5 ms·
Do you have any examples of something which solves a real problem better than mature, scalable technologies? There's a lot of speculator money floating around w
by acdha 6y ago
Do you have any examples of something which solves a real problem better than mature, scalable technologies? There's a lot of speculator money floating around which can give the illusion of something being promising until you do the math and realize that it's more expensive and slower than the alternatives or cannot grow outside of a small ideological community.
For example, nothing is preventing paying artists more for music — that's been a solved problem since the late 1990s — but the problem comes back to licensing: people use services which have the music they want and it's brutally hard to bootstrap an indie-only business to the point where you can the deals you need to satisfy popular demand.
- selfhoster11 6y ago> Do you have any examples of something which solves a real problem better than mature, scalable technologies? The same could be said of the Internet when it was first invented. It was far from mature and took two decades, but it revolutionised the delivery of information. Cryptocurrency is revolutionising delivery of cash. It will take a while to work out the development of it, but we didn't have a ready made plan for the internet either.
- zepto 6y ago> The same could be said of the Internet when it was first invented. I see this repeated often, but it doesn’t seem remotely true. Look back to Englebart and the work done at Parc. The applications were very clear.
- nwah1 6y agoPeople were using the internet for useful things from pretty much day 1, and technology adoption curves have only compressed over time. It may have took a decade or two for the internet to become popular, but it only took a few years for smartphones to become popular, or social media, or for ridesharing to usurp the taxi industry.
- acdha 6y ago> The same could be said of the Internet when it was first invented. It was far from mature and took two decades, but it revolutionised the delivery of information. This is a standard talking point but it's not an accurate comparison because it ignores the barriers to adoption related to computing in general. Internet adoption in the very early years was constrained by the need to use expensive computers and network connections. Despite that, in the 1980s many people paid for commercial services like CompuServ, GEnie, or later AOL which were popular enough to be profitable despite the limitations of dialup non-general access because those provided useful ways to chat, research, or shop. By the time the Web arrived in the early 1990s, GUIs were becoming common and internet connectivity was still limited in speed and availability (modems weren't just slow, they also incurred long-distance charges if you didn't have a local ISP, which most people didn't) but that situation was improving. By 1995 or so businesses were jumping online because it had already changed how they reached customers, took orders, and provided support. If you weren't around back then, there was tons of popular media discussion about how this was changing everything — news, education, shopping, travel, job hunting, etc. — and while there was certainly plenty of hype there were also real changes affecting all kinds of businesses, not just people trying to sell the technology to each other. People you knew who weren't computer fans would still be talking about checking sports coverage, trading stocks, making travel plans, etc. because it was faster, easier, and/or cheaper. In contrast, by the time blockchains were introduced computers were cheap and ubiquitous, and software was much easier to build and install. Adoption has never been easier — but only if you make something which provides actual value. Bitcoin has been around for 12 years and failed so hard at the original “revolutionising delivery of cash” goals that proponents switched to claiming the goal was being a “store of value” despite having nothing but fiat value. Despite all of that time and money, if it disappeared tomorrow nobody whose business isn't speculating in Bitcoin would have reason to care because it doesn't give any significant advantage for anything. Maybe we could write that off as an early failure except that nobody has come up with a successor which a) does anything normal people want at a competitive rate and b) doesn't share its problems with scalability. The use-cases most people come up with are all better served by other technologies and purveyors have had a hard time making the case that you should spend more to give control of your business to them. This is completely unlike the early web era, where so many people saw an opportunity to make a business which was using the technology to do something else and were able to be profitable against competing industries (e.g. Amazon started selling books in 1995 and was profitable in that sector a couple of years later despite having substantial brick-and-mortar competition).
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y agoSo that's a "no".
- Tenoke 6y agoDecentralized exchanges allow users to exchange funds without ever entrusting their asset to a third party while other users are the ones who provide the liquidity and take the profit from the fees, again without anyone having to trust anyone else beyond some publicly deployed code. I'd say that at least some of of the advantages cannot be recreated by a traditional service.
- acdha 6y agoIt’s not that simple, however, since the inherent inefficiency means you have higher transaction costs to operate the network and since there’s no fraud protection you still need trusted third parties to broker any exchange where fraud is a possibility. As an expensive way to transfer money to your drinking buddy it works but if you’re buying or selling with strangers those third parties are necessary and still need to be paid. Similarly, you aren’t getting rid of trust: power recentralizes in a handful of users who control the most mining power and the developers (Ethereum classic comes to mind). Very few people have the time or skills to audit that constantly so they either end up trusting strangers or relying on a trusted third-party who ends up being a bank in all but name.
- Tenoke 6y ago> since there’s no fraud protection you still need trusted third parties to broker any exchange where fraud is a possibility. The whole point of DEXes is that you dont need that. >Similarly, you aren’t getting rid of trust: power recentralizes in a handful of users who control the most mining power and the developers Maybe in ETH's case but highly decentralized non-mining networks already exist. Cardano for example is Proof of Stake and has rules in place where the more a pool has the less it earns so centralization is disincentivized.
- acdha 6y ago> The whole point of DEXes is that you dont need that. Okay, so if I sell you a new laptop and you receive a box with an old one, how do you get your money back? Do you have the option of reporting fraud and getting your money back even though I gave the promised good?