3 ms·
Calculation must always be imperfect, though. You can never perfectly calculate sqrt(2). Geometric constructions do presume that you have a perfectly straight
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Calculation must always be imperfect, though. You can never perfectly calculate sqrt(2).
Geometric constructions do presume that you have a perfectly straight edge and perfectly rigid compass, though.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoCan you perfectly calculate 1/6? sqrt(2) has a similar exact representation as a periodic "sequence"; its continued fraction is [1;2,2,2,2,2,...]. That's of limited use if you're trying to measure something, but in that case, conceptual representations are out (where the symbol √ and a picture of a square are equally valid), and you're choosing between a geometric approach where your accuracy is limited by the quality of your tools, or a symbolic approach where your accuracy is limited by how much accuracy you want.
- sudosysgen 6y agoContinued fractions require and infinite number of operations to be worked out, while periodic decimals are both finite in different bases and do not require any operations to decode.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoContinued fractions require an infinite number of operations to be worked out if you want to be exact, but that's also true of periodic decimals. You can terminate a continued fraction anywhere and get a best rational approximation.
- eru 6y agoThere's no contradiction here. You can refine your real-world realization of a geometric construction by eg executing it bigger and bigger. (Or doing something more clever about the errors.) Similarly, you can keep working on your calculation of sqrt(2) as a decimal number, and keep adding digits.