5 ms·
EVs still require nearly as much servicing as ICE cars: they still have suspension, body, brakes, wheels. This article is another in a line of cargo-cult leaps
by HPsquared 6y ago
EVs still require nearly as much servicing as ICE cars: they still have suspension, body, brakes, wheels. This article is another in a line of cargo-cult leaps defining anything Tesla does as somehow inherent to EVs in general. See also the apparent linkage between self-driving and EVs (unrelated, except both are done by Tesla).
Edit: I agree that dealerships are mostly obsolete, but the internet is what really kills them off - customers can now deal directly with the manufacturer.
- bombcar 6y agoI think the idea is that Tesla is showing it can be done - and that might finally break the dealership monopoly, or at least force them to be more competitive.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoEVs do not require as much maintenance or service as ICE vehicles. Tire rotations, brake fluid, and cabin air filter replacements primarily. https://www.tesla.com/support/car-maintenance https://www.tesla.com/support/car-maintenance > Unlike gasoline cars, Tesla cars require no traditional oil changes, fuel filters, spark plug replacements or emission checks. As electric cars, even brake pad replacements are rare because regenerative braking returns energy to the battery, significantly reducing wear on brakes.
- neogodless 6y agoThe real question is "how often does your car have to be taken somewhere for servicing?" Oil changes, by far, are the biggest differentiator here, assuming you don't do them yourself. That's every ~5000 miles (using synthetics you might go 7500-10,000) which is easily twice a year. (Intake air filters aren't quite as frequent but also need periodic replacement, and are specific to ICE.) Inspection is every year or every other year in most U.S. states, regardless of powertrain. Not having emissions included in inspection just saves you money, not the number of visits. Things like fuel filters and spark plugs are much less frequent - many spark plugs go 100K miles. Brakes could be a bit of a differentiator, but really those are something you tend to replace at your inspection, so can be rolled into your annual. Given all that, mechanics (you don't have to go to a dealership) could probably be reduced - places that can handle inspections and anything both EV and ICE powertrain vehicles require could be the norm, with a gradual reduction of the oil-change focused places as ICE cars faded in popularity. Ironically, the trend with EV is that you are more likely to have to go to the brand-specific repair shop cough dealership than you would with ICE, where the knowledge of how to service just about any ICE car has been well-distributed (with some exceptions of brand-specific things, but even ICUs tend to have published information available to independent mechanics.)
- kavalg 6y agoI agree about engine oil being a differentiator. I disagree about >10k miles with synthetics (maybe valid only under ideal circumstances, such as long trips, driver only, nice weather, good fuel ...). For the rest of the lubricants (e.g. gearboxes), I can't really tell, but these normally last e.g. 5 years on an ICE and are not that expensive (except some funky auto transmissions). Air filter is probably the cheapest and the easiest thing to replace on an ICE. Literally a 5 min job (washing your hands included :)). Totally agree about annual inspections (of which breaks, suspension and lights checks are probably the most important). I would seriously doubt the claimed brake fluid longevity on EVs. The biggest problem with brake fluid is that it is hygroscopic and you have to replace it e.g. every 3 years. I strongly agree and sympathize with the last one about being forced to the brand-specific/dealership garage. I have the feeling this has become trendy for all manufacturers to build a "subscription" based business model.
- leoedin 6y agoPretty much all the repairs I've had to do on my cars would still need to happen on EVs. In fact, with the exception of a clutch, every time any car I've owned has broken down its been a part which is common on EVs. EVs still have dampers, ball joints, springs, brakes, wheel bearings, steering alignment. They still have power steering motors, lights, wing mirrors, windscreens. Those are all things I've replaced at some point. EVs still corrode. EVs still have design flaws which mean water leaks into the cabin. EVs still have wiring issues (perhaps more!). EVs also weigh significantly more, which means the suspension has to work harder. I'm sure EVs require _less_ maintenance (especially when they're less than 10 years old), and not having to do an annual/mileage based service is nice. But the idea that they're maintenance free is just nonsense. No car is.
- deelowe 6y ago> EVs still require nearly as much servicing as ICE cars This is not true at all. My daily driving 2013 EV with 90k miles still has the original tires and brakes. There's no oil to change and only a handful of mechanical components. The only think I've had to service is the 12v battery.
