5 ms·
It's interesting to square: > and was late or absent 272 days And the mother's statement: > He didn't fail, the school failed him. The school failed at thei
by dmix 6y ago
It's interesting to square:
> and was late or absent 272 days
And the mother's statement:
> He didn't fail, the school failed him. The school failed at their job. They failed. They failed, that's the problem here. They failed. They failed. He didn't deserve that.
There's got to be far more than just the school failing here.
- jariel 6y ago"He didn't fail, the school failed him." It's almost ridiclous. If students don't show up, don't care, have absolutely no interest in paying attention, are more concerned with social structure etc. then a top prep-school would have the same outcomes. The blame and externalizations is part of the problem. The teachers are basically heroes. The families, students, communities are completely broken, that's the problem.
- belltaco 6y ago>The teachers are basically heroes. What? Why are the teachers basically heroes for letting a student to the next grade while he's failing that much? And also not informing the parent about it? Huh?
- jariel 6y ago? This line of thinking is really insulting to teachers. Do you think for a moment the teachers have a right one way or the other to fail those students? What would happen when the teacher decides to fail 80% of a class? Do you think that's allowed? Not for a second. And 'informing the parent about attendance'? You think the parents generally care one bit? You think the parents don't know their kids are never in class? What kind of parent 'discovers' their kid has not been in school for 2 years?!? That it's the teachers responsibility to spend 4 hours on the phone every day as 70% of her class doesn't show up? It is the expectation that students: 1) Show up. 2) Paid attention. 3) Don't join gangs. 4) Try to finish the work. If they do those things, they will get an education. Beyond that, it's really hard for schools - a school can handle a 'small handful' of special cases, but not much more.
- threatofrain 6y agoKeeping the parents in the loop and developing interventions is part of the administration's job, especially if a child has been absent overall (as opposed to only not attending math). The fact that this parent didn't know so many things for so long means that they are absentee. But they are holding 3 jobs, and for them to not know also indicates the failure of the school to keep the parent informed.
- hc-taway 6y agoIt is entirely possible the school didn't communicate well, but be aware it's typical for a parent with a grievance to report not having received messages that have been presented to them several times via several different channels. And that's not even considering the ones who'll simply lie (every teacher will run into some of these), but just the ones who don't read anything or respond to phone calls.
- belltaco 6y ago>but be aware it's typical for a parent with a grievance to report not having received messages that have been presented to them several times via several different channels. Sure, but it's also typical for school admin to lie about the same thing happening when it did not.
- hc-taway 6y agoI mean, yeah, that's fair. School admin is one of those things you had some thoughts about as a kid, and later learn you weren't only entirely right about them, but it's much worse than you thought, rather than one of those things where you realize you were wrong when you grow up.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tester756 6y agoI will never understand that logic where people try hard to avoid blaming parents parents are normal people too, they sometimes suck too, just move on.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Why are the teachers basically heroes for letting a student to the next grade while he's failing that much? Promotion policy is probably administrators, not teachers. (There are other reasons, like the lack of apparent attempted active contact from teachers despite the number of failed classes, absences, etc., why the teachers here are not heros, but promotion policy probably isn't something they control.)
- stormbeard 6y agoWhat did the teachers even DO to be heroes? It's not like they tried to turn these kids' lives around or something. They didn't even to the bare minimum of their jobs... They basically just showed up to work and rubber-stamped everyone on to the next grade. Tell me what about this makes them heroes.
- jariel 6y agoThey are 'heroes' because they are trying to teach the most impossible, intransigent, terrible students in a nearly hopeless scenario. Most of them could quit and just go elsewhere - often they do the work because they view it as a social responsibility. Everything they do beyond 'showing up and teaching' is beyond their duty, and most of them do. This whole bit about 'rubber stamping to the next grade' is a misunderstanding of the situation -> they don't have the power to fail students en masse. I suggest >80% of teachers would be happy to 'fail' students if that were allowable. They'd probably love to have classes of 8-10 students which is probably the necessary level of attention required. If teachers acted rationally they would quit and leave - frankly I think they should, let the communities deep problems be exposed for what they are.
- tedunangst 6y agoWhat does "trying to teach" mean in this context? Standing in front of an empty classroom and giving a monologue?
- gverrilla 6y agoexactly. from my experience, it's also the same monologue the prior class would get, and the next one
- prepend 6y agoThey are much heroes as anyone who does a hard job is a hero. It’s quite rationale to stay in a position and get paid in order to pay bills, manage life, etc.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIf one person is failing then maybe it's because they made bad decisions. If most people are failing, then it's not a case of bad decisions, it's a systems issue. It's stupid to try to apply personal responsibility to average behaviour. Groups of people do things for reasons.
- t-writescode 6y agoAnd it's rude to presuppose that even a single person is entirely at fault for their situation. If a kid is doing a job or twoand the mom 3 and he's missed several days of class because the family is literally trying to keep its life afloat, can you fault that kid for not knowing how to read? It's easy to make bold statements and declare the failing of others when you're not the one living it. Life. can. be. hard. To a degree that nearly everyone on this forum especially cannot begin to comprehend.
- upbeat_general 6y agoIt’s truly sad how out of touch HN can be.
