minimum wage and no jobs, but nobody actually wants that outcome.
- Aunche 6y agoThe bottom earners aren't the people driving the consumer market. That's why they tend to advocate for protectionism.
- trhway 6y ago>You can’t have $5 T-shirts and also a $15 minimum wage. with $15 minimum wage there is no need for $5 T-shirts.
- mc32 6y agoI agree!
- dgellow 6y agoA few speculative ideas/thoughts: - The US needs access to China's goods to be viable. For half a century US companies improved their efficiency/competitiveness by moving their process to China. They now have too many dependencies in the form of Chinese manufacturing and development capabilities and do not have the skills/knowledge/talents/infrastructure in the US. Because of this China can dictate their rules with zero pressure (though India and other countries will surely be a difficult competition at some point, or maybe already are). - China owns more than 1 trillion of US debt. In the past the country bought a massive amount of US debt to inflate USD vs RMB and boost their own economy. Currently China has no reasons to sell their reserve as that would impact their economy negatively. If the US blocks them they may start massively selling US debt, which would impact USD and the US economy.
- baybal2 6y ago> The US needs access to China's goods to be viable. No, it really isn't. The thing the US is indeed does very little for an economy of its size. Washington can slam fist on the table, and US industry will be out of China by tomorrow, without much impact at home besides no iToys this season, and few percents off its stock market. Lack of consumer goods would of course be upsetting, but people wouldn't die from lack of them.
- vkou 6y agoYes, it does. Run a political campaign on 'All the stuff you buy? I'm going to make it cost more,' and you will be slaughtered at the polls. People barely making ends meet aren't very interested in those kinds of political statements. You could, of course, try to lie to them about what the consequences of your policies are going to be.
- baybal2 6y agoYou are correct, and this is America's, and West's predicament. If you can't do this, you can't do this. And you certainly wouldn't be able to do even more painful things which are truly needed for the West to have any chance to put the genie back into the bottle. China, and Russia have effectively conditioned the NATO countries over the decades into "self-beneficial inaction." Now, seeing words like yours proves their strategy worked.
- nullifidian 6y agoBecause the US in large part is ruled in the interest of the international capital and the ruling elites, not in the interest of its general populace. It was more profitable to deindustrialize the US.
- da_big_ghey 6y agoWe need blocking foreign direct investment for America by any Chinese from 20 years previous. Today we need grand incentives for tax reducing to make repurchasing of China investments in America. No Chinese should have owningship on any asset of America. Chinese is hostile power to good things all in world. Need containment to until collapse of government it have now.
- freeflight 6y agoWhy not just ban Chinese from entering the US at all, just like in the good old times [0]? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_Exclusion_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_Exclusion_Act
- da_big_ghey 6y agoNo, is terrible plans. We ought make open our border for any Chinese who desier for come to America. No person ought forced to be in such places as China. And also we are wanting good people desirous for liberty.
- yorwba 6y agoChina, generally speaking, gives US companies full access to the Chinese market. When that is not the case, it's usually in sectors where Chinese companies don't have full access to the Chinese market either. If Facebook or Google were Chinese companies but hosted the same content, do you think they'd be allowed inside the Great Firewall? Actually, we don't need to guess: when Qihoo 360 tried to provide censored access to Western social media, they were quickly shut down: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/12/chinese-app-that-let-users-access-google-facebook-has-disappeared.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/12/chinese-app-that-let-users-a... Western companies who don't operate in China aren't shut out because the government treats them differently. On the contrary, the government would treat them like Chinese companies, and some aren't willing to put up with that. Chinese companies don't get a choice.
- bassman9000 6y agoWorse. Up until recently (2020), Chinese listed companies routinely failed to meet oversight rules, with Nasdaq's connivance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holding_Foreign_Companies_Accountable_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holding_Foreign_Companies_Acco... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EQUITABLE_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EQUITABLE_Act https://news.cgtn.com/news/2020-12-03/China-slams-new-audit-law-targeting-Chinese-companies-in-the-U-S--VVjaXGMKze/index.html https://news.cgtn.com/news/2020-12-03/China-slams-new-audit-... https://journals.library.columbia.edu/index.php/CBLR/announcement/view/247 https://journals.library.columbia.edu/index.php/CBLR/announc... In 2015, the SEC reached a settlement with the Chinese branches of the Big Four accounting firms on non-compliance with the PCAOB’s regulation, and the administrative proceeding against these firms was dismissed for four years.[15] Now, four years have passed, and the conflict of regulation remains unresolved.
- BelenusMordred 6y ago> The CCP doesn’t allow the us companies the same. Many of the biggest companies in China are from the US. This is a Fox News tier talking point that gets mindlessly parroted without any logical scrutiny. Hundreds of billions are earnt yearly by US domiciled companies. Google alone brings in $50 billion from China to the US and they have been "banned" there for years. Some others: Nike, Intel, GM, Walmart, Coke, KFC, McDonalds, Proctor and Gamble, Qualcom, Boeing, Lockheed Martin, 3M, Texas Instruments, Starbucks, Nvidia, AMD, the list goes on and is extensive. Starbucks has around 70% marketshare. Have any of the people commenting here even step foot inside China before making comments like "US companies can't compete there"? Who exactly in the us(sic) is locked out again? Garbage social media companies like Facebook and Twitter? Who cares? The world in general needs less of them.
