3 ms·
Is the main spar counted as a single component?
by HPsquared 6y ago
Is the main spar counted as a single component?
- WalterBright 6y agoThe main spar structure is redundant.
- HPsquared 6y agoIt's tolerant of random failure of individual components, yes, but the entire spar could fail under an overload condition. For this failure mode, the only way to ensure a suitably low failure rate is by setting an appropriate safety factor.
- WalterBright 6y ago> but the entire spar could fail under an overload condition. Each component individually is designed at 150% of the maximum load ever expected. The spar has redundant components. Any part of the spar can crack all the way through, and it will still fly safely.
- HPsquared 6y agoRedundancy protects against some failure modes (e.g. unrevealed fatigue cracking) but not overload, which is a common-mode failure that doesn't care about redundancy if the load is high enough. It becomes a matter of "probability of exceedance". Electrical/mechanical systems are different and can usually be separated/segregated etc, but there is only one structure.
- weaksauce 6y agoThere was a famous crash where the pilot flew through some wake turbulence and caused the tail to fall off by improper rudder inputs. at a certain point there is only one of something.
- WalterBright 6y agoThe rudder structure is redundant as well. That particular accident was caused by unexpectedly high loads on the rudder, not a lack of redundancy.