8 ms·
The thing seems a bit silly. Curious what was offensive I found the books are on youtube and I'm guessing it's drawing Chinese https://youtu.be/Vl6wD6EGOVk?t=2
by tim333 6y ago
The thing seems a bit silly.
Curious what was offensive I found the books are on youtube and I'm guessing it's drawing Chinese https://youtu.be/Vl6wD6EGOVk?t=228 https://youtu.be/Vl6wD6EGOVk?t=228 and tribal Africans https://youtu.be/Vl6wD6EGOVk?t=519 https://youtu.be/Vl6wD6EGOVk?t=519 looking like cartoon versions of those. Does this means cartoon caricatures are only acceptable if they are of white westerners?
I mean I can understand the publishers thinking they may get in trouble and it's easier to drop those lines but the thing seems to be getting a bit out of hand.
- offby37years 6y agoYes. When only whites can be racist, only whites can be caricatured.
- emptysongglass 6y agoNot only whites can be racist. Any race in power, anywhere, becomes the new "white man" when powers are tipped. There is nothing fundamental to your skin color: all of us bear the seeds of our future cruelty. And until we address desire and deconstitute it atom by atom, none of us will ever be free.
- Dig1t 6y agoI don't understand the need for the "in power" qualification. It specifically is saying that discrimination based on race is not racist unless they are the majority. So does this mean that if an asian man murders a black man, specifically because he is black, that this is not racism? I honestly don't get it.
- bopbeepboop 6y agoIt’s just a language game some racists invented to deny their racism. You don’t get it because it’s wrong.
- nerdponx 6y agoI don't understand the need for the "in power" qualification. It specifically is saying that discrimination based on race is not racist unless they are the majority. In a time and place where a local hegemonic group has a history of bigotry towards and/or oppression of a local minority or disempowered group, it could be argued that the hegemonic group has a greater moral authority to be sensitive to the oppressed/disempowered group. I believe that's a big part of the moral reasoning that is applied in these cases. There is a logic to it that goes further and has more integrity than than "people just want to take other people down".
- medicineman 6y ago>I honestly don't get it Because you are honest you wont get it.
- madeofpalk 6y agoWhat it’s saying is that a huge part of the -isms is the imbalance of power and how that is abused.
- pseudalopex 6y agoSome people call any discrimination discrimination and systemic discrimination racism. Some people call any discrimination racism and don't talk much about systemic discrimination. People in group 2 think people in group 1 mean it's impossible to discriminate against someone in the majority. But they don't. People in group 1 think people in group 2 mean systemic discrimination doesn't exist. But not all of them do. Some people in group 2 say people in group 1 should come up with a new word for systemic discrimination. But people in group 1 don't bother because it wouldn't change what people believe.
- anon_tor_12345 6y agoWhy do people always get tripped up on this. Racism is institutional and prejudice is personal. No one is saying an arbitrary person can't be prejudiced - ask the right people and you'll get an earful about how prejudiced x ethnicity is against y ethnicity. But a powerless group can't be racist because they don't control any institutions; for example there's no coordinated group of black landlords that don't rent to Asians. Would there exist such a thing if there were enough black landlords? Maybe. No one is denying that anyone can be cruel and hateful. What people do deny is that certain ethnicities have the same means to enact that cruelty. Again I don't see how this isn't manifestly obviously true.
- f1refly 6y ago> But a powerless group can't be racist because they don't control any institutions So when a black women walks up at you and punches you in the face because you're white and she hates white people that's not racist?
- anon_tor_12345 6y agoI'm at a loss. You're basically asking me to repeat what I already wrote. The answer is yes that's not racist it's prejudiced.
