2 ms·
> Imagine your Asian-American 4yo read who’s just learning to use chopsticks read “A Chinese man who eats with sticks,” with a ethnic caricature to go with it.
by inglor_cz 6y ago
> Imagine your Asian-American 4yo read who’s just learning to use chopsticks read “A Chinese man who eats with sticks,” with a ethnic caricature to go with it.
I imagined it and I felt no reason to collapse on my fainting couch.
What is even bad about it? Is America so far gone that a stereotypical picture of a Chinese man with sticks is considered to be on par with a lynch mob singing "hang him high?"
Or what precisely should be so shocking and horrifying there for a 4 y.o. kid? Isn't it actually a book that has been read by millions of kids, undoubtedly some of them Asian, without unleashing a PTSD epidemics among them?
- pqr53 6y agoI think the bar for child-safe content these days goes a little further than censoring images of lynching mobs, yes. Similarly, I believe our goal in writing children’s books should be a bit loftier than “not unleashing a PTSD epidemic.” It’s not that you’re tough and rugged; no grownups are fainting into couches over this, but some are clearly annoyed over their children’s confusion at reading these books. Why would they do make this decision if nobody spoke up about it?