8 ms·
What's tracking in your definition here? Is counting display of an ad tracking? Load of an image on page? Is logging nginx entry for your page load tracking? Is
by izacus 6y ago
What's tracking in your definition here? Is counting display of an ad tracking? Load of an image on page? Is logging nginx entry for your page load tracking? Is responding with correct image for your browser user-agent tracking?
I'm sometimes confused what is covered under this term and I'd kinda like to know where the line here is drawn. What exactly are we talking about here?
- dleslie 6y agoWhen site A and site B are able to communicate to each other that I am a unique individual who has a particular session or sessions open.
- michaelbuckbee 6y agoMy understanding of FLOC is that it would meet that standard. That it would independently identify you to Site A and Site B as a person in a particular cohort.
- dleslie 6y agoThat's enough information to begin to uniquely identify me, along with other commonly available factors; like GeoIP and so forth.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ChrisLomont 6y agoAnswering any packet request from your end is enough to uniquely identify you. How do you propose TCP/IP would work without unique addresses?
- dleslie 6y agoFrom my original comment: > This is precisely the role that privacy-protecting legislation should be undertaking.
- smolder 6y agoIn many cases yes, but broadly, IP address is not a basis for determining an individual. It's difficult to know it's not some other NAT'd user or dynamically assigned.
- ehsankia 6y agoAnd why is the same not true for FLoC? How come when it comes to FLoC, the bare minimum amount of information is magically enough to identify you, but when it comes to IP, you just shrug it away as it being too difficult?
- smolder 6y agoPersonally, I didn't make any claim about FLoC magically identifying people. It does help to identify people, though. IP address you can't do without, FLoC would be additional information beyond that, so it helps identify people.
- dillondoyle 6y agoin addition i haven't heard that google is dramatically changing GA tracking?
- probably_wrong 6y agoI fear that your questions reduce the problem to the point where no answer is possible. Loading the Y Combinator logo in here is almost certainly not tracking, but loading an invisible, 1px-by-1px gif in an email almost certainly counts. It's missing the forest for the trees. The simplest definition of tracking I can come up with is "collect data about me that can (and often, is) used to build a profile of me and my behavior". The NGinx log could or could not be tracking, depending on whether you use it to diagnose issues ("we should optimize this picture, it's loading too slow for too many people") or to profile me ("ID 12345 uses a 56K modem, let's sell him a new one"). But no perfect definition exists because everyone has different thresholds of what they are okay with.
- izacus 6y agoIf I understand FloC correctly though, it sends your profile/tags/interesting topics from your owned client software. So this basically means that if you have a browser like Firefox, it could send a preset cohort set to server that doesn't build your tracking profile and gives you things you're interested in. To me this seems like a win? It allows you as a person to control how your ad profile is built (and if it's sent at all) and doesn't send your data to servers anymore? (Please correct me if I misunderstood the technology.)
- sodality2 6y agoIf this doesn't get taken advantage of by google, this would be awesome. I bet if a random open source project of the same kind were released, it would probably be pointed at as a reason why Google is evil ('see there are good alternatives!'). But because Google is doing it, people are (rightly) wary and (definitely not rightly) calling it evil without doing research.
- bogwog 6y ago> But because Google is doing it, people are (rightly) wary and (definitely not rightly) calling it evil without doing research. That's what happens when no one trusts you. It's human nature, and logical arguments aren't going to change that. If anything, it's a good thing for society if Google burns despite trying to do something genuinely good (not that FLoC is good), because it shows others that there are real consequences to betraying the trust of your customers. We lose one untrustworthy company today, and gain many trustworthy companies in the future. That's a net positive for society!