8 ms·
The Trolls Among Us
- theoneill 18y agoI wonder how this story is doing on reddit...
- emmett 18y agoA symptom of the web being the lawless frontier. Eventually, the law will begin to close in on this frontier as it has on every other.
- pg 18y agoOr customs, at least. The reason trolling doesn't work in the real world is that there are long evolved customs for neutralizing such people, like the idea of private buildings. The first generation of online communities had no protection against them. But these tend to evolve quickly in response to abuses.
- akd 18y agoBut Internet escapism is in large part a rejection of these long-evolved customs. The people who flock to places like /b/ want a place where everything goes. Sure, there will be the equivalent of "private buildings" on the Internet, but there will always be free-for-all places, just as there are places in the real world where typical customs are more relaxed (e.g. Burning Man)
- pg 18y agoMy guess is that as the web matures, there will be some places populated mainly by trolls, like /b/, and that everywhere else will evolve protections against them. I haven't been to Burning Man, but it doesn't sound like it's a complete free for all. Doesn't it have customs banning certain types of asshole behavior?
- adrianwaj 18y agoI just came back from /b/ with a decapitated man's head laying alongside his genitally-dismembered body now seared into my mind. Sounds like a daily hangout for some. I just posted this to my Friendfeed: "A good idea is to have a cross-site commenting system such as Disqus that enables both identity-verified and anonymous commenting and comment viewing. This separates commenters into two groups, those who want to be anonymous and those that do not. The system would not be fault-free, but it would promote responsibilty, encourage better commenting and improve user experience without necessitating modding - one's named identity is the moderating factor. It may not be as fun, but would filter out spam, trolls and junk." Plastic.com has the feature to post a comment as anonymous even whilst logged-in. Trolls would absolutely love this. Also, anonymous comments can be set to hidden.
- jackchristopher 18y agoAnother reason we need to keep anonymity, is that it allows people to report sensitive information, they don't want their names attach to.
- ivankirigin 18y agoFunny anecdote (though I've never been to burning man): There is a very common practice of shirt-cocking, where men only where shirts and nothing on the bottom. A brigade of annoyed burners decided to solve this with a pants cannon. The range was good and the platform was mobile, and shirt-cockers would get bombed with pants and everyone would laugh at them. So, yeah, there is _some_ policing.
- william42 18y agoSo bsaically what we need is an internet pants-cannon?
- ivankirigin 18y agoThat mass of laughing people pointing at the shirtcockers also helped. Community policing with editors that have big guns is already pretty common on the internet. Here we have flag options for the community, and a set of editors. To shoot pants at shirtcocking trolls.
- emmett 18y agoMy experience with Justin.tv has shown me there is a more dangerous kind of troll who will call the police on you, prank call at all hours of the night, make prank deliveries, etc. These more dangerous trolls are mostly enabled by the weak security in our phone system, rather than the internet. Actually, as I write this, I realize that the solution will not be laws (although I would certainly derive pleasure from seeing these people jailed). The real solution will be VOIP; turning phones into the internet. When you can turn your phone into accept-whitelist-only with a click, mass prank calling will be stopped. When identity can be cryptographically determined, fake calls to pizza places or the police will be stopped. So we don't actually need laws; we just need a secure phone system.
- shawndrost 18y agoWow, it would be fantastic to have your phone controlled by software. For one thing, you could apply the same kind of anti-spam techniques, and since there is a canonical phone number distributor, they would be even more effective.
- cdr 18y agoED was having serious bandwidth/funding issues already. Looks like it's down again now; getting this kind of publicity was probably the surest way to kill it dead.
- alaskamiller 18y agoOh no! Where would people find documentation of underage girls and their webcam pics?!
- iron_ball 18y agojj.am.
- eznet 18y agoIn the real world we call them "douche bags"...
- cdr 18y agoI honestly don't understand why this is getting modded up as much as it is.
- SwellJoe 18y agoBecause it seems too obvious, or because you disagree?
- thaumaturgy 18y agoBecause it's crass.
