2 ms·
Slightly off-topic, or perhaps more general. The solution to proof of work using too much energy is not proof of work. It's fractional reserve bitcoins / ethe
by eru 6y ago
Slightly off-topic, or perhaps more general.
The solution to proof of work using too much energy is not proof of work. It's fractional reserve bitcoins / ethereum / etc.
To explain:
For game theoretic / economic reasons, people will spend as much effort mining as there are mining rewards to be claimed.
If move to a system that doesn't hand out mining rewards, you still have to hand out the coins on some basis. So people will do the activity of that basis as much as there are rewards.
I will talk about bitcoin for simplicity.
It behaves very much like gold in a lot of respects.
If bitcoin sees wider adoption as cash, that means it will have to support a larger amount of spending in real terms and also a larger demand for real balances held in 'cash'.
Since the total nominal amount of bitcoins is fixed, you can only get the latter via an increase in the real value of each bitcoin.
But, here's the solution: gold was (and is) also hard to mine, but even when gold was money, you didn't actually need physical gold coins to serve most of your cash needs.
Bank notes and 'checkable' deposits fill this very need: they allow to expand the effective money supply without needing to mine more gold. The same will work for bitcoin.
(Of course, only that the banknotes will be electronic, of course.)
We already see some signs of that eg in bitcoin futures. The only way to get investment exposure to bitcoin used to be buying physical bitcoins. But nowadays you can buy (and roll over) bitcoin futures instead.
Of course, every future needs a counter party that's taking the opposite side of that exposure.
If you think about it, that's pretty much the same thing that banks do. Selling futures is very similar to offering time deposits:
With a time deposit, the bank incurs an obligation to pay a certain amount of money later. They could hedge that obligation by just holding on to physical money, but more typically, they invest in assets like bonds and loans, and hope to be able to exchange them for money when they have to pay back the time deposit.
That's basically the same economic exposure as being short a bitcoin future and going long a bond future.
To end the long rant, even if your base currency is gold or bitcoin, you can support lots more money than that.