4 ms·
> talk about things like “autopilot” instead of “driver assist” I actually find driver assist technologies almost as damaging. For example, lane assist (car c
by craftinator 6y ago
> talk about things like “autopilot” instead of “driver assist”
I actually find driver assist technologies almost as damaging. For example, lane assist (car centers itself in lane) can cause the car to veer when lanes are mis-painted. After having it turned on for a few minutes without issues, you begin to relax, then the car decides to take an off-ramp or swerve towards the shoulder.
As a comparative example, let's look at automatic gear boxes vs manual. As far as I know, there are no auto gear boxes that will occasionally require you to hit the clutch in order to successfully change gears. Their either completely auto, completely manual, or auto with manual override. Having something halfway between automatic and manual is just ASKING for problems; that being said, an auto gearbox that is expected to work only 99% of the time also really doesn't exist, which is why self driving is hard.
I'd much rather better alerting and imminent danger capabilities; more ubiquitous and accurate blind spot sensors, lane change cameras, brake alarms (or even auto-braking, if it's high reliability). These technologies will allow the overall self-driving landscape to improve (because there's so much overlap; self-driving NEEDS all of these sensing techs, and needs them to be REALLY good in order to work) and mature over time, while road infrastructure, mapping, legislature, and public opinion catch up.
- brianwawok 6y agoHumans mess up mispainted lane lines also. Have seen many times where there were 2-3 conflicting lane lines painted and people just kinda drove where ever. I think both humans and robots could benefit for federal laws about road construction and lane markings.
- craftinator 6y ago> Humans mess up mispainted lane lines also. Have seen many times where there were 2-3 conflicting lane lines painted and people just kinda drove where ever. That's very true, I've seen it as well. I think the big difference is that humans have the context and experience to deal with those situations on the fly, making choices that a self driving systems just haven't matured enough to make; this is why I advocate for better alerting systems rather than anything that changes the trajectory of the car on its own.
- brianwawok 6y agoI’m sure they will continue to sell alerting systems for many years. I hope I don’t have to use them. I quite enjoy autopilot on long trips.