3 ms·
> the same whitewashing (wokewashing?) happened to the Richard Scarry books which are all "abridged" Do you really have issues with the changes they made? They
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
> the same whitewashing (wokewashing?) happened to the Richard Scarry books which are all "abridged"
Do you really have issues with the changes they made? They weren't abridged but just edited to show both sexes and different races doing jobs other than being maids and housewives. I'm not sure replacing milkman, fireman and cowboys with firefighters, gardeners and scientists is 'woke'
- mc32 6y agoI don’t see an issue with an author updating their books with new editions. I do have a problem if they ban the older editions.
- citizenkeen 6y agoNobody has banned the older ones. The owner of them just wishes not to sell them, which the free market totally allows for.
- mc32 6y agoThe publisher and IP owner I understand. I don’t understand the used book market eBay and Amazon taking them off the real and virtual shelves.
- craftinator 6y ago> I do have a problem if they ban the older editions. I don't see how they are "banned". Banning means "forbidden, disallowed, illegal". The older editions do not fall under any of the definitions. They are harder to get, because the author stopped selling them. You can still find them somewhere, and if you already have them you can keep them, they are just less convenient to acquire than they used to be.
- mc32 6y agoBanned books of the week were also not banned. They actually often remained in print. The bs Ning was being done by busybodies who knew what was right for young children. You’re trying too hard to defend the indefensible. eBay and Amazon stopped the used book market for these not just the publisher and rights holder. According to your take no book has ever been banned in the US and people who complained about book banning were clutching pearls.
- craftinator 6y agoI have no idea what you're talking about. Your sentences literally don't make sense.
- rualca 6y agoIf you're a real person and not a bot, you would be doing yourself a favour by stepping away from the keyboard, tar a break, and thing about what you're writing and how it looks.
- cema 6y agoIt looks reasonable to me. And why ad hominem? At least you were polite; but the argument does not look compelling.
- craftinator 6y agoIt's a normal argument for the time, but it is far from reasonable. The person who wrote the original response to me failed to respond to any of the logical arguments I was making, just spouted some outrage and moved on. So, normal yes, reasonable, no. The word "ban" in this context applies to legal or cultural actions where you make owning, acquiring, or reading a book disallowed. All that has been done is a company decided to stop selling it. You can still get the book elsewhere, still keep it if you own it, and still read it in any library that has it (which I'm sure many, many do). They are just spouting outraged nonsense.
- 6y ago