- cdr 18y agoDisagree with it being modded up? Yes, this is more the type of comment I would expect to be modded up ono Reddit. Disagree with calling "them" "douche bags"? I don't think I've ever called any one a "douche bag". A regional dialect thing, perhaps.
- crocus 18y agoWell, one interesting thing about it is that it points out that such people have always been around, and in turn implies that we could learn how to deal with them online by using techniques we've developed for dealing with them offline.
- jorgeortiz85 18y agoAll I can say is: A Clockwork Orange was prescient, it just didn't predict the roving bands of violent hooligans would be on the Internet.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- d0mine 18y agoSuch articles prepare a ground for laws which will hurt everyone. Exaggerating trolls influence leads to a cure that is worse then the disease.
- ComputerGuru 18y agoSorry, I don't see anything exaggerated about intentionaly trying to hurt epileptics to "make them aware of the precautions they need to take."
- d0mine 18y agoHe who sacrifices freedom for security deserves neither </quote> I don't want a political debate here. My e-mail is in the profile.
- evgen 18y agoIf you are going to use the quote, get it right: "Those who would sacrifice essential liberty for temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety" (note the words "essential" and "temporary" in there, the interesting discussion is about what qualifies as essential liberty in this debate and whether or not the safety provided would be temporary or have a more lasting effect.)
- noonespecial 18y agoI kind of hope the father of an epileptic shoots one of these griefers with a deer rifle in order to "make them aware that they should be wearing ballistic vests".
- akd 18y agoWhat's with all the MSM coverage of 4chan lately? Why, of all Internet communities, does the New York Times write about its filthiest cesspool?
- iamelgringo 18y agoIt makes for good TV and sells. That's why the press.
- cdr 18y agoIt's kind of funny how mean/trollish a lot of the comments to this article are here.
- stcredzero 18y agoActually, it makes perfect sense. Agression is the natural reaction to hurt.
- cdr 18y agoOh, it's certainly understandable. Showing hurt is how the trolls win, because that's what they feed off of. And especially responding with aggression, you're going down to the level of the troll.
- vaksel 18y agoWell its obvious what this article wants, for the government to step in and regulate people from hurting your feelings. Seriously when have we become a country of pussies?
- BrandonM 18y agoThat's not the conclusion I got from the article.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- dehowell 18y agoYes, the parents of Mitchell Henderson are indeed pussies. It's unbelievable that they could be so thin skinned about a few harmless prank calls... come on, it's only the suicide of their child we're talking about! Being outraged by a problem is not synonymous with wanting the government to fix it. Bringing attention to a problem is not synonymous with begging for new laws.
- stcredzero 18y agoI've been on the receiving end of prank calls. When I first reported it to the police, the officer assigned to my case seemed to have the attitude that I was just thin skinned. That changed the moment I played him a recording I made of the callers. After that, he was just as motivated to track them down as I was. They turned out to be a bunch of teenage boys of low socioeconomic status. Their only reason for singling me out was my name which they had run across in the phone book. (The listing was in error -- it was supposed to be unlisted.) I suspect that their delight in the cruelty was enhanced by their conclusion that I was a poor immigrant who couldn't afford advanced features on his phone line. I suspect that they were happy to finally find someone "lower" than themselves to pick on. If you've never been the subject of arbitrary cruelty by some kind of mob, then you don't really know what it's like. And if you don't know what it's like to grow up in a society that brands you as somehow inferior, such that cruelty to you constitutes some kind of "joke" then there's something else you don't really know.
- rtfa 18y agoI just had an idea for how to turn the trolling phenomenon into potentially very lucrative profits for a startup. Anybody interested? On the one hand, I don't want to give away my idea. On the other hand, implementing it might take several people working on it for a few months. What should I do?
- Xichekolas 18y agoGive away the idea to several people in the hopes that they hear the idea and want to work on it.
