9 ms·
Reddit: Online Presence Indicators
- BitwiseFool 6y agoReddit is trying to become Facebook, it seems. With all these new and invasive "features" I really wonder how much longer old.reddit will be available. It's blatantly obvious Reddit's new direction is off putting to longtime users of the site, if not outright hostile to the late Aaron Swartz's vision. Edit: I had assumed Reddit's main business model was controlling what people saw on "the front page of the internet" via astroturfing and manufacturing consensus. Anyone who has been on the site long enough can tell you r/popular and r/all are blatantly manipulated by a few dozen power users and political activists. Mainly the AOC crowd, doing exactly what r/The_Donald did to manipulate the site's algorithms but across several subreddits. Outside of politics, people on subreddits such as r/HailCorporate often point out how seemingly genuine posts are actually covert advertisements for things like Coke, McDonalds, Wendy's, etc. I do wonder if all these new features are a way to augment the propaganda model, or if they are merely an aside to get more revenue from harvesting data.
- cyberlab 6y ago> I really wonder how much longer old.reddit will be available I want it around for as long as possible. The new interface is a pain to use, and full of obstrusive Javascript.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wsinks 6y agoSerious question here, I'm noticing that reddit is almost not worth the effort these days, after 10 years of good use. Any thoughts on better forums out there? I love HN, Product Hunt (although that's not really a forum..)
- matheusmoreira 6y agoTraditional forums are apparently gone. It's been so long since I've seen one with a significant amount of users. Anonymous image boards?
- pavel_lishin 6y agoThere are lots out there, but they aren't "centralized" like reddit subreddits are. It takes effort to seek them out. Many forums that are ostensibly about one thing frequently have other topical sub-boards; so you can join a poker forum, and talk about car repair, etc.
- dredmorbius 6y agohttps://tildes.net https://tildes.net by an ex-reddit staffer. Small yet, but decent. Otherwise, HN, Metafilter.
- mariusor 6y agoI'm working on an alternative to reddit, which allows for federated interaction between smaller instances. It's not ready yet, but there is a demo instance up at https://littr.me https://littr.me
- matheusmoreira 6y agoHaving to edit every reddit URL to get the old site is annoying enough. If they disable old reddit, I don't think I'll ever visit it again. The new interface is just too obnoxious.
- gruez 6y ago>Having to edit every reddit URL to get the old site is annoying enough you can get an addon to do that for you, or set an option in your user options (if logged in).
- matheusmoreira 6y agoMobile browsers don't have extensions and I rarely browse reddit while logged in. I almost always reach specific reddit threads via search results in incognito browser mode. Wish these search engines would simply rewrite the URL to old reddit so I didn't have to do it myself.
- he7gff 6y agoFirefox Mobile has extensions; I use it because it has ad blocking. I believe you meant to say that Safari and Chrome don't have extensions on mobile, lol.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rolicia 6y agoAs someone who's been on Reddit for a decade, the amount of astroturfing is astounding. Particularly active brands are mC'ds, coke - but there are so many others. I'm also now convinced that there is a lot of psyop intel type operations that aim to spread their goals via reddit. Either pro / anti a foreign policy position. I think these types of posts could probably easily be flagged and isolated but it doesn't seem to be a priority for reddit. I guess making money and invading users privacy is way more important for now.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoAlso consider that the moderators and admins agree with the kind of messages being posted and turn a blind eye to it.
- nirushiv 6y agoI really wish the rest of the Reddit site wasn’t so buggy. The search sucks and is unintuitive. The mobile website forces you onto the app, but deep links don’t work 90% of the time. On both platforms, the site loads so slowly. If you try to delete a post or comment, the operation often fails with no error message. Sometimes you comment, there’s a long pause, then an error message and 2-3 copies of your comment show up. Pages break randomly on the back button. On mobile, login tends to break context - this is a feature even bootcamp projects have now. I really don’t understand how it’s possible to be so bad after so many years and so much complaining. Conceptually, Reddit isn’t a very complex site. There is a core set of maybe 10 user flows, of which over half are broken on at least one platform. I understand they’re trying to become hot for VC attention and are trying to monetize (are they profitable yet?) I actually don’t mind ads on Reddit as they’re generally relevant and clearly marked (minus the shilling, which is an unsolved problem on many platforms). I just wish they’d make the core experience less obnoxious before trying to add these big features. I didn’t mean to hijack the thread with this rant - it just hurts when the site for a community you really enjoy also sucks to use, and drains the joy out of it.
- ghostpepper 6y agoThe one that really baffles me is: 1) Navigate to a subreddit of interest 2) Start a search 3) The default behaviour is to search the entire site, not that subreddit There's a checkbox there to 'search only this subreddit' which is disabled by default. I am now wondering if there is some userscript I can inject to change the state of that checkbox by default. The fact that such lengths are even considered by your users should be a massive red flag.
- CivBase 6y ago> There's a checkbox there to 'search only this subreddit' which is disabled by default. I've always wondered why that checkbox is even there. Why are they even the same search box to begin with? If I go to a particular YouTube channel, there is a global search box at the top and a channel-specific search box a under the channel banner. That's a much more intuitive layout IMO.
- 6y ago
- gww 6y agoI went to disable the online presence indicator for my Reddit account and the "use new reddit" option was magically enabled when I have only been using "old reddit". Has anyone else experienced this? I wonder if they are trying to push additional users to new reddit or if it was an anomaly with my account.
- ghostpepper 6y agoAnomalies which "coincidentally" align with company goals should never be given the benefit of the doubt.