- nate_meurer 6y ago> If students don't show up, don't care, have absolutely no interest in paying attention, are more concerned with social structure etc. then a top prep-school would have the same outcomes. Bullshit. I'm exactly who you describe. I went to a top prep highschool. I jerked off for four years, doing no serious work and giving no fucks. I coasted to graduation with a 2.0 grade average, a feat that I repeated in college for my five-and-a-half year bachelor degree. I now have a career, a house, and various other fixings of middle class life because I was a white kid in a wealthy area code, and was thus afforded enough attention to spare me from my own foolishness.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoAnother quote: > “He feels embarrassed, he feels like a failure,” France said of her son. “I'm like, you can't feel like that. And you have to be strong and you got to keep fighting. Life is about fighting. Things happen, but you got to keep fighting. And he's willing, he's trying, but who would he turn to when the people that's supposed to help him is not? Who do he turn to?” Her son is the victim? Maybe that school is not the best, but the student made the choice to skip classes and not tell anyone. He's not the victim, he's actually a failure because he failed most of his classes, and he needs to learn from that and take school seriously, or stop pretending he's studying. Losing three years is a fair exchange for the three years of freedom he loaned from his future.
- robotresearcher 6y ago> He's not the victim, he's actually a failure He's a kid. He made bad decisions. He needs support, role models and being gently but firmly held accountable for his decisions in a way that ramps up gradually. I don't see these things in this story. The school informed his mom of his grades but - at least as reported here - didn't explain the eventual consequences to her. They did not impose the 'natural' consequences of not progressing in classes that she was expecting. There's a communication failure there, a weird policy, and a failure to escalate this case. He was not held accountable for his decisions regularly with gradually increasing stakes. There's also the bad reassuring incentive provided by publishing his peer ranking in a failing peer group. The mom also apparently did not escalate these very bad grades and attendance into a major issue for her son. She didn't go down there and dig into it. And now she is avoiding any overall responsibility for the bad situation he is in. Perhaps she didn't learn personal accountability at school. Certainly she trusted the school too much. Shit is messed up. But we take schooling as a shared responsibility, and that's the only piece of this puzzle we have collective control over, so let's focus on how that can be improved. It's a long game. The kids of educated kids will almost always be educated. Blaming the mom is not productive. Calling the kid a failure is unhelpful.
- prepend 6y ago> He's a kid. He made bad decisions. He needs support, role models and being gently but firmly held accountable for his decisions in a way that ramps up gradually. This is not exclusive to failure. He failed AND he needs help. I think the issue here is that missing 270 days of school requires some detailed explanation. There’s a reason, but having once been a teenager the most reasonable is that he skipped a lot of school. Blaming “the system” for this level of just plain missingness is not telling the whole story. Unless you want to go deeper in that the underlying condition that made it hard for the parent to not check grades in 4 years and the kid to skip that much school without anyone noticing.
- joshspankit 6y agoWith a parent working 3 jobs (probably just to make ends meet), they at some point have to rely on the implied social contract (as dictated by the law): - That the school will teach what they are required to teach - That the school will track absences/lates - That the school will notify the parent if they see that the child is falling behind at either of those Having seen similar cases myself, I can say almost definitively that one of the other huge parts going on here is that at some point the student fell behind and was ashamed to speak up. If no one is being accountable, students in this position can show up every day and still fail because they simply don‘t have the foundation to understand what’s being taught. It doesn’t take much at that point for them to simply disengage and stop showing up. By not being “disruptive” I would argue that they are more at risk of failing as these issues fly under the radar.
- Alupis 6y agoAre we assuming the school put zero effort into bringing these issues up with the parent? All the schools I attended would place an automated call to my parents if I was absent for a class or the day. Mid-Semester progress reports were mailed to my house for my parents to review. If a student fell severely behind, the teacher could request a conference with the parent. Perhaps... perhaps this school did none of that (hard to believe). But on some level, the parent has to actually give a sh*t about their child and their education. Working 3 jobs or whatever is not an excuse to be an absent parent. I'm close with several elementary school teachers, and we've had this discussion before. A parent that doesn't care at all, will nearly always yield a child that performs poorly, no matter how much individual attention the teacher applies to the child. Parents must be engaged in a child's upbringing - they are the primary role model for the child and are the only people that can enforce desired behaviors like doing homework instead of playing video games.
- aaplok 6y agoFrom the article it looks like that information was delivered through a web portal. My kids' school has a similar system and unexplained absences are notified through the portal. School reports are delivered there too, though at least for that we get an email notification asking us to access the portal. Why the report cannot be attached to the email is beyond my comprehension. Accessing that portal is a technological barrier not every parent can overcome. Judging by the extent of the problem in that particular school, it might be a common issue in the community it serves.
- goldcd 6y agoI'm going to go out on a limb, and say I'll excuse the school for failing him, on the days he didn't go there.
- goldcd 6y agoI'm not normally one to get pissy over a down-vote - but "Come on?"
- BeetleB 6y agoWill you excuse the school for continually promoting him when he was doing so poorly? The school I went to would not let you advance if you failed a subject (with a few exceptions). You failed math? You don't get promoted. No exceptions. Of course, my school may have had its own set of problems, but this sounds like the opposite extreme.
- goldcd 6y agoNo - and I'm guessing my misunderstanding is based on "not-being-American". I'm British and school (at least when I was there)'s purpose was passing a set of exams when you're 16 and then another optionally at 18. There were informal exams throughout, to tack progress. Occasionally it was suggested a pupil was held back a year (if they were so far behind, they wouldn't benefit from the next year) - but that was pretty extreme. Normally pupils were just streamed, so they were put in a class of comparable ability the next year. If they did well they might go up, if they didn't they might go down. If you hit an exam in a low stream, you might get pushed towards an easier exam (with a lower maximum grade available) Basically you as a pupil, were never in any doubt as to your trajectory.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]