- rtfa 18y agoI think there is value in the idea itself. If I just give it away for free, whoever implements it has no incentive to share the profits with me. If I share the idea, I make no money from it. If I don't share, I might one day have enough time to implement it myself, or run into people I can trust 100%. If these are the only options, I HAVE TO choose the latter, and not share it for now :-(
- Xichekolas 18y agoBut you have to ask yourself, what are you doing currently that is more valuable than the idea, and if that is the case, then how valuable is the idea to you at all? If what you are doing right now isn't as valuable as the idea, then why not work on it (right now, with someone you trust) instead?
- adrianwaj 18y agoThe founder of 4Chan said: "My personal private life is very separate from my Internet life ... There's a firewall in between." http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2008/jul/20/internet.google http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2008/jul/20/internet.go... and here in this article Jason Fortuny calls himself "a normal person who does insane things on the Internet." In both cases, they separate their screen lives with their non-screen lives. But, the mind is the same that moves between the two, except that there are two separate levels of morality that habituate according to the mind's sensory context. So what lies in the mind at the border between the two moralities: shame, fear, hate and intolerance.
- pg 18y agoI find it clarifies things to filter statements like "My personal private life is very separate from my Internet life" and "a normal person who does insane things on the Internet" through the rule: "Judge talent at its best and character at its worst."
- adrianwaj 18y agoIn that case would you say Weev has lots of talent and seriously bad character, in which case his "destroy others around him to build himself up" philosophy is the result?
- Hexstream 18y agoThose people "with a firewall" hurt people in real life with their "virtual" selves, crossing the real-world/virtual border, but I have a feeling they'd be the first to whine if someone retaliated in real life (in a more or less civil way) for what their "virtual" selves did. What hypocrisy.
- jackchristopher 18y agoHumans have a tendency to compartmentalize themselves. It's an inherent cognitive bias. http://www.overcomingbias.com/2007/01/outside_the_lab.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2007/01/outside_the_lab.html
- iamelgringo 18y agoI actually found moot's new robot9000 banning algorithm to be interesting. I'd like to hear more about it. Banning people for progressively larger periods of time seems to be a decent idea.
- cdr 18y agoActually, it's Randall Munroe's: http://blag.xkcd.com/2008/01/14/robot9000-and-xkcd-signal-attacking-noise-in-chat/ http://blag.xkcd.com/2008/01/14/robot9000-and-xkcd-signal-at...
- Xichekolas 18y ago> said one ex-troll Once a troll, always a troll.
- time_management 18y agoThere are many different kinds and levels of trolling. Most trolls are reasonable people who refuse to post racism or affect others IRL, but get a kick out of stimulating controversial discussion or "pwning" others (Rickroll, etc.) in harmless ways online. One of my best trolls, in 2000, was when I hit a Magic: the Gathering forum and started the rumor that the ink on old Magic cards has a 10-year lifespan and that valuable cards would soon become illegible. It's obnoxious and hilarious, but no one is harmed or harassed by this. The fringe, though, is clearly getting out of hand. For 95% of trolls, it's an embarrassing hobby held by a small set of neurotic, but otherwise normal and upstanding, individuals. It's like a video game, in terms of its addictive nature, and also the ease with which the practice can absorb an unreasonable proportion of one's time. Unfortunately, the truly rotten 5% is giving the rest of the trolls a terrible name by doing things that are unacceptable by any standard, internet or "IRL".
- william42 18y agoThere are really two types of trolls and they're completely different things. One type is the person who does rickrolls, feigns ignorance in technical forums, and generally is more of a prankster than anything else. And then there are people who would be best described as terrorists. These are the people who drive teens to suicide. These are the people who send death threats to Kathy Sierra. These are the ones who need to be arrested for harassment.
- greyman 18y agoThe leading photo is hilarious.
- wallflower 18y agoAfter reading this article, I am concluding that there are small percentage of trolls who are literally terrorists - impacting other people's lives in a dangerous way. No remorse, too.
- goodgoblin 18y agoWow - what a great article- I never thought characters like Weev actually existed. Definitely makes the sound of cars passing by more interesting.
- biohacker42 18y agoI remember kids like that from junior high, they push the line until someone punches them in the face, then they have borders. The internet removes that whole punch in the face part, it's a shame.
