8 ms·
> This is a multi-dimensional failure at all levels. It's a failure at the Federal level, where NCLB etc pervert education. It's a failure at the state level to
by rayiner 6y ago
> This is a multi-dimensional failure at all levels. It's a failure at the Federal level, where NCLB etc pervert education. It's a failure at the state level to provide and enforce educational standards, and to address systemic poverty. It's a failure at the municipal level where crime, corruption and bureaucracy failed. And it's a failure at the personal level where a mother and son aren't communicating, aren't taking care of themselves.
I agree with all of the above. But I feel like you’re missing a key component, in between the distant federal bureaucracy and the over-burdened single mom. At 61%, this school has a daily attendance rate 10 points lower than Bangladesh did in 2000, when almost 70% of girls were married by age 18 and where, even today, children get pulled out of school because they are needed to work in subsistence agriculture. How does this happen?
My dad told me that he used to walk several miles in his village in Bangladesh to go to school, and people kept an eye on him the whole way. If he had not been in class a couple of days, word would have gotten back to his father. I’m talking here about a real village, where people relied on growing rice and mustard greens and fishing to live. His school house had no walls. A third of children died by age 5. They had nothing, other than a tight-knit community where nearly every single child was being raised by two parents, and were intrusively involved in the raising of all of the community’s children.
You’re correct that a “dysfunctional society” failed this kid. But society that’s missing here is the society of people who are supposed to keep an eye on this kid. Literally, not metaphorically. That social infrastructure has been destroyed—for a variety of reasons, from mass incarceration to social normalization of single parenthood. There is no replacement for this society. A federal bureaucracy with standards and metrics can’t fix this problem, because it doesn’t operate at that level.
- gwerbret 6y ago> You’re correct that a “dysfunctional society” failed this kid. But society that’s missing here is the society of people who are supposed to keep an eye on this kid. That social infrastructure has been destroyed—for a variety of reasons, from mass incarceration to social normalization of single parenthood. There is no replacement for this society. A federal bureaucracy with standards and metrics can’t fix this problem, because it doesn’t operate at that level. Very, very well-said, particularly as your example articulates how one of the most fundamental elements of society -- the immediate community -- should work. This loss of society as community (as opposed to society as formalized bureaucracy), affects everyone in myriad ways that I'm sure we fail to appreciate. Unfortunately, the effects are disproportionately felt by the less privileged: a wealthier parent would simply have sent her son to a better school.
- rayiner 6y ago> Unfortunately, the effects are disproportionately felt by the less privileged Its a tragedy. Lower income people are much more likely to experience this breakdown in social infrastructure, but the least able to afford to lose it.
- greedo 6y agoWhen I was growing up, I had a similar experience of people in the neighborhood watching over me. But my youth was vastly different than an inner-city one. You touched on mass incarceration, which is a result of failed economics. In many of these communities, there simply aren't enough jobs, so low level crime becomes a way of survival. Drug use compounds the problems because it affects employment opportunities, as well as increasing the incarceration rate. I didn't say this was solely a Federal problem, though the Feds have the most money and mechanisms to address some of the problems. The state plays a huge role, as does Baltimore. They simply have less resources, though more accurate street-level information. Issues like this are so complex in terms of factors, that fixing it will take a huge amount of money, time, and attention. And even then, much as the issue is multi-dimensional, it's multi-generational; not just in Baltimore, but in Detroit, Chicago, Atlanta, in the majority of inner-cities. Families have grown up with no hope, with little opportunity for improving their lives, with poor educational systems, with a "justice" system that sends a kid to Rikers for allegedly stealing a backpack. Then add the racism that is prevalent in our country, both institutionally and individually. It gives me great sorrow to see so many lives squandered, and I doubt it will be resolved in my lifetime.
- rayiner 6y agoI feel like your analysis has a huge blind spot. Your analysis seems to assume that the social structure can be explained in terms of economics and government policy. Those things are clearly factors. But whatever money, jobs, and municipal resources you think are lacking in Baltimore, it’s exceedingly wealthy compared to villages in Bangladesh. But Bangladesh manages to have mostly intact local communities, low crime rates, limited gang violence, etc. And that’s because it follows traditional social norms with respect to marriage, fatherhood, and child rearing. The poverty rate for children in single mother households is four times higher than for children in married couple households. For millennials who graduate high school, work full time, and then get married before having children, 97% live above the poverty line. There’s only a handful of census tracts in the US where low income Black men enjoy similar upward income mobility to low income white men. They have certain features you’d expect: higher overall incomes, lower racism among whites. But they are also conspicuous in having high numbers of fathers present: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/19/upshot/race-class-white-and-black-men.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/19/upshot/race-c... (“And, intriguingly, these pockets — including parts of the Maryland suburbs of Washington, and corners of Queens and the Bronx — were the places where many lower-income black children had fathers at home. Poor black boys did well in such places, whether their own fathers were present or not.”). This result is a no-brainer to my dad, or pretty much everyone in Bangladesh, but is deemed a “pathbreaking finding” by the likes of Harvard sociologists. So why do people refuse to acknowledge the possibility that the breakdown in marriage and fatherhood is part of what causes the breakdown of the local community? To be clear, there’s lots of factors in play and they are coupled. The kid who gets sent to Rikers for stealing a backpack probably doesn’t become an attentive, involved father. Mass incarceration, loss of middle class jobs, etc. There are lots of things need to be solved. But at the same time, the blind spot around family structure—refusing to label it a problem that also needs to be solved along with the other things—is actually destroying lives. That’s especially true for lower-income Americans. Upper middle class people still adhere to traditional norms in their own lives: they graduate school, get married, and raise children in wedlock, in that order. It’s lower income Americans, not just in Baltimore but across rural America, where those norms have deteriorated the most. And it’s those communities, especially the women and children, that bear the brunt of these social changes.