4 ms·
The Economist response is that Okta just rewarded their competition with $6.5B. This is a serious incentive for anyone to launch a new company in the field.
by BurningFrog 6y ago
The Economist response is that Okta just rewarded their competition with $6.5B.
This is a serious incentive for anyone to launch a new company in the field.
- bsder 6y agoI have been beating the drum for a straightforward hardware key-based identity system for 5-50 users here for years. And, yet, everything is still a pain in the ass. We were looking at Auth0 precisely because Okta was doing the enterprisy thing. Sigh.
- ezekg 6y agoWhat do you mean by a key-based identity system? I've never heard that before, or perhaps I just don't know that term.
- gnud 6y ago'hardware key-based', not just 'key-based'. Which presumably means that all authentication is done via hardware keys (like yubi or similar).
- stavros 6y agoLike WebAuthn?
- gscho 6y agoWhat's wrong with Yubikey?
- bsder 6y agoThe keys are fine. The system the keys are a part of, not so much. I want to hand anybody in my company 3 keys each (normal, backup, and emergency) and I want them to log into everything with those keys. This is so mind-bendingly difficult to implement that I simply give up every time I try. After you kill yourself putting it all together, you can generally make logging in with the keys sorta work. And then you have to cancel and replace a key that somebody lost. And then you realize all the corner edge cases that don't work. Or, somebody leaves your company and they're the administrator for something on GitHub and now you can't transfer it without their help. And, if you've destroyed the keys, you're shit out of luck. Anything to do with keys is second-class relative to the password flow because that's what everybody uses.
- grinich 6y agoShameless plug - We are doing this at WorkOS. :) It's like Stripe for enterprise features, including SSO/SAML, Directory/SCIM, and more. https://workos.com/docs https://workos.com/docs
- lyptt 6y agoWow this looks really useful. Thanks for posting!
- telesilla 6y agoHave you looked at adding 2FA that isn't email eg Google Authenticator etc. We're seeing lately that enterprise customers aren't interested in email 2FA.
- grinich 6y agoYes, it's coming. Both SMS and authenticator apps (including TOTP via scanning QR-codes). Here's an overview of our approach and technical demo for how the integration will work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQzzlqNAc-I&t=2139s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQzzlqNAc-I&t=2139s Planning to launch this to everyone sometime in Q2. Email me if you'd like preview access.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jjeaff 6y agoYa, I see very little moat for services like authentication. There are tons of other similar services and rolling your own (and by that I mean implementing one of the many open source options is really not a big deal).
- andy_ppp 6y agoI mean auth0 can be eaten that does the default thing (login for web/app/is/tokens etc) without config. For some reason auth0 makes all of this extremely configurable and it’s 99% confusing and unnecessary!
- indeedmug 6y agoI can't find this article you are talking about. I just looked up Okta on their website and nothing shows up.