10 ms·
Maxwell’s gambling demon is smart enough to quit while it’s ahead
- Danieru 6y agoIs a better way to think about the demon that is is "sorting" the particles? The demon may be able to construct a energy gradient, but only because certain particles had above average energy. Yet I suppose the random interactions between particles must result in an imbalance. Thus is, at least as a thought experiment, super neat.
- ToJans 6y agoI don't get it... Isn't this stating the obvious? Let's assume you have a dice, if you roll a six, you get 5 times your bet. If you win on a first or second try, it makes sense to stop, from an expected value(EV) point-of-view. But in most of these systems you cannot stop betting forever... So you would start again when things get interesting, which might be the next roll if it is truly random, right? So the only thing they say is to temporarily pause when you are above EV. But when is the best time to start again?
- gexla 6y agoYou should expect that over the long term, your losses will equal the house edge. The more you play, the more your losses will approach that of the house edge. In the short term, you'll see lots of variance. So, the answer to your question is that you should never start. There is never a good time to start. And there's no betting system which gets you over the house edge.
- saurik 6y agoActual article discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26284494 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26284494
- gexla 6y agoThe article lost me on the gambling stuff. The only winning move when there's a house edge, is not to play. There is no strategy for minimizing your losses (other than not playing or limiting your playing time.) Every bet you place on game with a house edge is progressively dumber.
- slaymaker1907 6y agoTechnically no if the gambler can keep placing bets which increase in size. A winning strategy is to just keep increasing your bet until you recoup your winnings plus some delta gain.
- tromp 6y agoThat only works if you start with unbounded money.
- DJBunnies 6y agoAnd no limit tables.
- gexla 6y agoCorrect, it's called the Martingale strategy. Anyone who doesn't know the name of that strategy and why I doesn't work, shouldn't be gambling. And yet, if they knew that information, then they wouldn't be gambling. I guess nobody should be gambling, but the people who do are the people who don't do the math.
- DJBunnies 6y agoI think you are missing a key element of the equation. It’s not about making money. This isn’t a job replacement, it’s recreation. It’s fun and exciting, it costs money, and we know that.
- ed_elliott_asc 6y agoThis is what I think, I gamble - do I care if I win? No. Do I care if I lose? No. Is it nice if I win? Yes Will I replace my salary gambling? No Has it crossed my mind that I can replace my salary gambling? Yes Has it also crossed my mind to do lots of other careers? Yes
- 6y ago
- kgwgk 6y agoI've not look beyond that but the headline reminds me of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brownian_ratchet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brownian_ratchet
- PeterWhittaker 6y agoMaxwell's Daemon's fatal flaw is that it must consume energy and do work to analyze the state of the system, move the door as particles approach it, etc. The entire thought experiment is fundamentally flawed, the gedankexperiment of perpetual motion imps.
- SilasX 6y agoYep, said the same about this modified version when this story (in a different publication) was posted a week ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26302918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26302918