12 ms·
The rise of Bitcoin is a reflection of low trust in the existing currencies. Low trust leads to inefficiency.
by HPsquared 6y ago
The rise of Bitcoin is a reflection of low trust in the existing currencies. Low trust leads to inefficiency.
- te_chris 6y agoOh please. It has almost no use as a currency, it's the rise of an asset bubble.
- Pungsnigel 6y agoStill has usage as a potential store of value and a means of cheap global transfers. My mother in law use it monthly to transfer money to her home (third world) country, which is crazy easy and cheap compared to traditional means.
- Kye 6y agoI can rent a moving truck to get groceries, but that doesn't mean it's a good idea. There might be narrow use cases, but that doesn't mean it's the best realistic way to solve every problem, and it doesn't mean it's worth the cost.
- fullstop 6y agoI hear what you're saying, but it's not nearly as "narrow" as you suggest. Remittances from the United States total hundreds of billions of US dollars each year [1]. Even with what I feel are bloated fees associated with Bitcoin, it is vastly cheaper than other services like Western Union. 1. https://www.pewresearch.org/global/interactives/remittance-flows-by-country/ https://www.pewresearch.org/global/interactives/remittance-f...
- Kye 6y agoThe concern here is power use vs. utility relative to other options, not price. By cost I meant the cost under discussion: environmental and health. How much energy do remittance services use to move an equivalent amount of money? What about the cost to health and the environment?
- shawnz 6y agoThe utility isn't solely measured by the amount of money a financial service can move, or the amount of transactions it can process. If that were true, Western Union would obviously have less utility than Visa. But actually, WU and Visa solve totally different problems with different risks associated, so it doesn't make sense to compare them in that way.
- shawnz 6y agoWho is claiming that Bitcoin is the right tool for every job, besides hype artists? And how do we judge whether the market price is "worth" the use cases or not? Isn't that exactly what the market is doing in pricing the asset?
- cwhiz 6y agoIt’s easy and cheap because it is bypassing all the money laundering, KYC, and other money movement rules.
- flyingfences 6y agoYou say that as if it's a bad thing.
- bogwog 6y agoAny legitimate use of cryptocurrency will never materialize as long as people are gambling with them. The intrinsic value of Bitcoin is nowhere near the current price. When the speculators all sell and the only demand comes from people looking to actually use them, the price will drop by a lot. But, when that happens, the speculators/grifters will simply move to another coin. That other coin will see a similar bubble, and bitcoin’s value will drop even further as people perceive it as “dead” or worthless (as maybe it should have always been perceived) So until this shit gets under control somehow, cryptocurrency is going to remain the exclusive domain of the speculator/gambler/criminal/grifter/gullible. And of course, the world will suffer increased energy usage, pollution, and GPU shortages.
- krapp 6y agoCryptocurrencies and their markets are anarcho-capitalist by design and intent. The entire premise of crypto is that only the free market determines legitimacy through profit and market share. If gamblers and thieves dominate the crypto market and cannot be outcompeted by honest actors then by definition the market has decided it prefers gamblers and thieves to honest actors. If someone wants an economy with rules other than "lol Caveat Emptor" they shouldn't get into crypto.
- shawnz 6y agoIncreased amounts of speculation actually in theory should decrease volatility and bring the price to the fair value more quickly. What I think you are not considering here is that you can speculate both on the upside or the downside. Speculators are only trying to predict the future price, speculation is not the same as a "pump and dump scheme". > When the speculators all sell and the only demand comes from people looking to actually use them, the price will drop by a lot. ... bitcoin’s value will drop even further as people perceive it as “dead” or worthless (as maybe it should have always been perceived) Like you said yourself, if it is true that Bitcoin is overvalued then it would be a good thing for every Bitcoin user if its price dropped to the fair value. Why are you describing that situation like a bad thing here? I expect users would be happy that they can now afford more of the coin for practical use cases, and adoption in those use cases would probably go up more than anything.
- malthaus 6y agoPlease stop those myths - cheap global transfers is not something that needs cryptocurrencies for it to happen, this can and will work within the current rails.
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y agoLow trust decisions are not always rational.
- asutekku 6y agoAbsolutely not. Bitcoin’s value increases because it’s a speculative asset and there’s almost zero reasons for it to go down since it’s not really tied to anything tangible.
- spdionis 6y ago> there’s almost zero reasons for it to go down since it’s not really tied to anything tangible Or... every reason?
- tryonenow 6y agoWell, there's at least one speculator (myself) who is also using BTC as a hedge against an uncertain petrodollar. Metals and volatility funds also are purely speculative assets - risk mitigation itself is tangible value.
- shawnz 6y agoSimply take a moment to see how that argument works with other kinds of assets and you will see how it doesn't make any sense. Gold is a speculative asset that also has some limited tangible uses too. So does that mean gold has less reasons to decrease in price than an asset which only has tangible uses and no speculation?
- neilwilson 6y agoTry it for certain vintages of fine wine. The same as Bitcoin. Over time the quantity available for sale decreases due to loss. People lose their keys and the coins get lost. People drink the wine. Both naturally reduces supply driving up the price of the remainder. BTC is a one way bet, right up to the point where people decide it isn't worth holding any more. Just like certain vintages of wine.
- shawnz 6y agoSure, the fair value might slowly climb over time due to losses, but that has nothing to do with the fact that it's the target of a lot of speculation. The fact that there is some small rate of losses doesn't significantly impact the amount of downside speculation you'd expect.
- ohgodplsno 6y agoCryptobots really believe this? Even as a European citizen, I have faith that the US Dollar will stay the US dollar, and keep value. The Euro will keep being the Euro. Hell, even the Yuan will stay the Yuan. Just accept that you're willing to shit on the planet to make a few bucks, it's fine.
- gruez 6y ago>Even as a European citizen, I have faith that the US Dollar will stay the US dollar, and keep value. Clearly the market doesn't think so. Nearly every asset class is getting inflated in the past year, in the middle of a pandemic no less.
- ohgodplsno 6y agoThat's... called printing money. Inflation is a necessary evil and infinitely more preferable to the alternative that is bitcoin, which gives you no reason to ever use it. Why would you use it at 10k when it's going to be a 20k next month ? Inflation encourages money changing hands. The market has absolutely fuck all to do with it.
- gruez 6y agoIn other words, you're saying that it won't keep value?
- ohgodplsno 6y agoYour $100 today will still be usable in 20 years. Sure, it'll have lost you a bit of purchasing power, but it'll still be backed by an actual nation, have its value recognized everywhere in the world. Your bitcoin will have gone sideways three times, jumped up and down. Could be tripled. Could be halved. Still controlled by three chinese farms who could double spend at any point should it become less valuable.
- dosenbrot 6y agoAs European citizen I don't really trust the Euros or Dollars. Just think about the loss in value If you own money. Even if the official 2% inflation, its still 2% lost of value. And now with Corona they printing billions of Euros and the inlfation will stay at 2% ... sure.