2 ms·
> When society is perfected and true communism is achieved, the state is unnecessary. I mean, "the public" still has to make decisions on the allocation of res
by throwaway894345 6y ago
> When society is perfected and true communism is achieved, the state is unnecessary.
I mean, "the public" still has to make decisions on the allocation of resources, goods, etc. Is the idea that every little decision is put before the whole community to vote on? Everyone spends all day voting on everything? Even assuming the Magic Wand of Communism absolves us of our selfish tendencies, is it also going to make us all experts in medicine, energy, engineering, etc? Or do we regress to agrarianism or worse? If the answer is "we elect people to manage our medicine, energy, engineering, etc", how does that differ from a state?
I understand this isn't your idea to defend, but I think there are problems with the idea of "statelessness" even if people are cured of all selfishness.
- edbob 6y ago> In social relations between people certain voluntary social norms will have to be accepted, namely, the obligation to fulfill a freely accepted agreement. Anarchism is not no government. Anarchism is self-government (or its equivalent, self-administration). Self-government means self-discipline. The alternative to self-discipline is enforced obedience imposed by rulers over their subjects. To avoid this, the members of every association freely make the rules of their association and agree to abide by the rules they themselves make. Those who refuse to live up to their responsibility to honor a voluntary agreement shall be deprived of its benefits. > Punishment for violation of agreements is balanced by the inalienable right to secede. The right of groups and individuals to choose their own forms of association is, according to Bakunin, the most important of all political rights. The abrogation of this right leads to the reintroduction of tyranny. You cannot secede from a jail. Secession will not paralyze the association. People with strong, overriding common interests will cooperate. Those who stand more to lose by seceding will compromise their differences. Those who have little or nothing in common with the collectivity will not hurt the association by seceding, but will, on the contrary, eliminate a source of friction, thereby promoting general harmony. This the most reasonable-sounding explanation of the concept of "free association" in anarchism and communism. It definitely glosses over the lessons of much of human history. https://web.archive.org/web/19980206141952/http://flag.blackened.net/liberty/miscon.html https://web.archive.org/web/19980206141952/http://flag.black...