- ct0 6y agoOriginal tires? How? Tires don't last that amount of miles.
- deelowe 6y agoThey are high mileage economy tires with a really high treadwear rating. I'll need to replace them this year.
- neogodless 6y agohttps://tirereviewsandmore.com/top-10-longest-wearing-all-season-tires/ https://tirereviewsandmore.com/top-10-longest-wearing-all-se... You can get an 80K mile tread warranty, and you can use tires beyond warranty. Of course, that is in no way specific to the powertrain of the car (unless you're using your powertrain to do burnouts...)
- aynyc 6y ago90K for original tires and brakes? I don't know how EV brakes work, but tires should work the same. Are there any treads left?
- deelowe 6y agoBrakes hardly get used because of regenerative braking. I only brake once I'm below maybe 25 mph unless there's an obstacle or I'm in some sort of traffic that demands it. I don't have a tesla, but I've heard if you use the one pedal driving mode with the aggressive regen, the brakes may never need changing. I imagine tires on a tesla would need to be serviced like any other sports car as they are definitely NOT using the sort of thing you'd find on a volt or leaf. My car came with "special" ev tires that are super hard and are inflated to 36 psi. My understanding is that a lot of the non sporty EVs have similar tires.
- cbm-vic-20 6y agoI do wish other manufacturers had that option; they all have configurators on their sites. For example, the Ford Bronco has at least a dozen options[1] with a handful of choices for each. This is a classic CPQ use case. I want to be able to create a valid configuration, arrange payment, and have them drop off my car at the front door (or pick it up at a local dealer if I must, since they sometimes have to do the last steps of unpacking the car, filling fluids, etc). Even if it takes the factory ten weeks to deliver it. [1] https://shop.ford.com/configure/bronco/model/customize/base https://shop.ford.com/configure/bronco/model/customize/base
- ghaff 6y agoOne issue is that you're pretty much paying list price in that case. Generally speaking, if you're taking a car off a dealer lot that's been sitting there for a while you can probably knock something off. I've mostly bought new cars over the years but I don't think I've paid the sticker price.
- yardie 6y ago> EVs still require nearly as much servicing as ICE cars Not even close. I was just talking with my service guy at the local VW dealership. The e-Golfs that come in are usually there for a few broken things. But the service is almost negligible unless your counting tire rotations and wiper blade changes. And regenerative braking has dramatically extended brake wear.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoReplacement rates of brakes on electric-powered vehicles are probably on par with manual transmission vehicles, if the driver uses the engine to brake. Anecdote, but the brake pads on my old VW lasted 4+ years and 120k km, and changing them was almost trivial. A bigger issue is replacing brake fluid every two years, and electric vehicles are no different in that regard.
- yardie 6y agoSome of the fluids not in a EV: * Power steering fluid * Transmission fluid * Differential fluid * Lubricating oil fluid That's over 20L less toxic, potentially leaky fluid than most current cars use.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoMost cars have electric power steering these days, and most transmissions and diffs have lifetime fluids, ie they never need changing, and it's pretty rare that they leak. Lack of engine oil is a big plus for electric cars, but not a major one when you consider that it only needs to be changed every 15k–20k km, or once a year.
- DennisP 6y agoThe reason both are done by Tesla is that there's an economic reason to link electric cars with self-driving. Electric cars are more expensive, depreciate like other cars, but have powertrains that go a lot more miles before wearing out. As long as these things are true, it makes sense to pile on the miles as fast as you can. Even at cost parity, if obsolescence reduces the car's value fast enough, you still want to rack up the miles to maximize the economic benefit of that powertrain. Self-driving taxis are a great way to do that. There's a climate benefit too. It takes a long time to replace the entire fleet, if you're waiting for people to buy themselves new cars. The more people ride self-driving electric taxis, the faster we lower emissions.
- gwbas1c 6y ago> EVs still require nearly as much servicing as ICE cars Not true. I had a Leaf for 4 years and only had to rotate the tires and put in washer fluid. That's about 1 service visit a year. At the same time I had a Subaru that needed two oil changes a year, in addition to tire rotations. The brakes last much longer due to regenerative braking. (Basically, the motor slows the car down without using brake pads.)