3 ms·
Oh freaking finally. I've been making the point for years that OUR is about 20% of total (all 16-64 minus ft+pt 16-14) unemployment. I understand that the tota
by WarOnPrivacy 6y ago
Oh freaking finally. I've been making the point for years that OUR is about 20% of total (all 16-64 minus ft+pt 16-14) unemployment.
I understand that the total includes self-employed but it also includes underemployed.
I am convinced that the most important employment numbers are:
People who are insufficiently (less income than needed to sustain until death) employed. I believe that number is much higher than even total unemployed.
People who are critically (less income than needed for regular bills plus typical emergencies) un/under-employed.
Compared to the reality of Americans, OUR is full-on bullcrap.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoTo your point, employment is an archaic, broken metric (from the "before times", when stable jobs throughout the economy were a thing). Jobs are poor indicators compared to a metric more robust and blended, such as income, needs being met or not by income, etc. "Does your current income situation allow you to comfortably meet your basic needs?" "If not, how much is your monthly shortfall?" would be better questions to gauge consumer financial health versus "Do you have a job?" I assume this would not paint a pretty picture of the American labor market.
- jjk166 6y agoEven among those who can meet their needs, underemployment is still a serious issue. There are lots of people over-qualified for the jobs they have (the stereotypical barista with a masters) who could be producing more value elsewhere, and plenty of people working non-standard hours which skew the metrics (lots of people working excessive hours that really should be counted as 2 jobs, and lots of people who would normally be full-time being kept part-time to avoid paying benefits). The number of people with employment that adequately utilizes their skills without burning them out has dwindled substantially in recent years, and while the cost of lost economic opportunity and increased fatigue is difficult to quantify, it is certainly substantial.
- vaidhy 6y agoI would consider underemployment to be a case where people are not making enough to live - food, health, shelter and clothes. Whether the area of work and their education qualification are a match, seems superfluous and an unwanted distraction from calculating labor participation and effective unemployment rate.
- jjk166 6y agoWell how much people need to live is highly variable and not very informative. If you get diagnosed with cancer and your medical expenses go through the roof but you're still making the same income, have you become underemployed? No, there isn't a problem with the job market here, there is a problem with healthcare costs. On the other hand if you were making $200k last year and now you can't find a job that'll pay you more than $100k, you'll still be able to afford the necessities of life as well as quite a few luxuries, but that's still an immense reduction in economic output which suggests deep issues with the job market. Underemployment is a measure of labor utilization. What you're describing is poverty, which is related but not equivalent.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoOutlier examples are kind of the opposite of mass trends.
- jjk166 6y agoNot getting a raise just because you have unexpected medical expenses or taking a pay cut after being laid off are hardly outlier examples.