- wyldfire 6y agoI have had "Don't show thumbnails next to links" set in my preferences since forever. But some years back (prior to new reddit IIRC), it kept getting re-enabled somehow, without any preference changes on my part. I think Hanlon's razor [1] probably applies. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor
- CivBase 6y ago> We believe Online Presence Indicators could be beneficial to some of our communities where we see more real-time discussions unfolding Most communities would not obviously benefit from this. Surely it would make more sense to have this off by default and allow specific subreddits to enable it at their discretion.
- frouge 6y agoThanks for the feature! <turned off> "The intent of this feature is to drive greater engagement amongst our users" => smells bad!
- nerdponx 6y agoIf you do not want to display your status indicator, you can opt-out of this feature by clicking into your profile (on the redesign or in-app) and toggling off “Online. Fuck this and everything about it. This is like Venmo's public-by-default payment history. What's the end-game here? Just indoctrinating everyone into being comfortable with surveillance? I understand the benefit this has for very specific Reddit communities. But to turn it on my default is mind-bendingly wrong. If anything, each sub should have to turn it on individually for that sub, and users should have to opt-in on that particular sub.
- forgetfulness 6y agoReddit is full of bad actors and you don't want to give them visibility of your activity. Turned off.
- RossM 6y agoThis feels like it's just designed to encourage rapid replies, like their chatrooms. I've always admired HN's time-delay on posting replies the deeper you get into a thread - it deliberately reduces engagement but seems effective at stopping things getting too heated.
- minikites 6y agoReddit, like all companies, needs to grow or die. If you're not happy with this change, think about why Reddit needs to make it and address the root cause.
- beervirus 6y agoReddit, like all online forums, will die by growing too large. The root cause is that they took too much VC money and/or they've gotten greedy. The solution is bankruptcy, and a new site that 99% of redditors aren't aware of yet.
- elastolin 6y agoWhich site?
- beervirus 6y agoMaybe one that doesn't even exist yet.
- mariusor 6y agoI'm building something that could help in this regard: https://github.com/mariusor/go-littr https://github.com/mariusor/go-littr It's a distillation of the early reddit into a discussion platform that speaks activitypub. This means that the goal is not to have "one site" to rule them all, but that communities can each create their own and then interact with others if they chose to. An demo instance is at https://littr.me https://littr.me
- oarsinsync 6y ago> Reddit, like all companies, needs to grow or die. I disagree with the base premise. Not all companies need growth in order to survive, or to thrive. Companies seeking highly speculative investment are not all companies. I don't think they're even the majority of companies.
- 6y ago
- pityJuke 6y agoI find it... intriguing that reddit have chosen to update their "legacy" website with this feature. Not very legacy?
- gruez 6y agoA theory I heard being floated around is that most of the "power users" (ie. the 1% or 9%[1]) use old reddit, so if they shut it down there's a risk of all them leaving and taking their content with them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1%25_rule_(Internet_culture) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1%25_rule_(Internet_culture)
- pityJuke 6y agoSure... but they still don't have to add features to it, no? Just ensure it stays functioning to access the basics of reddit, posts and comments. For a feature that is currently on a test basis, and is widely derided (pure conjecture here) by said power users, it just seems... strange?
- cyberlab 6y agoThis is not a sane default. Luckily you can turn if off if you use the old.reddit.com user interface. Someone in the comments pointed it out: If you use old.reddit you will be able to opt-out of this feature by following the below instructions: Click on Preferences>Privacy Options> uncheck "Let other users see my online status"
- PaulKeeble 6y agoThat takes you from Online>Offline to Hiding. Not offline, not nothing or null but hiding. That is very biased and loaded way to implement the feature.
- jldl805 6y agoOut of curiosity... what would you propose is a better solution? I prefer no status to a fudged status, personally. *edit: From that thread: "Apologies for not being more clear about this point in our announcement. When a user has toggled their status to "Hiding" it means they have disabled the feature. Once you are “Hiding” the presence indicator is turned off and no one will be able to see your online status anywhere on the site. This will not change unless you change it, regardless of what device you use to browse Reddit. . Why did we choose "Hiding" vs "Offline?" Well, you're not really offline even if you've disabled this feature, and we wanted that to be clear in the broader sense of the term. We will have an explanation published in our Help Center detailing all of this before we publicly roll this feature out to everyone."
- LittlePeter 6y agoPotential evil use case: scrape the online status of users, get top 5%, figure out where they work, blackmail them threatening to reveal their online history to the boss.
- liveoneggs 6y ago...and immediately got porn spam
- gbrown_ 6y agoIt feels like Reddit is going the same direction Digg did years ago. Sadly for users (but good for Reddit) there isn't a moderately large rival that might have the momentum to capture jaded users.
- johnchristopher 6y ago> The intent of this feature is to drive greater engagement amongst our users and encourage more posts and comments across the site. So, they want to generate more posts and content, as if it'd be a good thing in and by itself. What happens when people generate billions of useless shitposts ? Ah yes, the engagement metric goes up, the ad networks are happy, investors are happy. OKay. But then again: > During this initial phase, users will only be able to see their own personal status indicator. No other user will be able to see your online indicator. This's gonna be a really short initial phase I suppose because not much engagement will come from that :]. Can't wait for the private public homepage/profile with your own posts on it à la twitter and then friending and then we have facebook.
- xofer 6y agoThis is exactly what happens when you optimize for engagement. Usually when I find myself on Reddit, I'm looking for something specific and want to get it as quickly as possible and move on. The increasing level of noise created by "engaged" users makes me more and more hesitant to click on a Reddit link when one comes up in search results.
- pupppet 6y agoSeriously, f*ck "engagement". It has become such a dog whistle.
- haolez 6y agoThe network effect is sometimes a curse. Reddit is the worst UX of a product that I use routinely.