- RspecMAuthortah 6y ago> He unequivocally said, yes. He was willing to forgo their market. US is a corporate republic. The republic that founders dreamed of has waned and frailed from generations of corporate sellout political, legal, media, and business conglomerate establishments. Shareholders will come first and will continue to do so. With 33 trillion dollars debt there is not really any other option left now other than to continue to sail the sinking ship the same way. > We'll see how Biden handles this. I'm sure it's a tough call. He won't. He is just the face of the same old thinking that brought us here. Just like all of his predecessors in last 40 years.
- 1996 6y ago> He won't. He is just the face of the same old thinking that brought us here. Just like all of his predecessors in last 40 years. And it's a good thing. Only Trump was bold enough to entertain the idea of a commercial war with China. I live in the US, but I don't want that. I want peace and freedom. China and the US are natural allies given the complementarity of the industries. Let's make peace not war.
- rorykoehler 6y agoChina needs a new political system before we can talk about anyone being their allies. The CCP have made it clear they are only interested in total power.
- r00fus 6y agoHow likely is that to happen?
- rorykoehler 6y agoMore likely than it seems imo. Seeing the huge amount of discontent and dissent during the initial covid outbreak in Wuhan points towards the system being very fragile with no pressure release (such as democratic elections) in place. This can only go on so long before it implodes.
- alisonkisk 6y agoTalk is cheap. Has MS pulled out of China like Google did in 2009 before they backtracked?
- __m 6y agoMicrosoft is a crucial pillar in the US's political and industrial espionage, they won't let that happen. It wouldn't protect the US from threats, it would protect China.
- baybal2 6y ago> We'll see how Biden handles this. I'm sure it's a tough call. I don't see how he can. I don't see how the next 2-3 US administrations can. If the current level of China's "scare power" is enough to paralyze the US, you will have less, and less options on the table with each year as you go. Time works against the US, and the West at large.
- r00fus 6y agoThe proposal was always TPP or some transnational treaty like that. You know, the one that went over like a lead ballon and likely cost Hillary the 2016 election? Likelihood that this kind of treaty coming into force now is essentially nil.
- baybal2 6y agoWell, what solution do you propose then?
- bushbaba 6y agoYou forget that China also is running up against their demographic clock. They have a very anti immigration culture, and the one child policy means they’ll have more retirees than working age in a decade or two. And it’ll only get worse as given their less than replacement birth rate and substantially more males than females.
- baybal2 6y ago> You forget that China also is running up against their demographic clock. A slightly aged China will still be able to field more military age men than the whole of Western bloc combined.
- thekyle 6y agoI don't know if having a large army matters that much in a nuclear war. I think its more a matter of who has the best antimissile defenses. In the age of nuclear weapons having a large population might actually be a liability since you have more civilians that need to be defended.
- jonathannat 6y agoSo china's aggression in the past few years isn't out of position of strength, it's from a position of extreme weakness. And with Biden continuing Trump's china strategy in economic sanctions/stopping tech transfers/getting companies to move out of china, as well as now forming alliances to combat china, the continuing overall trend for china is decline and withdrawal, and for democratic countries is unity and strength. some recent events include: - Lowest approval ever of China from US citizens (20%). similar decline/rates in other democratic countries this year. That means people are boycotting "made in china" goods. - Japan self defence force, UK aircraft carrier, France submarines, and Germany frigates are now (and will be) patrolling south china sea along with US carriers. - UK and Canada offering citizenships to Hong Kong citizens - QUAD alliance (Japan, India, Australia, US), as well as 4 out of the 5 eyes alliance, increasing activities - Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, US and other countries offering continued incentives for companies to move back from China - Apple moving iPhone, iPads and MacBook productions out of China - Even Angela Merkel, China's most important ally in europe, has openly warned China to open up its markets or suffer. Also, she will be stepping down later this year (THANK GOD), and anti-China sentiments are rising in Germany - US to build anti-China missile network along first island chain on Japan, Taiwan https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/International-relations/Indo-Pacific/US-to-build-anti-China-missile-network-along-first-island-chain https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/International-relations/Ind... BUT. An encircled crazed maniac will do strange things. It will probably do something ridiculously stupid like attacking Taiwan. The attack will fail, and china will be sanctioned by the world just like russia.
- elefanten 6y agoYou're not wrong about any trends you mention. I don't know if my level of confidence in seeing all these things through is as high as yours (especially wrt democratic unity). But the doom and gloom outlooks have certainly gotten ahead of themselves.
- ycombigator 6y agoThe CCP is a dramatically larger threat than Russia has been for at least a decade probably two.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vgchh 6y agoIncreasingly, companies like Tesla also need to figure out how they will adjust to an adversarial China and the corresponding shift in Geopolitical reality. I remember reading that China may derive 40% of its revenues from Chinese market soon. Also wonder if this is already priced into Tesla's stock. That being said, I am also sure Elon and Co. are not sitting idle and twiddling their thumbs. In any case, it will be interesting to see how they deal with this.
- tim333 6y agoTesla seem to have maybe sensibly kept their Chinese operations largely separate.
- chrischen 6y agoThe article is saying no evidence that this attack is state sponsored, apart from Microsoft's allegations.
- vmception 6y agoprotip: they never have evidence. the next hack will be using one of these Microsoft Exchange Servers most likely at a government or contractor's facility/account, and intelligence agencies will say Putin signed off on it himself. its all the information they have, just erase the idea about their omniscience. they are doing the same traceroute's that you are doing.