4 ms·
I wonder if the end game of adblocking is simply to proxy the entire page to the client - completely obscuring who you are or where the request originated. edi
by endisneigh 6y ago
I wonder if the end game of adblocking is simply to proxy the entire page to the client - completely obscuring who you are or where the request originated.
edit: I almost wonder if this could be done safely in a decentralized manner. Everyone runs a BitTorrent like service and when you make a request the swarm proxies it to a specific node who then serves the page back to you.
Under this scheme it would become impossible to trace who you are.
- getcrunk 6y agoI've been thinking about this too. But taking it a step further. Streaming not only web pages but apps from a virtualized enviornment .
- bordercases 6y agoThere already exist Linux distros which do this natively.
- endisneigh 6y agoI think this is a better approach than what I described - but how would we make it so the virtualization doesn’t expose fingerprints? With VirtualBox for example it’s possible to figure out you’re in a VM from outside the guest.
- getcrunk 6y agoYou would just need alot of users/be very popular. And then have a standardized vm
- vulcan01 6y agoThe idea you propose in your edit is basically Tor, no?
- endisneigh 6y agoI am familiar with tor but wasn’t sure how it was implemented. After briefly checking the tor wiki it appears you are right. I guess the only thing that’s necessary now is to set it up so that the node could be another mobile client. Maybe it’s possible with webrtc or an extension?
- sbarre 6y agoWouldn't this just create a whole new set of privacy concerns if you're having random people MITM your traffic? Even if it's encrypted, I feel like someone smarter than me would figure out how to do bad things with this.
- endisneigh 6y agoYeah that’s the main challenge. With TLS in theory it shouldn’t matter but not all pages are served with https. Managing self signed certificates would also be an issue.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SheinhardtWigCo 6y agoThe most prolific trackers already require authentication; this approach will lead to every website requiring authentication. Impossible to trace = easy to attack.
- asdff 6y agoIt will be the 99% of the internet in ignorant bliss roaming the censored walled gardens, and the 1% in a constant arms race with ad tech writing scripts to separate the content from the adware and view with their hardware on their own terms. Who knew The Matrix would be so prophetic?
- mrtksn 6y agoJust deliver the goods through the Advertisers systems. I think it will work until we have an AI based adblocker that can identify and remove the parts of the content that are advertisement.
- cookiengineer 6y agoMaybe you want to take a look at stealth [1] as you've seem to understood the real strength of a browser with a decentralized (and delegateable) request system. Personally I don't think the strength of p2p is only trust, it's delegation. If you have peer to peer encryption running, the possibilities are endless. Add a statistical "proof of authenticity" and you have an unbeatable anti censorship mechanism that can also identify in-page modifications and weed out malicious MITMs in between. [1] https://github.com/tholian-network/stealth https://github.com/tholian-network/stealth
- walrus01 6y ago> the end game of adblocking in the future, given sufficient CPU resources on the clients, another method could be browser page-rendering engines that use advanced machine learning image recognition to categorize and blank out ads, no matter where they come from.
- joeyrobert 6y ago"Near-path NAT"[1] has been suggested as a mechanism that browsers can use to proxy requests through an intermediate server, similar to what you suggest. [1] https://github.com/bslassey/ip-blindness/blob/master/near_path_nat.md https://github.com/bslassey/ip-blindness/blob/master/near_pa...
- throwaway189262 6y agoI think the endgame is machine learning based blocking and Apple/Mozilla disabling API's used for fingerprinting. I think Google pre-emptively locked down Chrome API to prevent ML based blocking from working. This would explain their fixed URL block list and removing interactive API
- pdkl95 6y agoHiding every URL behind a proxy seemed like the obvious response ~5 years ago[1] when the popularity of DNS filters like the pi-hole was rapidly rising. The proxy could even increase the obfuscation by rewriting URLs and filenames so every HTTP request to the proxy was just random noise: https://proxy.example.com/ZGQgaWY9L2Rldi91cmFuZG9tIGJzPTEgY291bnQ9NTIgfCBiYXNlNjQgCg== However, the "end game" of adblocking is far worse - the entire page becomes this: <!doctype html> <html lang=en> <head> <meta charset=utf-8> <title>null</title> </head> <body> <canvas>Run the WebAssembly blob to render the page</canvas> <script src="load_webasm_blob.js"></script> </body> </html> The entire page becomes an giant obfuscated WebAssembly blob that renders the page into the canvas tag. The technologies of the open web like HTML become legacy baggage; a "web page" is just a stub loader for what would effectively be a statically linked executable binary that uses the canvas tag as a generic framebuffer. In this "end game", URL based blocking is irrelevant; most page assets become part of the blob. The question "is this an ad/tracker/virus?" becomes undecidable; answering any question a page's behavior requires running potentially hostile code or solving the Halting Problem. Some people don't want an open web that respects things like user agency. They want control. They want the "web page" to be an opaque binary blob that nobody can investigate or modify. They want full control over what the user sees and is allowed to do. They want TV. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10294187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10294187
- Analemma_ 6y agoThat’s not the endgame, because advertisers don’t trust publishers: they need their ads to load from, and phone back to, servers that they control. If they trusted publishers enough to do something like you describe, they’d already be evading adblockers by just serving the ads from the publisher’s page.
- samcheng 6y agoI think you have it backwards. The advertisers can serve the publishers' content themselves, rather than the publishers serving the advertisers' content. See Google's AMP. Of course, the publishers will need to trust the advertisers, but I don't see how they have much choice...
- Seirdy 6y ago> I almost wonder if this could be done safely in a decentralized manner. Everyone runs a BitTorrent like service and when you make a request the swarm proxies it to a specific node who then serves the page back to you. > Under this scheme it would become impossible to trace who you are. This is how i2p works, in a nutshell. Every i2p user is a node in the network for others to proxy through. Unfortunately, hiding your IP and geographic location isn't enough to stop fingerprinting and other forms of de-anonymization.