3 ms·
> As such, the concept of "5" does not necessarily exist in all possible Ring-systems. Don't think of 5 as a quantity; think of it as a variable name. The proo
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> As such, the concept of "5" does not necessarily exist in all possible Ring-systems.
Don't think of 5 as a quantity; think of it as a variable name. The proof only depends on the concept of addition and an additive identity (and distribution of multiplication over addition, which you're using anyway); no property of 5 appeared.
> the A * 0 == A * (1 + (-1)) == A - A == 0 thing is built up from fundamental portions of Ring theory. As such, the proof I constructed at first applies to all rings.
To repeat myself:
n·5 = n·(5+0) [definition of 0]
n·(5+0) = n·5 + n·0 [multiplication is distributive over addition]
n·0 = 0 [definition of 0]
Every step in that proof is a direct application of one of the ring axioms; it doesn't matter what 5 is.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 6y agoI see what you're saying now. So to answer your original question... > You don't think it's easier to say... No. I disagree, your way of thinking is harder for me to think. :-) You're correct, but my mind didn't work like yours. But that's the beautiful thing about mathematics: we both are correct. We just had different viewpoints about how things work. Ultimately, it seems like we're both saying the same thing, although we tweaked the formulas to look like the simplest ways for our own brains.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoFair enough.
- dragontamer 6y agoI do like your format though. So I'll borrow it for my side of the discussion. n·0 = 0 [definition of 0] n·(1 + -1) = 0 [definition of additive inverse] n·(1 + -1) = n + (-n) [multiplication is distributive over addition] n + (-n) = 0 [definition of additive inverse]
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI feel like I'm not understanding something. Isn't "n·0 = 0" the demonstrandum? I would have written something like n·0 = 0 [we seek to show this] ------- n·0 = n·(1 + -1) [definition of additive inverse] n·(1 + -1) = n + (-n) [multiplication is distributive...] n + (-n) = 0 [definition of additive inverse] QED (Sorry, but what you have above makes me slightly queasy, and I'm hoping the fuss about rigor can be acceptable in a math thread.)
- dragontamer 6y agoI see. I'm not a real mathematician, I just dabble in it on occasion. And I fully admit: my math professors always criticized my proof constructions throughout my life, so its definitely not something I was ever that good at. I'll happily take your advice however! Proper mathematical rigor is always something I appreciate, even if its something I'm not very much practiced at.