3 ms·
There's a bell curve on each issue independently. This has been well established by surveys. And therefore however you want to aggregate issues into an axis, y
by crazygringo 6y ago
There's a bell curve on each issue independently. This has been well established by surveys.
And therefore however you want to aggregate issues into an axis, you'll invariably find the political distribution to be normal.
It doesn't have anything to do with how coherent or not you find each party's platform to be.
So yes, it is fair to say that political views are bell curve-shaped. It's not an artifact of political parties.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> There's a bell curve on each issue independently. This has been well established by surveys. I'd be curious to see the data. Measuring agreement is challenging. (Strongly Agree versus Agree mean different things to different people.) And polarizing issues tend to be multi-modal, thereby defying normal characterization. Where one can create an objective x-axis, e.g. with increasing strength of regulation on a topic, one frequently sees non-normal preference patterns.
- crazygringo 6y agoThe political scientist Morris Fiorina is who you want to start with. His book "Culture War? The Myth of a Polarized America" provides a great overview with lots of data. A central finding is precisely that people appear polarized when you measure badly, but when you really delve into their nuanced beliefs with better surveys and more accurate questions, the bell curve is apparent everywhere and polarization disappears. And I don't know where one sees non-normal preference patterns. Regulation is a great example -- very few people believe in zero regulation, and very few in extreme regulation. People overwhelmingly prefer a moderate amount. Of course, whatever the objective measurement is, you may need a logarithmic scale or something else for it to show up as truly Gaussian -- as well as not limiting the range of responses. But on any modern issue of society-wide disagreement, one virtually always finds it to have a single central peak (as opposed to two peaks or more, or increasing/decreasing monotonically).