- stcredzero 18y agoThe self-righteousness of trollers is every bit as intense as those of the so-called "blowhards" that they target. It's something that I recognize. It's just like the kids who used to haze me when I was a kid, solely because of my Asian ethnicity. There is the same insistence that it's some kind of joke. There is the same delight in cruelty. There is the same self-righteous self assurance that somehow they've struck a blow to make the world a better place. It is also something that I recognize in myself. The superiority of the Tit-for-Two-Tats strategy seems to be on the level of mathematical truth.
- AndyKelley 18y agoWhat does 'haze' mean in this context?
- cdr 18y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazing
- eznet 18y agoAgreed. I is funny that the majority of these 'trolls' would not dare provoke an individual in the real world as they will online. I knew a guy in high school who was extremely passive and timid in the real world, but got the biggest kick out of being an aggressive ass to strangers online - I never understood him, but feel that he knew in the real world, there were consequences for his actions, where online he could get away with it with no recourse. Really cowardice in my opinion.
- Chocobean 18y ago
- jonknee 18y ago> As we walked through Fullerton’s downtown, Weev told me about his day — he’d lost $10,000 on the commodities market, he claimed — and summarized his philosophy of “global ruin.” “We are headed for a Malthusian crisis,” he said, with professorial confidence. “Plankton levels are dropping. Bees are dying. There are tortilla riots in Mexico, the highest wheat prices in 30-odd years.” He paused. “The question we have to answer is: How do we kill four of the world’s six billion people in the most just way possible?” He seemed excited to have said this aloud. Wait, is this article about reddit users?
- byrneseyeview 18y agoWeev is mad that they didn't include his entire philosophy: http://weev.livejournal.com/305600.html http://weev.livejournal.com/305600.html
- icey 18y agoFortunately most of us have already seen The Matrix, so we didn't need the refresher.
- byrneseyeview 18y agoI had no idea that The One referred to being number one in the MarHedge rankings.
- mynameishere 18y agoI wonder...how many wall street journal and (now) new york times readers will, for the first time in their sheltered lives, head on over to the darkest [1] corner of the internet and see its inevitable bounty of child pron and mutilation pron and cartoonishly extreme racism? [1] Maybe. There's probably worse... Keep your wsj subscription up, I guess.
- time_management 18y agoThere's a wide spectrum of behavior that is categorized as "trolling", from the obnoxious but harmless to the outright criminal. Rickrolling people on message boards and harassing people IRL don't deserve the same word. Anyone who affects others' real lives has no right to use the "trolling" excuse. It's just unacceptable. Also, the people claiming, in that article, to have made large sums of money from their trolling activities are lying. Trolls always exaggerate their "accomplishments" to absurd degrees, taking credit for others' "work" and blowing the external effects/importance of their trolling way out of proportion.
- AndyKelley 18y agoAs I was reading this article, a song called "Most Terrible Archer" by Joy Electric came on. While it was probably not written about trolls, I couldn't help seeing the connections: Separate your chief anxieties Cut the cord, but you won't Excommunicate from our society Are you bold? You are not Oh no The most terrible, terrible Archer You among the league of militants How little you have learned Tried and failed to be one of the innocents Little left of yourself Little left of myself Little right of yourself
- menloparkbum 18y agoWhen I was in college eons ago I used an IRC channel that was taken over by trolls. Taken over might be an exaggeration... they showed up, took channel ops, and never left. The original regulars just kept chatting as usual. Anyway, the thing I find most bizarre is that the trolls who took over my IRC channel only talked about weird anti-semitic conspiracy theories. The stuff they discussed was exactly the same as what the "Weev" character from this article talks about on his livejournal page. I also had never looked at encyclopedia dramatica before... i guess internet troll culture is heavily intertwined with the white supremacy movement? Or is all the jewish conspiracy stuff part of the joke?
- unalone 18y agoIt's part of the joke. Several friends of mine are active trolls, and in person they're pretty well-balanced. Their saying things like that is entirely because they know it'll offend people.