4 ms·
> The flaw here is that by understanding more deeply what's going on with this analogy, we can learn so much more about the cosmos, like explaining the motion o
by bawolff 6y ago
> The flaw here is that by understanding more deeply what's going on with this analogy, we can learn so much more about the cosmos, like explaining the motion of planets etc etc. By not seeking an interpretation of quantum mechanics' observations, we limit ourselves.
But the sun being the center of the universe is a physical theory. It makes testable predictions. We can learn something about the universe from such a theory. On the other hand, most of the interpretations of quantum mechanics are metaphysical theories closer to religion than science. They do not make testable predictions or allow us to learn about the cosmos. They may be interesting thought experiments but they teach us as much about quantum mechanics as debating heaven and hell teach us about death.
[IANAP]
- intrasight 6y agoIt occurred to me while reading Scott's blog article that a very interesting idea for a SciFi novel would be to explore a future society where are current religions are replaced with these QM religions.
- why_Mr_Anderson 6y agoReminds me - what happened to the Church of String, I mean String theory? IIRC that was the ultimate "nothing can ever be tested, not even a tiniest part" theory
- ojnabieoot 6y agoThis is very unfair to string theorists, who a) are almost universally honest about the empirical difficulties in their field, b) are reasonably exploring the possible theoretical options to hopefully create testable predictions for a future experiment/telescope (science is hard) c) have made major advances in mathematics, with important (and testable) applications outside of string theory I feel like you’re projecting the attitude of one sometimes unscrupulous scientist (Brian Greene) onto the entire field. Although laypeople’s fascination with string theory has died down it is still a vital and vibrant field.
- intrasight 6y agoFor me, part of the "Zen Anti-Interpretation of QM" is to accept that there will be theories that are untestable mathematical models of reality. Testable mathematically - but not with a big particle accelerator.