3 ms·
> They were already gifted many billions of dollars in the past for this same basic purpose but they pocketed the money. Very little government money has been
by rayiner 6y ago
> They were already gifted many billions of dollars in the past for this same basic purpose but they pocketed the money.
Very little government money has been spent on broadband. Federal funding for broadband dates back only to the Obama administration. And cable companies have largely not received this money. You’re thinking of something else.
- chromaton 6y agoTo avoid another repeated thread, just read this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556 I just realized that you were posting on that thread as well.
- rayiner 6y agoWhatever conclusions you reach from the points made in that thread, there is an important additional point here. That thread is talking about telephone companies. OP is talking about cable. We tend to think of both of them as just “broadband” today, but the regulatory structure is totally different. The central premise of the notion that telephone companies received “billions of dollars from the government” is that the government lifted rate regulation on telephone companies in the 1990s. Rate regulation told the companies what they could charge for local phone service. The argument is that phone companies made $200 billion more than they would have had had those regulations remained in place. I disagree with that assertion for phone companies, as addressed in the thread above. But even on its own merits that argument is not applicable to cable companies. Cable companies weren’t rate regulated (except that in some places there is a regulated minimum television service they must provide at a government-specified price). There was no government action in the 1990s that contemplated subsidies to create incentives for cable companies to build fiber.
- greedo 6y agoI think the Telecommunications Act of 1996 was supposed to help improve Internet access through its Universal Service provision. Of course all the telecoms pocketed the money and didn't do shit. https://www.fcc.gov/general/universal-service https://www.fcc.gov/general/universal-service
- rayiner 6y agoThe 1996 telecom act had an unfunded statement of policy to that end. But the universal service fund wasn’t used for broadband until 2013: https://connectednation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/caf_ph12013_fundingawards_final.pdf https://connectednation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/caf_p.... Larger carriers weren’t covered until 2015. And it has not been a lot of money: https://www.telecompetitor.com/ahead-of-rdof-caf-lives-on-as-carriers-opt-for-seventh-year-of-support/ https://www.telecompetitor.com/ahead-of-rdof-caf-lives-on-as... > AT&T and CenturyLink accepted all funding for all states for which they accepted CAF funding. For AT&T, seventh year CAF funding totals approximately $427 million for 18 states. For CenturyLink, the total seventh year funding totals approximately $503 million for 33 states. Over 7 years, AT&T has received half a billion dollars from the feds. That’s not a lot of money for building fiber. In rural high cost areas, where that money is supposed to be targeted, that might be like 20,000 homes. AT&T spends over $10 billion per year on wireline upgrades and maintenance: https://www.fiercetelecom.com/telecom/at-t-dedicates-40-40b-capex-budget-to-wireline-wireless-business-services https://www.fiercetelecom.com/telecom/at-t-dedicates-40-40b-... ($16 billion in 2017). Over that 7 year period you’re talking $100+ billion in investment from AT&T versus $0.5 billion from the feds. Do you see why that money hasn’t moved the needle at all? To my knowledge, Comcast has never received universal service fund (now called the connect America fund) money. We can argue about whether universal service money has been used efficiently. But the idea that companies like Comcast received billions of dollars from the feds to build fiber everywhere is a very Trumpian misrepresentation (taking something with a tiny grain of truth and spinning it into a tall tale).
- Retric 6y agoYour numbers are misleading. “On October 27, 2011, the FCC approved a six-year transfer process that would transition the money from the Universal Service Fund High-Cost Program into the new $4.5 billion a year Connect America Fund, effectively putting an end to the USF High-Cost Fund by 2018.“ “In March 2014, the FCC approved "Phase II" of the transition to the Connect America Fund, adding $1.8 billion a year in funding.” What’s important to realize is these subsides ends up providing paying customers to these companies. As such they don’t need to cover 100% of the cost of connections only the subset of that cost that wouldn’t be covered by monthly fees.