3 ms·
None of the white people are presented in exaggerated, outdated costumes. It exaggerates the slanted eyes, the queue, and (in some editions) the bright yellow c
by jfengel 6y ago
None of the white people are presented in exaggerated, outdated costumes. It exaggerates the slanted eyes, the queue, and (in some editions) the bright yellow color.
Compare it to some of the deliberately-racist cartoons that Giesel drew during World War II:
https://reimaginingmigration.org/dr-seuss-political-cartoons/ https://reimaginingmigration.org/dr-seuss-political-cartoons...
This wasn't intended to offend, and I don't know how many people were offended by it. But if I were the publisher the similarities would distress me.
- rufus_foreman 6y ago>> None of the white people are presented in exaggerated, outdated costumes There was a white person presented in an exaggerated, outdated costume in that very same drawing.
- tyingq 6y agoThe whole image: https://smartcdn.prod.postmedia.digital/nationalpost/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/9729098_orig.png https://smartcdn.prod.postmedia.digital/nationalpost/wp-cont...
- refenestrator 6y agoBut it's all white people getting offended at it, and specifically it's white people who never give a shit about Chinese in any of their other culture wars. Discriminated against in college admissions? Erased in discussions of diversity in tech? Who cares. Call me back when we can use you to get mad at a children's book.
- Alupis 6y ago> None of the white people are presented in exaggerated, outdated costumes. Outdated? These cartoons were drawn in the 1930's and 40's... 90+ years ago. They were not outdated at the time. Regardless if we find some of these drawings racist by today's standards - they are historical and should be preserved as such. 1984 becomes more real by the day...
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Outdated? These cartoons were drawn in the 1930's and 40's... 90+ years ago. They were not outdated at the time. They aged pretty f-ing fantastically considering what they could have drawn back then.
- jfengel 6y agoYes, they were outdated at that time. The Chinese had adopted western dress decades before. The queue was dated long, long before that.
- yellowapple 6y agoAnd you know the depicted individual is wearing a queue... how, exactly? There's no hair depicted at all from what I can tell. As for the wardrobe, no, it doesn't look that dated, especially for the time. Maybe the style of it, but conical hats and wooden shoes are both practical and still commonplace throughout East and Southeast Asia, last I checked. The clogs are probably the most objectionable aspect, and only because I don't know if anything resembling Japanese geta was common in China. And further, the whole book is from the point of view of a child's imagination, so expecting it to map particularly closely to reality is entirely ignorant of literary context.
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoAsian with lots of Asian friends in and out of country. Nobody cares at all.
- cambalache 6y agoWell Stephanie and Jaydren in Portland care a lot thank you very much.
- jfengel 6y agoAnd honestly, it's not about that. It's about how Americans present the Chinese to each other. We have a history of abusing minorities, and one of the ways we do that is through presenting demeaning images of them. I'm sure that actual Chinese people have more to worry about -- though the black people living in America definitely have current fears from people living up to the racist stereotypes presented here. This is about us and dealing with our own difficult past that still afflicts us today.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Rebelgecko 6y agoHow out of date was the outfit in the 1930s when the picture was drawn? I don't really know what terms to look up to research that myself so any suggestions would be appreciated. Anyways, IMO the white character's coloration is just as exaggerated as the Chinese character's. "White" people aren't actually 0xFFFFFF. The white character's physically improbable nose length and hair situation are also reminiscent of racist caricatures of white people.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "How out of date was the outfit in the 1930s when the picture was drawn?" It's kind of a stereotype of rural farmers in China. If you do a Google image search for "rural Chinese farmers" or even "Chinese peasants" you can still see the same type of grass hat being worn today. Then remember that in the 1930s the industrial revolution hadn't reached China yet; it was very much an agrarian society (much like the US a century before then) and nearly everybody was a farmer like that. Is Dr. Seuss's cartoon offensive? Meh, it just feels dated and out of touch with what modern China has achieved, culturally and economically. I personally don't find it any worse a stereotype than what one sees today if they do a Google Image Search for "Texan", "Frenchman", or "Englishman" but YMMV. (Actually, the GIS result for "Frenchman" is rather amusing; perhaps Google owes France an apology for being "offensive".)
- yellowapple 6y ago> It's kind of a stereotype of rural farmers in China. Is it, though? The wardrobe seems a fair bit elegant for some rural farmer; I'd expect a straw hat and simpler garb. I ain't familiar with Chinese formal wear from that time period, but if I were a child in the 1930's trying to imagine a formally-dressed Chinese man (i.e. the literary context of that depiction) that's probably what I'd imagine. The white rice contributes to that perception of wealth, too; from what I understand, white rice is a symbol of affluence in a lot of Asian cultures, and brown rice a symbol of peasantry (see also: the Imperial Japanese Navy's experience with thiamine deficiency because sailors subsisted themselves entirely on "fancy" white rice instead of brown: https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/japanese-curry-history https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/japanese-curry-history). The Chinese man's presentation alongside a formally-dressed magician contributes further to that interpretation.