3 ms·
> Okta, whose cloud software allows office workers to access all of their apps through a secure online service, said on Wednesday that it’s spending $6.5 billio
by crazygringo 6y ago
> Okta, whose cloud software allows office workers to access all of their apps through a secure online service, said on Wednesday that it’s spending $6.5 billion to acquire rival Auth0. Okta’s shares plunged about 13% in extended trading after the announcement.
Huh? Generally speaking, companies acquire other companies to become more valuable, not for their shares to go down. And even more so when the acquired company is a competitor.
Why do investors think this is such a backwards idea, and why did the board approve an acquisition that investors appear to be rejecting?
This is extremely unusual and the article provides zero explanation whatsoever.
- Clewza313 6y agoThe default explanation for the share price going down is that the market thinks they're paying too much. And let's face it, $6.5B is pretty toothy. (Remember when FB paid $1B for Instagram and everybody lost their minds?) But apparently Okta is also going to issue 21% new shares, diluting existing shareholders, so going down only 12% means they're actually kinda-sorta up 9%.
- fnord123 6y agoThe shares of the purchasing company always go down as the free cash available is being spent - or debt being taken on - on something at a premium. More explanation here: https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/203.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/203.asp
- shubik22 6y agoI think it's actually quite common for the acquirer's share price to decrease following the announcement of an acquisition. (See e.g. this HBR article from 1999: https://hbr.org/1999/07/are-you-paying-too-much-for-that-acquisition https://hbr.org/1999/07/are-you-paying-too-much-for-that-acq....) One simplified reason for why this occurs is that the management of a company is who decides whether to make an acquisition. That management might think it's in their interest (prestige, compensation, etc.) to lead a larger, more important company. One way they can do that is by acquiring a competitor, and they might even be willing to overpay to accomplish that goal. The board of the company, often appointed by management, doesn't provide true oversight of the management's decisions. In other words, the incentives of management are misaligned with the incentives of investors. Management's response to this theory might be that the market (investors) doesn't understand their business, and isn't properly valuing the acquisition. I'm more sympathetic to the first view, but I believe there's research supporting both views.
- AznHisoka 6y agoThe stock literally dropped a few seconds after the press release was out. This wasn't investors reading the details and thinking "Oh, this acquisition is a disaster, let's sell our shares". It was algo funds that saw something they didn't like, and decided to trigger a bunch of selling. If investors really like the acquisition, they will probably buy more shares in the days/weeks ahead.