2 ms·
> Digital files don’t have that much going for them. They store monumentally less information than say, a piece of paper- which contains the artwork on it as we
by lmm 6y ago
> Digital files don’t have that much going for them. They store monumentally less information than say, a piece of paper- which contains the artwork on it as well as inscribed histories of hand, pen, ink, pulp, forest- a dense connected materiality that unfolds forever. A digital file is a pauper in comparison. A file breaks down to requisite ones and zeros well before one can reach the atomic composition of the materials in a physical drawing.
> Digital files also require power to access and maintain, and are incredibly unstable over time as new operating systems, plugins and standards render things unviewable- often within a decade. They are also vulnerable to bitrot and physical degradation of storage media- the stable shelf life of a CD-ROM, for instance, is less than 20 years.
This is pretty much nonsense. The actual artwork on a piece of paper will typically be lower fidelity than a digital version of it, and paper degrades faster than CD-roms. I've dug out a CD full of photos that spent 10 years in a damp attic, and the photos are as good as the day they were taken - try that with photos printed on physical paper. Furthemore, while an NFT is by design not copyable in some sense, it's certainly not vulnerable to degradation of physical media.
- kevingadd 6y agoThere are books printed on paper that have survived dozens if not hundreds of years under the correct archival conditions. We do not currently have a means to do the equivalent with CDs. Just ask the people working at places like the Internet Archive.
- averynicepen 6y agoBoth sides of this have pretty good counterexamples. There's an experimental way to encode data on crystals (using lasers, I recall?) that last a very very long time. The more feasible example though would be archival tapes used in long term cold storage, that also do quite well. For physical medium, given the right storage conditions, you can store film for quite a while, and that technically has infinite resolution in comparison to a digital copy.
- at_ 6y ago>The actual artwork on a piece of paper will typically be lower fidelity than a digital version of it, and paper degrades faster than CD-roms. I think the post does a nice job of countering this; a physical object will always contain much more information (in the Shannonian sense) than any digital alternative could, and that goes far beyond things like DPI.
- lmm 6y agoWhich is to say that it will contain more noise. The digital equivalent will be more faithful in recording deliberate details, which is surely the part that's art.
- ogig 6y ago> The actual artwork on a piece of paper will typically be lower fidelity than a digital version of it, ... I don't know your definition of fidelity, but a paper artwork is full of details and a digital capture of it will loss information. Consider the tridimensional nature of real paper and paints, or the infinite interplay between light and medium. You can't capture any of that information in a digital copy. Also, the argument about longevity is not that clear cut. We can see paintings in cave walls from thousands of years ago, same with stone carvings. Let's see if you can render a JPG 10.000 years from now. (without having to reconvert/maintain it each epoch)