- f1refly 6y agoYes, I'm asking you to repeat it because what you're saying is absolutely insane and completely detached from the rest of the world. You might check the definition other people around you are using, I'll even give you a handy link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism
- ModernMech 6y agoFrom your link, emphasis added: "Today, some scholars of racism prefer to use the concept in the plural racisms, in order to emphasize its many different forms that do not easily fall under a single definition. They also argue that different forms of racism have characterized different historical periods and geographical areas.[24] Garner (2009: p. 11) summarizes different existing definitions of racism and identifies three common elements contained in those definitions of racism. First, a historical, hierarchical power relationship between groups; second, a set of ideas (an ideology) about racial differences; and, third, discriminatory actions (practices).[13]" This is exactly what the OP is talking about -- they are pointing out that some forms of racism are worse than others, and one thing that makes one form of racism worse than other forms is when there's a power imbalance that historically has resulted in the oppression of one group. Two individuals in a marginalized group getting into a scuff over an issue of race is one kind of racism, yes, but the damage is localized between themselves. One group of people, from a position of power an authority, subjugating and oppressing another group of people over an issue of race is a completely different matter.
- flippinburgers 6y agoDiscrimination based on race is racism regardless of who the perpetrator is.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jfengel 6y agoThey're not just cartoons. They're caricatures associated with racist tropes, which have been used in conjunction with discrimination and even violence. The African pictures in particular look like minstrel shows, which were deliberately intended to demean black people in America. It's not that the publishers were afraid of getting in trouble. It's that they were ashamed of their own book -- with good reason.
- jjcon 6y ago> which were deliberately intended to demean black people in America So if someone makes caricatures to demean the irish should we ban those? Seems pretty ridiculous...
- bitdizzy 6y agoYes.
- hpen 6y agoAnd maybe we should ban free speech too huh? That way nobody will ever get their feelings hurt.
- f1refly 6y agoIs there _anything_ that you wouldn't ban because it could offend some paper-skinned postgraduates? Am I still allowed to read Asterix?
- bitdizzy 6y agoNo one is barred from reading these books.
- f1refly 6y agoSure, anyone can read the books. Just buy them. You just have to open your own bookstore, your own rental operation for the building its in and your own payment processor. Also your own supplier, publisher and hosting provider for the company website residing in your own datacenter wired up by your own isp. Noone can claim he's being censored, it's not the government after all ;)
- krrrh 6y ago> Does this means cartoon caricatures are only acceptable if they are of white westerners? They cancelled Apu from the Simpson’s without understanding that his presence on the show demonstrated a mainstreaming of Indian immigrants, in a similar way that the uncanceled Groundskeeper Willie, Mayor Quimby, and McBain demonstrate the mainstream acceptance of Scottish, Irish, and Austrian immigrants.
- yerwhat01010 6y agoI watched The Simpsons religiously growing up and I never realised Mayor Quimby is supposed to be an Irish immigrant. Where is that established? He doesn't have an Irish accent.
- UncleMeat 6y agoDidn't the Simpsons continue using Apu? The documentary also explicitly discusses the "mainstreaming of Indian immigrants". It isn't something that is just ignored or missed.
- justin66 6y ago> They cancelled Apu from the Simpson’s without understanding that his presence on the show demonstrated a mainstreaming of Indian immigrants, in a similar way that the uncanceled Groundskeeper Willie, Mayor Quimby, and McBain demonstrate the mainstream acceptance of Scottish, Irish, and Austrian immigrants. The guy who voiced Apu, Hank Azaria, decided to stop doing it. Nobody "cancelled" him. He is an articulate guy and describes why he reached the decision in this interview: https://www.npr.org/2021/01/29/962031274/hank-azaria-on-brockmire-and-why-he-no-longer-performs-apu-on-the-simpsons https://www.npr.org/2021/01/29/962031274/hank-azaria-on-broc... The whole interview, not just the Apu-related stuff, is quite interesting.
- dx034 6y ago> I mean I can understand the publishers thinking they may get in trouble and it's easier to drop those lines but the thing seems to be getting a bit out of hand. But they dropped whole books. If they had changed a line in one of the books and cut out or changed a few illustrations, I'm sure fewer people would bother. Taking whole books off the market because (at least in one case) a single illustration could be deemed offensive seems a bit over the top.