3 ms·
> sounds to me purely like a bashing exercise. For the record, I like the Khan Academy and they do a lot of good; but I still think that's really unfair to say
by chaostheory 15y ago
> sounds to me purely like a bashing exercise.
For the record, I like the Khan Academy and they do a lot of good; but I still think that's really unfair to say that given that the article brings up a really important point (regardless of its style of writing): Khan Academy history lessons are so abbreviated, that key, important points and figures in history are skipped. Why is this not good? One of the major key reasons we study history is so that major mistakes of the past are not repeated in the present or future. Now this is an extreme example that no Khan like outlet actually does, but what if they skipped over Jim Crowe laws in their history of the US?
Going on somewhat of a tangent, reading this article reminds me of this TED talk about filter bubbles.
http://www.ted.com/talks/eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_bubbles.html http://www.ted.com/talks/eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_bu...
Essentially Khan Academy and other ventures like it, may be inadvertently creating dangerous filter bubbles.
- ThomPete 15y ago"One of the major key reasons we study history is so that major mistakes of the past are not repeated in the present or future." And yet we learn nothing from history even when we know what is considered factual. The things we learn from history that are important become implicit part of our culture, our DNA not our curriculum.
- chaostheory 15y ago> The things we learn from history that are important become part of our culture, not our curriculum. How does it become part of our culture if it's not part of our curriculum? Given my own personal tastes (when I was a child), I would have skipped everything in history except for WWI, and WWII. Even with WWI and WWII, I probably would have only focused on the battles and not the social issues if given the chance. I wouldn't have learned about things like the Trail of Tears, the Japanese Internment camps in Hawaii, and so on.
- ThomPete 15y agoAnd many people don't learn about those things because they are brought up in difference cultures. But to claim that some history books are better than others is just wrong. (I know you are not claiming that) You will naturally learn your countries history albeit not to the point where you can become a history professor but it's not the end of the world. History is perspective it can't be anything but perspective. There is no right or wrong teaching in history. Only survivors to tell the tales.
- chaostheory 15y ago> You will naturally learn your countries history albeit not to the point where you can become a history professor How? Through video game blockbusters like Call of Duty or summer movie hits like Saving Private Ryan?
- ThomPete 15y agoHow is Saving Private Ryan different from the US schools interpretation of 2nd World War? How is Call of Duty different than a soldiers account of how a battlefield looked like? They are after all consulting soldiers. I am not talking about learning historical facts but about growing up in a culture that has a memory of a past. Things that naturally flows between people. I knew of 2nd world war before I had history, I knew of JFK before I had history. And I am Danish.
- andos 15y agoHow is Call of Duty different than a soldiers account of how a battlefield looked like? Between a WWII veteran's personal account of the battles and playing CoD, which one would you pick? If you pick the veteran's account, you know that Call of Duty trivializes war. There is a difference.
- ThomPete 15y agoThat is simply your opinion. I don't think it trivializes war.
- kenjackson 15y agoI seriously doubt a history lesson in 15 minutes that covered WWII to Vietnam is meant to be comprehensive. With that said, when I was in school we regularly covered a thousand years in a single page. And in many cases complete eras as pertained to geography were skipped altogether. To this day I don't think I could tell you the name of a single African King pre-1900. With that said, one of the things I still prefer about Khan's lectures, even abbreviated ones like these stated, is that I can pause them at any time, and look up the Japanese oil embargo. And start right back up where I left off in the video. With live lectures at best you can take a note of it, and look it up later, but then other facts that build upon this in the lecture are missed -- and you may not even know that you missed them.
- chaostheory 15y agoI agree with everything you just wrote, but I think you're missing the point of my post. I was just merely giving reasons as to why people shouldn't dismiss the article.
- rubergly 15y agoIf they skip over something like Jim Crowe laws and someone notices, then that someone can mention it to Sal, explain why (s)he thinks it's important, and then Sal (or another instructor in the future) can make a video, and it can easily be incorporated into the curriculum. This process is much easier than it would be to incorporate it into a textbook, curriculum, etc.