4 ms·
So can you sell the book used on eBay? If not, and the "blame" is on the Seuss estate, how is that not against the First Sale principle?
by phendrenad2 6y ago
So can you sell the book used on eBay? If not, and the "blame" is on the Seuss estate, how is that not against the First Sale principle?
- tareqak 6y agoIs eBay required to have their platform be used to sell items they do not want to be associated with? Your comment make me think of something else though: I wonder if Dr. Seuss Enterprises would be willing to offer to buy back these banned books?
- phendrenad2 6y agoWell there are two different arguments here. One is that eBay is free to take down whatever they want. That's true. The other is that a publisher can request that something be taken down in the used market, which I think isn't true, ...maybe?
- jasonpeacock 6y agoThey can request anything they want, but nobody has to agree :) In this case, it appears that Ebay and Amazon agreed to the request.
- hbrav 6y agoCorrect - the publisher does not have the power to stop used copies of their books being resold, as per first sale doctrine. You can definitely still sell or buy used copies, although one of your most convenient markets (eBay). But that's eBay's decision, they have the right to decide that.
- dTal 6y agoThe elephant in the room is the contradiction between laissez-faire, libertarian free market capitalism where everyone is free to enter into contracts or decline to do so, and de-facto monopolies where essential functions of society are taken over by monoliths. "Consensual" collaborative actions by large market players have historically been heavily regulated. You're not typically allowed to telephone your biggest competitor and "politely request" that they double their prices, on the condition that you will do the same. That's because we recognize that there is simply a limited supply of competitors, and once a company gets big enough to throw its weight around it has a responsibility to be "fair".
- detaro 6y agoI'd say: The First Sale principle says they can't ban you from selling it second-hand. It doesn't say that can't ask people to not do second-hand sales, nor that people can't choose to comply with that. And barring some other rule, "people" includes eBay here? (Are there examples of people successfully challenging eBay prohibitions? I would assume this has come up before in other contexts, which would give us hints)
- jasonpeacock 6y agoEbay is a company, they can choose to sell (or not) whatever they wish (within legal bounds). That doesn't violate First Sale Principle, nobody is stopping you from selling the book, Ebay just doesn't want you to use its platform to do so - which is entirely in its rights. There's a large number of items which Ebay won't allow to be sold, including souls.[1] [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/soul-listing-policy-ebay-2012-7?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/soul-listing-policy-ebay-201...
- tanseydavid 6y agoLast week it was allowed. In light of this your argument seems very weak.
- chris_wot 6y agoAnd they reviewed the item and decided not to sell it any more. This sort of thing happens all the time. Dicks Sporting Goods decided not to sell guns. What if it?
- esturk 6y agoMany things were auctioned on eBay that got pulled after review. Ie. someone tried to auction their kidney, driving bids up to 5 million dollars and still got pulled. Ebay should do whatever they see fit to improve their business.
- ThePadawan 6y agoI concur, but also: IANAL but isn't Ebay not a seller at all? They make money by selling ads, and charging private sellers to list their items. At no point does anyone pay eBay for anything that isn't a service.